Success in
politics, as with so many things, is often about learning from past mistakes.
What is surprising, perhaps, is how few in politics – full as they are of their
own sense of certainty – are able to do this.
Following last
week’s catastrophic election results for the Labour Party, which saw millions
of their traditional supporters abandon them for the Brexit Party, Labour moved
further towards supporting a second referendum. As the party inched towards
formally repudiating the views of 17.4 million people, it seems its leaders are
quite incapable of learning from what happened in 2015.
Ed Miliband’s
inability to understand, let alone articulate, the anti-EU sentiment of
millions of voters during the general election campaign in 2015 helps explain
why he fell far short of a majority. Rather than recognise any of that, Labour
looks set to repeat Miliband’s mistake on an even grander scale.
The Conservatives
seem even less capable of learning from what went wrong when it comes to
Europe. For forty years, the party has tripped up repeatedly as it has
attempted to be both a party of the nation, and one whose leadership defaults
towards closer European integration.
In the early
1990s, this meant joining the European Exchange Rate mechanism – with
disastrous economic and political consequences. In 2009, it meant David Cameron
putting aside his ‘cast iron’ guarantee to oppose the Lisbon treaty. His
party’s poll ratings fell as a direct consequence, and in the ensuing election
against Gordon Brown, he failed to secure a majority and was forced into
coalition with Nick Clegg.
Finally, in the
aftermath of the 2016 referendum, it seemed as if the Conservative Party might
at last come to its senses and embrace leaving the EU. Instead, they have made
a mess of it, with various would-be Tory leaders quick to tell us that leaving
the EU without the EU’s permission would be a disaster.
There is, however,
one figure in UK politics that does seem to have learnt from past errors –
Nigel Farage.
His new Brexit party
doesn’t just top the opinion polls. Last week they won an actual election by an
extraordinary margin.
The Brexit Party
might in some ways be a reincarnation of UKIP, but so far it seems to have
managed to avoid many of its predecessors’ mistakes.
For a start, the
party has mastered the art (or should one say, science) of online campaigning.
They are no longer in the business of merely holding meetings for a few of the
faithful in the backrooms of pubs. They know how to reach millions, with
messages that resonate.
The new party has
broadened its appeal, with the sort of beyond-the-base strategy that was so
badly lacking in 2015.
The Brexit Party
is not – thus far – all about Nigel, either. In the recent Euro elections, it
fielded an impressive range of candidates – entrepreneurs, charity sector
professionals, business owners. They looked a party of all Britain and all
Britons.
So far, the party
seems to have a message discipline that was not always there with UKIP. There
have been precious few off-piste comments about HIV or immigration, for
instance. Unlike in the run up to the 2015 election, the party has stuck to a
simple message; the SW1 elite have failed to honour the referendum result.
And it’s a message
that has cut through precisely because it rings true. The past thirty-three
months have seen a consistent attempt – by MPs and the House of Lords, by civil
servants and broadcasters, even by judges and archbishops – to undermine the
referendum result.
At every
opportunity, almost all of those that hold positions of authority within our
country since June 2016 have acted to try to reverse the verdict of the people.
Most of our Europhile Establishment don’t even regard what they have been up to
since the referendum as an error. They still assume that they are somehow
ameliorating the effects of a terrible misstep made by their inferiors.
The fact that all
those urbane, educated people at the apex of our country, full of a sense of
their own entitlement, have been slower to learn than Nigel Farage tells you
something about the state of our elite.
Like the Bourbons
or the Stuarts or the Romanovs, the chances that they might learn from what they
have got wrong before it is too late look remote.
Douglas Carswell, a
former MP, was a member of the Vote Leave campaign in the 2016 EU referendum.
This article first appeared on CapX HERE.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Thanks for engaging in the debate!
Because this is a public forum, we will only publish comments that are respectful and do NOT contain links to other sites. We appreciate your cooperation.