"Everyday Kiwis will not be losing sleep over political sideshows in Wellington – they’ll be thinking about their mortgage, their kids’ education and the safety and security of their community."
It suddenly hit me.
He's not talking to me.
A good portion of New Zealanders have either paid off their mortgages or are renting. A great deal more than have active mortgages.
Most voters don't have children at school or uni.
And most people feel safe and secure in their community.
It suddenly hit me that Luxon talks to this small middle ground of young aspirant families who angst over their children.
He doesn't talk to an older generation who hold grave fears for the constitutional future of their country. Who have no trust that the health system will be reliable as they encounter conditions that may be life-threatening.
He certainly isn't talking to beneficiaries who largely rent and have no prospect of saving enough to obtain a mortgage.
He isn't talking to students who face leaving NZ to 1/ get a job and 2/ get a job that pays well enough to make a dent in their loans.
I realise the above statement is just a grab from a presser. But having said that, I've felt this generic sense of irrelevancy before and couldn't quite put my finger on why. Like he talks to the upwardly mobile who go to sports games and cafes and work out in their vast garages.
And it's not just him. Hipkins is the same. They talk to this particular group. Is it their group? Their friends and colleagues?
Or is that the group that contains the swinging voters?
I don't know. But I do know NZ is much, much more.
With his leadership confirmed - and frankly, I'm pleased the status quo and some skerrick of stability survived - he needs to start sounding like he knows that too.
Lindsay Mitchell is a welfare commentator who blogs HERE
Most voters don't have children at school or uni.
And most people feel safe and secure in their community.
It suddenly hit me that Luxon talks to this small middle ground of young aspirant families who angst over their children.
He doesn't talk to an older generation who hold grave fears for the constitutional future of their country. Who have no trust that the health system will be reliable as they encounter conditions that may be life-threatening.
He certainly isn't talking to beneficiaries who largely rent and have no prospect of saving enough to obtain a mortgage.
He isn't talking to students who face leaving NZ to 1/ get a job and 2/ get a job that pays well enough to make a dent in their loans.
I realise the above statement is just a grab from a presser. But having said that, I've felt this generic sense of irrelevancy before and couldn't quite put my finger on why. Like he talks to the upwardly mobile who go to sports games and cafes and work out in their vast garages.
And it's not just him. Hipkins is the same. They talk to this particular group. Is it their group? Their friends and colleagues?
Or is that the group that contains the swinging voters?
I don't know. But I do know NZ is much, much more.
With his leadership confirmed - and frankly, I'm pleased the status quo and some skerrick of stability survived - he needs to start sounding like he knows that too.
Lindsay Mitchell is a welfare commentator who blogs HERE
9 comments:
Whoever Luxon is or thinks he is talking to, the fact is that by his failure to address Maorification and co-governance, issues that are the real 'effalump in the room' and which have the real potential to destroy this Country, he is dooming his and all others children to a future of abject misery and poverty. Why, because it will ultimately destroy wealth, growth and prosperity..
Old farts such as myself are pretty fixed in our ways politically.
Young people, particularly students and those not seriously contemplating home ownership tend to vote fashion, fads or not at all.
Beneficiaries (not already covered above) are far too busy not just demanding even more for nothing but, now, telephoning charities demanding their unearned freebies are delivered to their doors to think about their (usually non) vote.
Why would Luxon waste his time addressing that lot when he can address those who may vote for his Party and hope for thought?
OK, but what about climate change, why doesn’t Luxon fix that ?
Agreed Anon @8.40am, Luxon's 'thriving economy', if it ever happens, will be worthless to non-Maori NZers as his silence lets the Maori takeover continue at pace.
I look at this from a different perspective- is it possible that this is a blip of statesman thinking? In time of crisis the state protects its most productive people. Without the people who work and pay taxes will be no healthcare, no benefits, no student loans?
Some of these comments are laughable. If you think Maori are thriving or elite you’re living in your own private Idaho! That song is a banger by the way.
More than ever I conclude Christopher Luxons foray into PM was about the status of the title. I've seen not a hint that he has a vision of change or improvement or anything.
Today, like last week, he has no better idea of what he's doing, why he's doing it or where he's going. A performative process manager doing stuff for stuffs sake, being that pseudo progressive guy, down with the woke liberal set.
But in a slow motion train crash scenario, Luxons Joe Biden 2024 moment fast approaches because the man who stands for nothing and studiously avoids being exposed as an imposter will be thrust into the daylight of an election campaign. And to me Christopher, it's game over, thanks for playing.
Hold on "Comrades" - this is the gent who told NZ that we need people to come to this Country with $5 mill, to buy houses. Just houses!
Mind you if the "Shania Twains" arrive now they can go to Queenstown, Bayley's Real Estate are holding an auction of homes soon, that start at $1.2 mill (each) so such 'potential visitors', could possibly, Fly In, buy then Fly Out, then become FIFO's to their 'holiday homes' .
Yup I can see that 'fixing' the economy, should keep (current) Min of Finance happy, yer think?
Come on youse jokers, - agree with me.
Agreed Pete. As he said himself, "I'm sorted." He is only in it for the title, to hobnob it with 'A-listers', and get an eventual Knighthood - which he doesn't deserve given his failure to deliver.
As for anon@4.22 -given the $billions year after year, decade after decade, after decade (and plenty more) that have been directed at Maori, you would have thought they would be doing better? But, nah! Still languishing at the bottom of every bad stat. Throwing money at them doesn't work, so it's time they took some personal responsibility and stopped sucking on the teat of the taxpayer. After all, they're only too keen to spout on about their 120+billion dollar economy.
Post a Comment
Thank you for joining the discussion. Breaking Views welcomes respectful contributions that enrich the debate. Please ensure your comments are not defamatory, derogatory or disruptive. We appreciate your cooperation.