......is sullied before the election count is announced
Opportunity Party bigwigs will be a treat to listen to when they explain how they reconcile the headline below, about the identities of advisers being kept secret, with their policy pledge about transparency…


Click to view
Transparency?
That’s what they said.
They backed that up with a raft of commitments including –

Click to view
If secrecy and transparency can’t be reconciled, we will know – before special votes have been counted and a final general election result announced – that Opportunity is just like other parties. What it promises and what it does can differ.
One thing looks certain: no matter which clutch of parties wins the most seats in Parliament, Opportunity will become embroiled in negotiations to form the next coalition government.
Deputy leader Daniel Eb affirmed this today when he told RNZ’s Midday Report it’s going to be a “pretty gnarly negotiation period,” as the party prepares for any discussions to form a government.
He said he was on the party’s negotiating team, and their bottom lines were a good starting point.
“It’s an unusual thing to do with the bottom lines, but I think the payoff at this point in time in the sort of cycle is is pretty clear.”
The second of five bottom-line positions (as reported by RNZ) is:
Regulating lobbying and capping political donations to “clean up politics”.
Party leader Qiulae Wong said, when announcing the five positions:
“New Zealanders deserve to know who is trying to influence their government, and no one should be able to buy disproportionate political influence.”
Can party negotiators be advised but not influenced while they try to shape the next government’s policy programme?
But Qiulae Wong will not identify two of her advisers.
The New Zealand Herald today reports:
The Opportunity Party says two anonymous public servants on its policy committee have appropriately managed their conflicts of interest, but is refusing to disclose details of their arrangements with their employers, and has back-tracked on their involvement in potential coalition negotiations.
As the Herald reminds us, Opportunity’s constitution gives the policy committee sole responsibility for developing the party’s policy.
The committee is made up of four members, including Wong and incoming MP Jessica Hammond, who was a public servant before being elected to Parliament.
Wong said the two others, who she has previously refused to name, are also public servants and need to remain anonymous.
Asked whether the party would make public the names of those two potential coalition negotiators, in the interest of transparency, Wong said the party “haven’t agreed as a team whether we would make that transparent”.
After the election, at a media stand-up on her first day at Parliament, Wong was asked whether it was appropriate for public servants to be involved in potential coalition negotiations.
Her response:
“They have been in their public servant roles up until now because we haven’t had an official team, so we are now constructing that team, and we will have those policy advisers who will be working for us as part of that team.”
Did they plan to leave their public service jobs and join the party’s parliamentary team as staffers?
Wong said they were “working through that at the moment”.
And then:
Questioned as to whether they had disclosed their roles on the policy committee to their employers, Wong said: “We haven’t determined who is going to be part of coalition negotiations at the moment because we haven’t had a first official caucus meeting yet.”
Later that day, the party held its first caucus meeting.
Afterwards, the Herald interviewed Wong again and sought clarification on whether the anonymous public servant policy advisers would be part of negotiations, as she had previously claimed.
Wong said the caucus had confirmed the negotiating team would be made up of herself, deputy leader Daniel Eb and chief of staff Iain Lees-Galloway, but would also bring in their parliamentary staff and other caucus members for consultation as required.
Asked whether the two policy committee members were joining the party in Parliament as staff, Wong said she would “rather not name them”.
“I’m sure all those people will have their LinkedIn updated in due course, so yeah, that will be all public eventually,” she said.
Asked again whether they had declared their roles on the policy committee, the party said it would come back with confirmation.
The party provided the Herald with a statement yesterday saying it “does not publicly disclose the individual details of members serving on its internal Policy Committee”.
“We are satisfied that our internal appointment and governance processes, including the early identification and management of potential conflicts of interest, have been followed appropriately,” a spokesman for the party said.
The spokesman said the party had confirmed that the individuals had addressed their disclosure obligations.
“The particulars of those disclosures and any employment-related arrangements are matters between the individuals and their respective agencies.
“We respect the privacy of those who contribute to our party and won’t be providing further details about individual committee members,” he said.
Transparency loomed large in Opportunity’s Clean Up Politics policies.
Opportunity will hard-wire honesty, transparency, and genuine public participation into our democracy, so that corruption and the abuse of power cannot take hold.
Alongside establishing an anti-corruption body, Opportunity said it would upgrade day-to-day integrity rules, including:
- Official Information Act reform: narrower withholding grounds, strengthening the public interest balancing test, enforceable timeframes for actually providing documents and binding order-making powers for the Ombudsman.
We await with deep interest the Opportunity explanation that reconciles secrecy about who is advising it with transparency around influence on government.
Bob Edlin is a veteran journalist and editor for the Point of Order blog HERE.

No comments:
Post a Comment
Thank you for joining the discussion. Breaking Views welcomes respectful contributions that enrich the debate. Please ensure your comments are not defamatory, derogatory or disruptive. We appreciate your cooperation.