An interesting poll of 117,000 people in 101 countries on whether they support or oppose their being a World Parliament. They say 40% support it, 27% oppose and 33% undecided.
The question design is very important. The question was:
Would you support or oppose the creation of a citizen-elected World Parliament to handle global issues?
If you asked whether you support there being a World Parliament that could over-rule national governments, you might get different responses. Would the World Parliament have any actual power or would it be a talkfest?
The lobby group behind the poll says they advocate for:
Democracy Without Borders advocates democracy as a global right that spans across all levels and must be realized in all its dimensions: representation, participation, rights and liberties, and the rule of law.
I agree democracy is a global right. But one of the problems with a World Parliament is that it could be so large to be useless. If you get one seat per five million people then the Parliament would have almost 2,000 MPs. You could just give representatives votes proportional to their population but then it just becomes like a UN General Assembly with weighted voting (which would be great for China, India etc).
What is interesting with the poll is which countries are most supportive and opposed. Of the 20 countries polled in Asia-Pacific 18 were supportive and the two against were Australia (net 6% opposed) and New Zealand (net 7% opposed). Generally countries that are wealthy and democratic are opposed while almost all other countries are supportive. Maybe it means that citizens in countries which don’t get much of a vote would like one, or it could be that they support an institution that would give them more power (as they have large populations) and developed countries less power.
The 12 countries most supportive are:
- Turkey +38%
- Mozambique +38%
- Cuba +36%
- Cote de Ivoire +29%
- Senegal +29%
- Lebanon +29%
- Nigeria +28%
- Palestine +27%
- Egypt +26%
- Zimbabwe +25%
- Iran +25%
- Tunisia +25%
- Austria -11%
- UK -10%
- US -8%
- NZ -7%
- Denmark – 7%
- Netherland -7%
- Australia -6%
- Israel -6%
- Germany -4%
- Switzerland -4%
- Poland -4%
- Romania -4%
David Farrar runs Curia Market Research, a specialist opinion polling and research agency, and the popular Kiwiblog where this article was sourced. He previously worked in the Parliament for eight years, serving two National Party Prime Ministers and three Opposition Leaders
3 comments:
In the countries polled it would be interesting to know the political beliefs of the respondents. ie which party of party bloc they support in their own country. If NZ was polled my guess is Labour Green TPM voters would lean to global control (as long as they can make sure it stays in their hands) and the others against. Not everyone of course, within each bloc there are people who deviate .
>"Generally countries that are wealthy and democratic are opposed while almost all other countries are supportive."
Here's another way of putting it: countries that are an utter shambles owing to corruption and mismanagement tend to vote in favour while those run more or less properly vote against.
Desperate for an alternative, democratic countries are not.
Think Switzerland Canton by Canton democracy, the world is a macrocosm of that.
The Cantons are happy to wield their modest power.
Post a Comment
Thank you for joining the discussion. Breaking Views welcomes respectful contributions that enrich the debate. Please ensure your comments are not defamatory, derogatory or disruptive. We appreciate your cooperation.