"Things you know that ain't so - trams, trains and buses are
the only solution to Auckland’s congestion problem”.
All the mayoral candidates, the Council and its
planners are wedded to the idea that Auckland’s congestion can only be solved
by crowding people within the existing city boundaries and increasing
congestion to force people to travel by trains, trams, and buses. The cost will
be enormous and increased congestion is certain.
Nobody, it seems, is looking at what modern
technology will soon bring to personal transport and what is happening
overseas. If they did, they would soon realise that providing door-to-door
public transport and encouraging ridesharing is the best way of getting people
out of their cars. It will reduce congestion and eliminate the need to squander
billions of dollars on obsolete modes of public transport.
Minibuses with flexible routing, ridesharing and
carpooling are the way of the future. Minibus based transport is a viable
proposition in many overseas cities. Poda-podas in West Africa, dala-dalas in
Tanzania, jeepneys in the Philippines, and tuktuks in India are the predominant
form of public transport. In South Africa they provide 60% of all public
transport. They pick up passengers along the road and drop them off at their
destination. Because they respond to demand, they concentrate at places where
they are most needed – without a single transport planner being involved!
A recent article in The Economist says that
uncoordinated minibus (jitney) services like this are operating profitably in
New York, Dallas, Phoenix and other US cities right now. In New York rides cost
two dollars and the service is both cheaper and faster than a subsidised bus at
three dollars. So technologically advanced minibus services that take advantage
of smart phones, GPS and route optimisation would, for sure, be successful in
Auckland.
Imagine that Auckland had a coordinated minibus
service using modern technology. The minibus location, the number of passengers
and their destinations is monitored by a central computer that decides which
minibus to send to pick up a new passenger and sends empty minibuses to an area
where demand will soon increase. During the rush hour, the minibuses would feed
some passengers to express buses and provide door-to-door service for others.
Outside peak times, frequent minibuses would replace expensive virtually empty
buses pounding up and down fixed routes at infrequent intervals.
A user would download an app onto their smart phone
and register their name and credit card. When they need a ride the app will
send their location, name and destination to the central computer which tells
them when the minibus will arrive. The cost of the ride will be deducted from
the credit card. Eureka! Public transport that does the same job as a car or
taxi for a fraction of the cost!
Minibus drivers would contract to a central
coordinator. Little formal regulatory input is needed because the system would
allow people to provide feedback on the driver and the bus. Any driver or bus
with unfavourable reports would rapidly drop to the bottom of the queue – or
right off it!
The low cost and door-to-door convenience of the
minibuses would get a very large number of people out of their cars. Congestion
and the need for downtown parking would be reduced. Looking further ahead, we
could soon be using driverless minibuses that would be even cheaper and safer.
Compare this with expensive trains and trams that
only serve a fraction of the population, and buses that cannot provide
door-to-door transport. It would end the ever-increasing expenditure on roads,
trains and buses because it would carry many more passengers on existing roads.
It would also reduce expenditure on fuel and motor vehicles.
Auckland is in the perfect position to lead the
world on this. We have a tech savvy population that is often used by overseas
developers to test out new technology and we have many firms that have led the
world in developing advanced software. And we have the ideal pilot project –
the airport shuttles.
If the airport shuttles can be made more efficient
and cheaper, they become a viable alternative to very expensive trains or trams
being promoted for airport transport. So let's get the shuttles onto computer
optimised routing to see just how well the system works and how much more
efficient the service becomes. If it is a success then it will be easy to
extend the computer coordinated system to cover the whole of Auckland.
Implementation should be left to private enterprise
because those promoting it will need to be ingenious, adaptable and fast
moving. But Auckland Transport would need to provide the support needed and
allow the minibuses to use bus lanes.
It is blindingly obvious that before we commit more
expenditure to what soon will be obsolete modes of transport, we must consider
the modern, technology-driven, option.
The only fly in the ointment is the deluded Council
and it planners that, in spite of the evidence from overseas, continue to believe
that trains and trams are a viable option and will do everything they can to
block the modern alternative. But with elections coming up, the solution is now
in the hands of the electorate.
The rewards are enormous, the risk is minimal and
the cost is probably negative. What are we waiting for?
5 comments:
Thanks Brian. I've been discussing these ideas with friends for years. Uber and similar services combined with minibuses. Great. Owner operated, computer coordinated. No public money required. What's not to like? I've also been irritated for years seeing huge buses trundle around all day, mostly empty. Trains are even worse. Sigh.
Ross - Have you ever noticed that most cars trundle round 3/4 empty - 1.2 person occupancy is the average and the cars parked or moving are not space efficient in a city of Auckland's size. Please bear in mind that all roads are subsidised more than 50 % by ratepayers and taxpayers. Petrol tax probably doesn't cover even half the cost.
In Auckland the Northern Busway takes more 40% of people who cross the Auckland Harbour Bridge each day. Think how many more lanes would be required if everyone drove. And rail metro patronage is growing strongly and will continue to do so when the City Rail Link is completed. Bring it on - the sooner the better.
I do not deny that vehicles of one sort or another will be a significant part our transport mix but merely bulding ever-widening motorways to accommodate more and more vehicles has not reduced congestion and is highly destructive of the "quality of place". Continual widening and flyovers usually benefit those further out, to the detriment of those living closer in to the city centre. A single or double rail track is akin to laparoscopic surgery when compared to a new motorway and better still if it can be put underground.
And the evidence from overseas clearly shows that many cities are investing in metro rail as a necessary part of the effective city transport solution. Modern metro rail is certainly not an obsolete transport mode as your writer suggests. London's new Crossrail is but one example.
Most importantly,the Government really needs to review its funding mechanisms for public transit in Auckland without delay.
Bryan,
You are so right. New technology and new thinking is urgently needed. Its exciting that there are transport alternatives that potentially have such low cost of entry.
The trouble is we are being led by politicians who want to maximize votes and bureaucrats who want to maximize empires. Add a good dose of ideology to both and you have lost the ability for most to think clearly. This is roughly the same lot that gave us leaky homes and the current housing crisis.
I read an amusing and sad comment about this business.
An Auckland blogger said he was upset to find out that Auckland voters were as stupid as
the rest of New Zealand.
Hard to know where to start.
It is amazing we will vote for stuff that is a proven failure and misuse of capital funds.
Post a Comment
Thanks for engaging in the debate!
Because this is a public forum, we will only publish comments that are respectful and do NOT contain links to other sites. We appreciate your cooperation.