Pages

Sunday, September 22, 2024

Ele Ludemann: Lying about lying


If three’s anything worse than lying, it’s lying about lying:

TĀKUTA FERRIS: —

. . . A knowledge gap is a dangerous thing. It allows lies to be presented as truths. Politicians call this obfuscation—the art of making something unclear, intentionally vague, ambiguous, to conceal or obscure the truth, to confuse others. Lies, in other words. Many in this House are masters of it, and it is a disservice to those who voted you into your positions. Unless, of course—

Rt Hon Winston Peters: Point of order, Mr Speaker. It is simply not acceptable for someone, inexperienced as he is, to nevertheless accuse other MPs— . . .

Rt Hon WINSTON PETERS: He made the allegation that members of this Parliament are liars, and he should have been stopped in his tracks right then.

SPEAKER: My apologies, I didn’t quite pick that up. But if that is what the member said, then he should withdraw and apologise. I’d also make it very clear to the member that reading speeches is not part of the tikanga of the House either. So the member may wish to continue, but if he has made that statement—we’ll obviously check Hansard later—then he should withdraw and apologise as quickly as possible.

TĀKUTA FERRIS: I haven’t made that statement.

SPEAKER: Oh, well—

Hon Shane Jones: Point of order—point of order.

SPEAKER: No, hang on—wait on, wait on. We can’t go back and hear what was said inside this House, but we will check it and I do hope the member hasn’t misled the House with that particular claim. . .

Is Lies, in other words. Many in this House are masters of it, accusing MPs of lying?

Audrey Young says it is:

Winston Peters may be the oldest MP in the House, but he is not hard of hearing and his political antennae are always finely tuned when one of the MPs from Te Pāti Māori is speaking. When one of them, Te Tai Tonga MP Tākuta Ferris, strayed from the rules yesterday and suggested MPs tell lies, Peters pounced.

Speaker Gerry Brownlee had been distracted and hadn’t heard what Ferris was saying, so sought the MP’s word on the matter. Ferris denied it, unfortunately. That is not a time to be tricky with words and to claim deniability because you had only said they tell lies, not that they are liars. . .

His claim that MPs are the masters of telling lies is a minor offence compared to the grave offence of denying it. A member’s word is meant to be synonymous with his or her honour. Ferris made the mistake of thinking that just because it is commonly believed that MPs tell lies, you can say it in the House – or that just because he didn’t name an MP, he could get away with it. That is no defence because it then becomes an offence against the whole House.

The MP will have to withdraw and apologise to avoid a referral to the Privileges Committee. He has certainly proved his point with his own blatant porky. But the process may take some time. It is understood Peters has filed a formal complaint to the Speaker and Ferris has 10 days to respond. . . .

This may be of no interest to anyone but political tragics but it does Ferris no credit that what is the most publicity, and possibly the first, since becoming an MP is for accusing his colleagues of lying and then lying about it.

Ele Ludemann is a North Otago farmer and journalist, who blogs HERE - where this article was sourced.

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

Sounds just like typical Te Pati Maori behaviour, intended to impress the Mongrel Mob rather than complying with rules. Once their intended dictatorship eventuates they will be able to forget about rules and telling the truth.

Robert Arthur said...

It is some way back in my memory bank but I vaguely recall that Mr Profumo lost his seat in the UK parliamnt for lying about his involvement with Christine Keeler and co.

Basil Walker said...

I respect the courtesy of democracy and comity of Parliament and despise the division of NZ by maori BUT, PM Luxon and National are anything other than truthful as he and they continually spout on about Carbon Zero with accompanying law . It is NOT possible EVER while people are breathing and is not honest, defendable or truthful . Yes it is a lie and yes they are liars .

Post a Comment

Thanks for engaging in the debate!

Because this is a public forum, we will only publish comments that are respectful and do NOT contain links to other sites. We appreciate your cooperation.