Well, that’s a rubbish free trade deal.
I think we can accept that as fact given pretty much everyone who knows anything about what they’re talking about is unimpressed with it.
Meat and dairy have been shafted. There is nothing to celebrate in this for them.
Beef exporters are only allowed to provide 0.1 percent of the meat that Europeans eat.
Cheese exporters are only allowed to provide 0.14 percent of the cheese they eat.
If meat and dairy are not happy, this is a rubbish deal, because these guys are our big hitters in this country. They make up about 40 percent of our exporters between them.
Some with skin in the game will be happy with what they’ve got overnight – kiwifruit for example – but fruit only makes up 5 percent of our exports. So for everyone, it’s actually rats and mice.
The question actually here is not whether or not this is a good deal, because it isn’t, but whether we should’ve signed it. I don’t think we should’ve.
I went to bed last night convinced we weren’t going to sign this deal for all the noises being made out of the Prime Minister’s delegation, and I was prepared to come on air and give credit to the Prime Minister for having the courage to walk away from a bad deal. But she didn’t.
She killed off the chance of these guys getting a better deal.
And there was always the chance of they would’ve got a better deal simply because of geopolitics.
The thing with China is heating up in a way that it hasn’t ever, the Europeans want our help dealing with China, but they know we’re bound to China with trade.
We could’ve hardballed them for a good trade deal to buy our loyalty and give ourselves options outside of China. But not now. We gave them our loyalty really easily and they bought us for cheap.
When you think about it, it takes more courage to walk away from a bad deal than it does to take a bad deal because of the uncertainty.
You’re never really sure because if you walk away from it that you can get something better, but if you’re brave, you take the chance because you know this isn’t good enough.
What happened last night is our people just weren’t good enough or brave enough.
Heather du Plessis-Allan is a journalist and commentator who hosts Newstalk ZB's Drive show.
6 comments:
Well said Heather, unfortunately our Prime Minister again displays her skills at gainning a great photo opp. With little thought of the long term consequences of the action. This time the economic outcome is poor for NZ. The EU can send us what ever they want tariff free, we gain virtually nothing except for onions and kiwi fruit and have to change the names of fetta and port . Thats about it! A bad deal but a great photo opp! Thats all that matters to Jacinda
Disappointing. More about Ardern getting something Labour will spin as a "win" than a good deal for New Zealand.
Thank you, Heather, for one of the most honest journalistic pieces I have read for a long time. You have said what needed to be said without kow-towing to political wokeness, so thank you. Well said in your analysis and conclusion.
Excellent. Mike E.
Maybe our government actually thought this was a good deal.
Their almost complete lack of people with any relevant business experience and negotiation skills must have been a godsend to their European counterparts.
Throw us a few beads and we hand over everything. Maybe they followed what Maori did way back when and took that as the gold standard in negotiation.
The deal still has to be ratified by 27 EU Countries. Canada signed their deal in 2014 and are still working through ratification. What this deal will also mean is that NZ is aligning with various EU rules on non trade matters such as climate change that will put them out of future democratic control in New Zealand.
Only Stuff and the MSM will talk her failure up positively.
Post a Comment
Thanks for engaging in the debate!
Because this is a public forum, we will only publish comments that are respectful and do NOT contain links to other sites. We appreciate your cooperation.