He makes a lot of sense, which is why I love having him on this show. He recently gave an interview where he talked about the fact we shouldn’t have to wait this long for election results.
I agree.
I’m sure most of us do. I mean we voted for a system like MMP which is not that clear cut so that parts on us, but surely the mechanism for counting special votes can be sped up. As it stands, special votes have to be sent back to their electorates. That’s your first hold up. Secondly they’re counted manually. They’re also taking all this time to scrutinize the roll, check for any duplication of votes, recount votes... and bear in mind there are around 567 thousand special votes apparently this year.
But Peter Dunne says we need to speed it up.
He said, “the votes need to be transmitted back to the electorates, they should be counted much more quickly and then those results declared within days.” So days, not weeks, and I agree.
Could they do it? An overhaul of how the electoral commission operates would be needed, and I actually think that’s not a bad thing. I mean on the face of it, the electoral commission seems an antiquated cumbersome old system. Too much paperwork, easy vote cards and voting packs having to be sent out to every letterbox, which were in many cases too slow to get out anyway, and as it turns out you don’t even really need them. A wacky rule around when a candidate dies in terms of adding a seat to create a potential overhang and having to go through a costly by election. Crazy.
But all of this dilly dallying and waiting three weeks means we wait almost a month after voting to get a government formed. All that time of limbo and nothing happening. All that time of a new government ready to get going and sink their teeth in and make some changes but can’t until it knows what shape it’s taking, and crucially, who’s in it.
It actually puts us all back if you think about it. If you factor in that three quarters of the country wanted a change of direction, then that’s three quarters of us stuck going nowhere. Which means the country is going nowhere.
I guess the alternatives would have to be soundly tested though – I mean automatic vote counting machines like in the US could be considered dodgy by some, so however the system changed it would have to get buy in. But surely not sending votes back to their electorates would be one easy fix to speed things up. That seems OTT.
Because it’s not just getting on with it to appease our curiosity as to what formation the next government will take – ie, with or without Winston, but also what decisions need to be made, what changes are coming. Whether the new government has time to enact much before Christmas. Can they get a new mini budget up? Can they get going on their first 100 days list? Can they push through the reforms they want to push through?
Starting a new government about 8 weeks out from Christmas doesn’t leave much time to kick into gear, and as far as I can gather, we’re all pretty keen for change to kick into gear, sooner rather than later.
Kate Hawkesby is a journalist and broadcaster who hosts the Early Edition show on Newstalk ZB.
4 comments:
I gather Luxon and a key team have been working all year planning. The new lineup MP's have been told, stat holidays only, there is (lot's of) work to be done.
Germany also has MMP and I believe that they get all their special votes counted on the night or just after by requiring people to vote in advance.
NZ seems to specialise in uber-bureaucracy and process which slows everything down. It's ridiculous.
There's also the cost to be considered. Not of counting the votes but in the amount of wasted money the outgoing government continues to pour down the drain on policies that will be getting axed.
I guess we're lucky Labour didn't set up a Ministry for Special Votes, along with some of the other pointless departments, employing even more public servants to do little or nothing.
they could count and tally directly and verify after 3 weeks the variation would be much smaller and the way forward much clearer.
International votes would be a little more difficult but planes could get all votes here and again a provisional number could be revealed within a week.
Yes there will be some final seat changes but we get that anyway with recounts but 90% of the 580,000 votes should be resolved much faster.
This so-called counting period is a delay - this gives Iwi the chance to launch its intimidation campaign with threats of violence if any of their privileges are touched.
so, when a new government starts to work, there is already a negative mindset from the people.... or, taken to extreme, outright fear of social unrest.
Post a Comment
Thanks for engaging in the debate!
Because this is a public forum, we will only publish comments that are respectful and do NOT contain links to other sites. We appreciate your cooperation.