Pages

Thursday, March 21, 2024

Professor Robert MacCulloch: The IMF should apologize.....


The IMF should apologize for its NZ Mission Chief stating our IRD supports Capital & Land Taxes (when it doesn't)

In order to achieve maximum embarrassment to the government, our bankrupting One (Sided) News channel splashed on TV screens its headline news story featuring International Monetary Fund NZ Mission Chief, Evan Papageorgiou, calling for a comprehensive tax on capital gains to be introduced in our country, as well as a land tax which should 'increase the progressivity of income tax' - widening the gap between lower & higher tax rates. He said, "We've recommended (capital & land taxes) repeatedly, [and] yes, I know that politicians don't pay attention .. Treasury & IRD also have similar opinions, there is a quite a lot of good enough advice out there to influence the public debate."

I do not know of a single Inland Revenue Report or statement from its Commissioner, Paul Mersi, that has expressed the opinion that capital gains & land taxes should be introduced. Can the IMF front up & state why it declared our IRD to be in support of such taxes? The IRD published last year its "High Wealth Individuals Research Project" which former Revenue Minister David Parker presented to my economics class, but that was only a data collection exercise, measuring the "effective" tax rates of high-net-worth families. It made no policy recommendations whatsoever & did not, anywhere, express the opinion that capital and land taxes should be introduced in this country.

The IMF is welcome to tell me I'm mistaken & our Inland Revenue Service does formally support these new taxes. Unless it comes up with evidence, it should retract what I believe to be a false statement made to between 500,000 and 1 million NZ'ers watching One News at 6pm. As for the IMF line that it "knows" our politicians "don't pay attention" to this issue, what again is it on about? That was point of the Cullen Tax Review. Former PM Ardern was on the verge of introducing these new taxes but pulled back at the last when she decided they'd be unpopular. David Parker & former Finance Minister Robertson were itching for them to be introduced. How could our politicians not have paid more attention to this issue?

More broadly, the IMF has become a waste of time. Sending staffers around the world to lecture countries how they should run their affairs is past its sell-by date. Does the IMF think that we are too stupid to work out what's good for ourselves? That we don't know how to follow "good advice" here in NZ because we're so ignorant? How patronizing. Go back to Washington and fix the finances of the US before you tell us how to run our own country.

Sources
https://www.1news.co.nz/2024/03/20/govt-warned-not-to-borrow-more-money-for-tax-cuts-in-imf-report/
https://www.ird.govt.nz/hwi-research-project

Professor Robert MacCulloch holds the Matthew S. Abel Chair of Macroeconomics at Auckland University. He has previously worked at the Reserve Bank, Oxford University, and the London School of Economics. He runs the blog Down to Earth Kiwi from where this article was sourced.

5 comments:

Ken S said...

Excellent comment Robert, and, like you, I look forward to a reply from the IMF. I certainly won't be holding my breath though.

Anonymous said...

The IMF or International Mafia Fund was issuing orders. They own NZ Incorporated thanks to our successive governments selling us out.

Anonymous said...

Good one Robert. Now only if the new finance minister would chop all the waste spending, there would be no need for more taxes.

Anonymous said...

actually if they chopped all waste taxes would fall

Anonymous said...

Yes, well said Robert. And what are 'Rates' if they are not already land taxes?

Post a Comment

Thanks for engaging in the debate!

Because this is a public forum, we will only publish comments that are respectful and do NOT contain links to other sites. We appreciate your cooperation.