New Zealand heads into the election with two big problems barely mentioned on the 2026 election campaign trail: rising government debt and stalling productivity.
Our report says the answer starts with getting value for money. That means value from what government spends and from the rules it makes.
If nothing changes, Treasury projects that interest costs will climb from 7.5 cents of every tax dollar this financial year to 32 cents by 2065. Credit rating agencies Moody’s and Fitch have already warned they may downgrade New Zealand.
Stalling productivity (how much we produce for each hour worked) also hits people’s pockets. New Zealanders earn about $20,000 a year less per person than Australians, even though we work just as hard.
It has not always been this way. After reforms began in 1984, productivity growth picked up quickly, but the gains faded once reform stalled.
The report says the least painful fix is faster growth with firmer control of spending. Government spends or redirects about half of everything New Zealand earns. Yet the Auditor-General has said it is ‘hard if not impossible’ to tell what $180 billion a year of central government spending achieves.
Regulation gets even less scrutiny. Spending goes before Parliament every year in the Budget, but existing rules and regulations never get a similar annual review, even though they cost households and businesses real money.
‘There is no silver bullet. Many things need to be done better, and they all come back to value for money,’ said author Dr Bryce Wilkinson.
The report puts forward six options:
Stalling productivity (how much we produce for each hour worked) also hits people’s pockets. New Zealanders earn about $20,000 a year less per person than Australians, even though we work just as hard.
It has not always been this way. After reforms began in 1984, productivity growth picked up quickly, but the gains faded once reform stalled.
The report says the least painful fix is faster growth with firmer control of spending. Government spends or redirects about half of everything New Zealand earns. Yet the Auditor-General has said it is ‘hard if not impossible’ to tell what $180 billion a year of central government spending achieves.
Regulation gets even less scrutiny. Spending goes before Parliament every year in the Budget, but existing rules and regulations never get a similar annual review, even though they cost households and businesses real money.
‘There is no silver bullet. Many things need to be done better, and they all come back to value for money,’ said author Dr Bryce Wilkinson.
The report puts forward six options:
- set up an independent fiscal watchdog on government spending, reporting to Parliament
- adopt firmer rules for deciding prudent levels of public debt
- report ‘temporary’ spending more clearly, so long-term costs are not hidden
- pay fair compensation when regulation cuts property values
- hold independent reviews of major spending and restrictive regulations
- give ministers more power to direct agencies and get information
Click to view
Dr Bryce Wilkinson is a Senior Fellow at The New Zealand Initiative, Director of Capital Economics, and former Director of the New Zealand Treasury. His articles can be seen HERE. - where this article was sourced
1 comment:
Nope, it’s unemployment/ lack of jobs, and the crippling cost of living. People aren’t idiots. Has this guy read any of the data about voter concerns? I wish these opinion folks would do a little reading sometimes. Informed discourse is so much more valuable than what the NZ Institute is engaging in these days.
Post a Comment
Thank you for joining the discussion. Breaking Views welcomes respectful contributions that enrich the debate. Please ensure your comments are not defamatory, derogatory or disruptive. We appreciate your cooperation.