Hello KBers … if it is too long don’t read it … but the outcomes of our education system are important.
What NZ’s 2025 PISA Results Tell Us
Alwyn Poole — with analytical/formatting support from AI
General Analysis
- Even small improvements, or arrested decline, provide some hope — and yes, I know “hope isn’t a plan”, but it can be a motivator for seeking further and more substantial improvements.
- There is little here to give politicians or any ilk bragging rights. These 15-year-olds would have had two years under National, six years under Labour, and two further years under National. The curriculum changes under National will have had little or no effect, although positive energy around improving achievement may have helped.
- These students also endured the Covid response, which possibly gives further hope that children can achieve despite tough times.
- There is a lot more to do, and the concerns around the huge gaps related to socio-economics remain. The fact that NZ’s total EQI spend is only $250 million — as little as 3% of funding for the highest-EQI schools — is a major issue that needs addressing. A more detailed and consistent curriculum may have marginal effects on equity, but there is a great deal more to be done to close the gaps, as a public education system should.
New Zealand students scored above the OECD average in mathematics, reading and science, and New Zealand also had a relatively high proportion of top-performing students.
For example:

Click to view
2. The biggest concern is the long-term decline
The 2025 results were approximately the same as 2022, but:
mathematics is below 2018 and 2015 levels;
reading is below 2018 and 2015 levels;
science has been comparatively stable for more than a decade;
the gap between high and low performers widened in reading.
Even more concerning:
Since 2015, the percentage of students below Level 2 increased by:
8 percentage points in mathematics
5 percentage points in reading
no significant change in science.
New Zealand still has a reasonably strong education system by international standards, but there is ongoing evidence of deterioration in foundational academic performance.
Key needs for improvement are:
Mathematics: strengthen foundational numeracy, confidence with problem solving, and sustained achievement over time.
Literacy and reading: improve comprehension, vocabulary development, critical reading, and written response skills.
Problem solving: build students’ ability to apply knowledge in unfamiliar and real-world contexts.
Independent learning: develop study planning, self-regulation, reflection, and effective help-seeking habits.
Academic resilience: support perseverance, confidence, and the ability to keep learning when work becomes challenging.
3. There is a significant achievement gap associated with socioeconomic status
The highest socioeconomic group outperformed the lowest socioeconomic group by 89 points in science. The OECD average gap was 85 points.
Between 2015 and 2025, New Zealand’s socioeconomic performance gap in science remained stable, while the OECD average gap narrowed.
This indicates that simply maintaining the current system may not be enough to reduce educational inequality.
The data also show that only 13% of disadvantaged New Zealand students achieved in the top quarter of science performance.
4. Student mindset is a major priority
New Zealand students demonstrate relatively positive attitudes:
78% say they are curious about many different things;
63% say they make additional effort when work becomes challenging;
74% demonstrate a growth mindset.
Students with a growth mindset in New Zealand had a 59-point science performance advantage compared with students with a fixed mindset, after socioeconomic factors were taken into account.
That is substantially larger than the OECD average difference of 28 points.
Recommendation
Our education programmes should therefore not focus exclusively on teaching content.
They should incorporate:
- growth mindset;
- perseverance;
- goal setting;
- learning strategies;
- confidence;
- problem solving;
- reflection;
- independent learning.
This is one of the clearest areas where an education provider could potentially add value.
Only about 34% of New Zealand students reported that they often or very often plan their approach to studying.
Only 45% regularly ask themselves questions about the material to check whether they have understood it.
This suggests that many students may have reasonable academic ability but lack strong learning-to-learn skills.
And the report provides evidence that these skills matter.
A one-unit increase in:
- goal-setting → +6 science points
- help-seeking → +11 science points
6. School engagement is another significant issue
Attendance is still poor – although we have recently seen some incremental change.
In 2025:
32% of students reported missing at least one full day of school during the previous two weeks;
OECD average: 22%.
Attendance is closely connected to learning opportunity.
Attendance is still poor – although we have recently seen some incremental change.
In 2025:
32% of students reported missing at least one full day of school during the previous two weeks;
OECD average: 22%.
Attendance is closely connected to learning opportunity.
7. Classroom environments need attention
In New Zealand, classroom disruption is a significant concern:
24% of students said they cannot work well in most or all lessons.
41% reported noise and disorder disrupting most or every science lesson.
36% said classmates do not listen to the teacher.
Students need learning environments where they can:
- concentrate without unnecessary disruption;
- participate confidently in class activities;
- ask questions and receive clear explanations;
- collaborate productively with classmates; and
- receive individual support when needed.
New Zealand students reported relatively positive teacher support:
75% said teachers show interest in every student’s learning;
69% said teachers continue teaching until students understand;
79% said teachers give extra help when needed.
However, these figures have declined compared with 2015.
So the issue does not appear to be simply “New Zealand teachers aren’t supporting students.”
Instead, the system appears to be under pressure.
9. Digital learning and AI are changing the education market
New Zealand students reported spending approximately:
2.5 hours per day using digital devices at school for learning.
The OECD average was 1.7 hours.
AI adoption is also already significant.
47% of New Zealand students reported using AI chatbots to help them learn at least once a week.
Other uses include:
- preliminary research: 32%;
- summarising texts: 28%;
- drafting writing assignments: 24%.
For example:
AI-assisted learning + critical thinking + verification + independent reasoning.
10. Digital distraction remains a real problem
As I said – when the cell phone ban was introduced – students will find a way around it.
New Zealand students use digital devices more than the OECD average:
38% reported that their peers are often distracted by digital devices during most or all science lessons. The OECD average is 28%.
11. Bullying is a significant issue
25% of New Zealand students reported being victims of at least one form of bullying a few times per month or more. The OECD average was 20%.
The report also identifies a significant relationship between cyberbullying and achievement.
Students reporting certain forms of cyberbullying scored, on average, 54 points lower in science than their peers.
We need to focus on:
- student wellbeing;
- belonging;
- peer relationships;
- respectful communication;
- digital citizenship.
In 2025:
75% of students said parents/guardians asked at least weekly what they did at school;
only 43% reported weekly discussions about problems at school.
In 2022 these figures were 81% and 55%.
As I have always said parents need to be a significant part of the learning ecosystem and very much welcomed by schools as partners.
13. There are significant limitations on the New Zealand PISA data
Our:
- student response rate was below the target;
- student exclusions exceeded the tolerance;
- school participation rate was below target.
However, the OECD also says that because the 2022 results were biased in a similar direction, comparisons between 2022 and 2025 are unlikely to be materially affected.
AI says:
“PISA 2025 provides a strong directional indicator of the challenges and opportunities facing New Zealand education, while the OECD notes limitations in the New Zealand sample and recommends caution when interpreting absolute scores.”
Overall Assessment
I would rate the education environment identified by this report as:

Click to view
Case Study: Comparing New Zealand’s 2025 PISA Results with Estonia
Our Prime Minister has often reference Estonia as a relevant/exemplar nation. So – here is a brief report on achievement, equity, and policy implications
Summary
In PISA 2025, both New Zealand and Estonia performed above the OECD average across the main domains of science, mathematics and reading. Estonia, however, remained one of the strongest-performing education systems internationally, with results near the top of the OECD and Europe. New Zealand’s results were solid and broadly stable compared with 2022, but they showed a larger spread of achievement and a continuing challenge in mathematics and equity.
Headline results

Click to view
Science: Science was the major domain in PISA 2025. New Zealand’s average score of 509 was above the OECD average and broadly stable over recent PISA cycles. Estonia’s score of 527 placed it among the world’s leading systems and first in Europe according to Estonian education reporting. The gap suggests that Estonia’s students, on average, demonstrated stronger science literacy and application of scientific knowledge.
Mathematics: Mathematics is the clearest area of difference. New Zealand’s average of 480 remained above the OECD average, but Estonia’s 508 was substantially higher. New Zealand also reported that 29% of students were below the baseline proficiency level in mathematics, indicating a significant challenge for foundational numeracy.
Reading: Reading was New Zealand’s strongest area relative to Estonia, with the two countries almost level: New Zealand scored 497 and Estonia 499. However, Estonia’s reading score had declined compared with earlier cycles, while New Zealand’s reading result was broadly similar to 2022 and remained above the OECD average.
Equity and spread of achievement
New Zealand’s results point to a continuing equity concern. Although the achievement gap between advantaged and disadvantaged students narrowed in 2025, New Zealand still had above-average variation in achievement, meaning outcomes differed widely between students.
Estonia’s system is widely noted for combining high performance with comparatively strong equity, where socio-economic background has less impact on learning outcomes than in many OECD systems.
Interpretation for New Zealand
New Zealand’s PISA 2025 results should be read as cautiously positive. Achievement appears to have stabilised after earlier declines and students remain above OECD averages.
At the same time, Estonia shows that higher average performance and stronger equity can coexist. The comparison suggests three priorities for New Zealand: strengthen foundational mathematics, reduce the long tail of underachievement, and continue improving support for disadvantaged learners without lowering expectations for high performers.
Policy lessons from Estonia
Equity with high expectations: Estonia’s results suggest that broad access to quality learning can lift average achievement while keeping gaps comparatively smaller.
Strong science foundations: Estonia’s high science score indicates the value of coherent curriculum, skilled teaching and sustained attention to scientific literacy.
Reading remains important: Even high-performing systems can experience declines in reading, making literacy a continuing priority for both countries.
Digital learning needs discipline: Both countries’ results highlight the growing importance of computational problem solving, but digital tools need to support—not replace—deep learning.
Conclusion
New Zealand performed above the OECD average in PISA 2025 and showed signs of stabilisation, particularly compared with the post-pandemic decline seen internationally. Estonia, however, remained a benchmark system, outperforming New Zealand in science and mathematics and matching it closely in reading. For New Zealand, the comparison reinforces the need to lift mathematics achievement, reduce achievement variation, and build a more consistently high-performing and equitable education system.
Alwyn Poole, a well-known figure in the New Zealand education system, he founded and was the head of Mt Hobson Middle School in Auckland for 18 years. This article was published HERE

7 comments:
Thank you Alwyn for your comprehensive and insightful appraisal of NZ’s PISA results.
Here’s hoping that our education providers take note. In fact, they must take note.
Alwyn Poole has made a valuable contribution to the discussion on education in New Zealand and has maintained a balanced, politically neutral tone throughout.
Indeed, socioeconomics appears to be a major determinant of academic performance, truancy is still a problem and indeed poor behaviour from a subset of secondary students continues to make life very challenging for teachers. It most certainly was challenging for many of us during my time as a secondary teacher during the 1980s.
Contributions such as Mr. Poole’s article here are very important as we head to a national election because they avoid party politics and the negativity that has emerged within the discourse on education over the last few years. I read the very frequent commentaries from the Aotearoa Educators Collective and, while I find myself agreeing with a perspective here and there on some aspect of education, the overall tone is virulently anti the current reforms and the Collective has lost balance. A piece from them published this morning asks us all to debate ideas, not people - challenge policy robustly, without personal attacks, inflammatory rhetoric, or fear-based division. This request may signal a welcome change to the National discussion on the future of education in New Zealand.
Certain research journals are part of the current problem, both in New Zealand and in other countries. Recently, a colleague of mine had a manuscript rejected for publication and received the following review:
“The author fails to disclose their own positionality, expertise, or interest in this area, which constitutes an ethical breach in scholarship concerning Indigenous knowledge systems and perspectives. ….. The manuscript's ideological alignment is not disclosed, which further compromises its academic integrity.”
AND:
“. . . this type of ‛research’ would certainly be found completely unacceptable by any New Zealand University in the 1990s or today. The argument of this article is simply racist.”
Several other colleague of mine have had the same experience. If failure to hold a mainstream view results in this kind of response, then how do we have a robust exchange of ideas?
In addition, some of those working in the current education reforms, or commenting on education more generally, have been subjected to appalling mistreatment on social media. Last year an education professional was accused of dishonesty on social media and was called variously a liar, a scumbag, a fraud, corrupt, dishonest, thief, gaslighter, a cockroach and other names. As a result, she was forced to close down part of her business website. And she is not by any means the only one to receive such treatment.
Mr. Poole has given a fine example of how the debate on education should be conducted – with balance and objectivity and with clear intent to add value to the mix of ideas.
Much/most 'research' in education (indeed across the social sciences) is not 'research' at all but ideological proselytising.
Hence we see bullshit methodologies like 'qualitative research' which involves a few chinwags with carefully chosen fellow travellers parading as data, and 'grounded theory' which means making up your theoretical base from your 'data' as you go (the perfect tautology).
Marxofascists are not interested in genuine, intellectually honest empirical research. They are totalitarians and suppress any dinkum research because it doesn't suit their social engineering agenda.
Thank you Alwyn for your comprehensive research .
I have interacted with AEC , by posting blogs, David because of their very aggressive and stated mission to counter the recent education reforms and to retain progressive education .
In our superior NZ educational past, we were tops in all subjects and without the present inequity displayed in the current disgraceful long tail of underachievement , Our standards were high as as long as traditional education largely prevailed. This was earlier last century.
Equity is the catch call of Progessivists but that is exactly what their ideology fails to achieve.
I received outrageous personal abuse and labelled 'dangerous' from a high level academic , on an AEC blog when I simply mentioned things like the Mississippi Miracle ( see article BV earlier this year). This event was about the lowest performing US state jumping up to among the top states in reading results after adopting systematic phonics .
Katherine Burbalsinghe has achieved spectacular results in her high equity London secondary school with a return to traditional methods including discipline . Her students achieved as highly as prestigious Eton College. She was given British 'Contrarian of the Year' award. However that comes at a cost with abusive on line personal attacks and even death threats.
AEC is entrenched in Progressive Ideology , as are still most of our educational institutions . It would take a massive revolution to have the leopard change its spots. Being nicer is only a tiny step. Gaynor
Gaynor. I am sorry to hear that you have been attacked by one particular body or by people connected with that body. You are not alone.
That body asks us all to debate ideas, not people - challenge policy robustly, without personal attacks, inflammatory rhetoric, or fear-based division. Let's hope that this request signals a welcome change to the behaviour of that body towards those who hold dissenting views from theirs.
Can we take from this that dressing everything in culturally relevant (for one culture) examples is an abject failure as scores haven’t improved since 2018?
Meaning maths problem = “Rangi has 7 pipis in the kiti, but there is a hole that 3 fall out of. How many pipis does rangi have for the hungi”??
Daughter used to often complain she had no idea what these questions were asking but just did 7-3 and got answer
David ,since the highly honoured academic ( an assistant Professor of education and culture ) that attacked me verbally on the AEC site, actually made a complete fool of himself the AEC site rearranged the blogs to make it look like the professor had the last say. It was a 1000 word tirade against me and my supposed ignorance and stupidity. .
Now since I am so 'dangerous ' they ignore me . This is quite an exciting site ! I am encouraging others to join the tiff. You can be annoymous .
Now when I make comments, the aggressors just ignore me .
Anonymous 8:06PM .As a maths tutor for 40 plus years , the problem was the lack of any rote learning of tables or number facts , half a dozen ways of doing ordinary arithmetic manipulations like two figure subtraction or multiplying , nothing taught cummulatively, systematically or even explicitly or in fact structured in any way. No revision. Also the abysmal ignorance of some primary teachers in teaching fractions , decimals and percentages. One case to illustrate this is of a teacher giving answer to 13/2 as 6. 1 - the remainder thought to be the same as the decimal ! Also group work for students to solve a word problem about eg area of a square and many children arrived at the perimeter as the answer . No correct answer was given by the teacher. Yes ,, there were wordy problems which many children couldn't read even in English let alone Maori. Most primary schools were not even teaching the year 8 syllabus in maths ( arithmetic) because the teacher couldn't do it . When my son was in Year 8, the teacher asked him to teach her class fractions because she couldn't .I taught my son the fraction lesson at home , then he went to school and taught the class ! Computers don't help- same insane methods . The newly introduced arithmetic is much better but the flaw I think is that it is based on Singapore maths . There parents are directed to buy homework workbooks if their child has weaknesses.
I. Our schooling in NZ is a fiasco .Get your child quality workbooks and do extra at home . Gaynor
.
Post a Comment
Thank you for joining the discussion. Breaking Views welcomes respectful contributions that enrich the debate. Please ensure your comments are not defamatory, derogatory or disruptive. We appreciate your cooperation.