Because we know he has always been opposed to the idea. Today, though, he's saying he's “come around to the idea". Which is hardly a ringing endorsement, is it?
What he really means is he’s come around to the idea because Chris Hipkins says it's his way or the highway.
There might, I suppose, be some people who will want to believe that Grant Robertson has had some sort of moment of realisation. These will be the five or six people who think it’s a great idea.
But we all know Grant Robertson hasn’t changed his mind or had a change of heart. We all know that he’s been told by the boss what’s happening and he’s going along with it because the boss said so. And that his job as the party’s Finance spokesperson is to sell it.
The danger, though, for Grant Robertson personally is any credibility he might have built up during his time as Finance Minister may have just gone down the gurgler.
And for what? For nothing. Because this GST idea is not going to turn the tide on Labour’s fortunes.
The saving grace for Grant Robertson is that no one is going to believe him when he bangs on about it over the next few weeks and all the economists and tax people will know he still thinks it’s a stupid idea.
And it’s a stupid idea that Labour should’ve ditched weeks ago. After National came out and said it had been tipped-off that Labour was planning a no-GST-on-fruit-and-veggies policy, Labour should’ve dropped the idea then because, straight away, all the people who know about these things wrote it off as dumb policy.
And they’re still writing it off as dumb policy. Which I think it is too.
Because, for me, what it comes down to is the opportunity cost of a policy like this. What you and I (collectively) will be missing out on for the sake of saving a few bucks a week. It’s an opportunity cost that couldn’t be starker.
It comes down to two numbers. The $5 that Labour reckons is the average amount of money most people would save by not paying GST on their fruit and veg. Versus the $2 billion that the government wouldn’t get in tax revenue.
That’s what it comes down to for me. I save 5-bucks. The government loses 2-billion bucks. You save 5-bucks. And we all lose 2-billion bucks.
2-billion less to spend on hospitals. 2-billion less to spend unclogging our courts system. 2-billion less to spend on roads. 2-billion less for schools. You name it. It’s just nuts.
We’re all feeling the pinch from what’s happened with the cost of living over the last few years and, for some people, even five dollars can make a difference. I know that. I get that.
But I just can’t see past the opportunity cost of stupid policy like this. Especially stupid policy announced two months from an election.
It is desperate. It lacks real thought. And it treats us voters like idiots.
John MacDonald is the Canterbury Mornings host on Newstalk ZB Christchurch. This article was first published HERE
But we all know Grant Robertson hasn’t changed his mind or had a change of heart. We all know that he’s been told by the boss what’s happening and he’s going along with it because the boss said so. And that his job as the party’s Finance spokesperson is to sell it.
The danger, though, for Grant Robertson personally is any credibility he might have built up during his time as Finance Minister may have just gone down the gurgler.
And for what? For nothing. Because this GST idea is not going to turn the tide on Labour’s fortunes.
The saving grace for Grant Robertson is that no one is going to believe him when he bangs on about it over the next few weeks and all the economists and tax people will know he still thinks it’s a stupid idea.
And it’s a stupid idea that Labour should’ve ditched weeks ago. After National came out and said it had been tipped-off that Labour was planning a no-GST-on-fruit-and-veggies policy, Labour should’ve dropped the idea then because, straight away, all the people who know about these things wrote it off as dumb policy.
And they’re still writing it off as dumb policy. Which I think it is too.
Because, for me, what it comes down to is the opportunity cost of a policy like this. What you and I (collectively) will be missing out on for the sake of saving a few bucks a week. It’s an opportunity cost that couldn’t be starker.
It comes down to two numbers. The $5 that Labour reckons is the average amount of money most people would save by not paying GST on their fruit and veg. Versus the $2 billion that the government wouldn’t get in tax revenue.
That’s what it comes down to for me. I save 5-bucks. The government loses 2-billion bucks. You save 5-bucks. And we all lose 2-billion bucks.
2-billion less to spend on hospitals. 2-billion less to spend unclogging our courts system. 2-billion less to spend on roads. 2-billion less for schools. You name it. It’s just nuts.
We’re all feeling the pinch from what’s happened with the cost of living over the last few years and, for some people, even five dollars can make a difference. I know that. I get that.
But I just can’t see past the opportunity cost of stupid policy like this. Especially stupid policy announced two months from an election.
It is desperate. It lacks real thought. And it treats us voters like idiots.
John MacDonald is the Canterbury Mornings host on Newstalk ZB Christchurch. This article was first published HERE
5 comments:
Hipkins is prepared to burn Robertson & Parker to get back into power. The Māori caucus (including Tuku Morgan of Tainui) are demanding these policies so Maori can get their grubby hands on fresh water? The same applies to Marama Davidson who I’m sure believes Māori elders have greater wisdom than all the rest of us!
My dear wife and I like so many others in NZ these days run a very tight budget. Yesterday I backtracked on our fruit/vege spend over the last seven weeks. Round figures. Total $135. Reduced by the proposed GST adjustment the total would have been $117. Saving $18 or $2.57 per week. We could then finance one chocolate chip muffin from the bakery counter, $2.49 and have eight cents to spare. How long before price rises see our chocolate chip muffin disappear?
Unfortunately John, most people believe anything.
ALL GST gone by lunch time. There fixed it.
Well of course this Labour government has treated billions of dollars as if they were $5. Don't be surprised if Robertson borrows another bunch of billions to spread around as he did in preparation for election year 2020. Maybe he will arrange to have $100 notes dropped from aircraft on political swing suburbs. His government has been corrupt enough for this and much more.
i can't understand the big deal about GST off fruit & veg. if this is all you want, just go to the sunday market at Avondale (or any other farmers' market). every transaction is in cash & there is no receipt whatsoever. are we to believe they are counting the money at the end of the day and sending a check for 15% to the treasury???
Post a Comment
Thanks for engaging in the debate!
Because this is a public forum, we will only publish comments that are respectful and do NOT contain links to other sites. We appreciate your cooperation.