Pages

▼

Sunday, November 22, 2026

John McLean: The Git That Keeps Giving


Palmer pokes his big empty head above the parapet, yet again

Sir Geoffrey Plonker continues to pop up. This time, he’s corralled a motley assortment of fellow-ish travelers into signing an “Open Letter” to “members of New Zealand’s new Parliament”. The letter calls for New Zealand’s next Parliament to change the nation’s Mixed Member Proportional (MMP) electoral system.

You can read the letter here:  Open Letter

I’ve previously covered Geoffrey’s life-long mission to undermine and dismantle New Zealand’s current Parliamentary democracy.

WOE BETIDE US WHEN PARLIAMENT’S WORDS NO LONGER MATTER

John McLean  19 June 2025



As a child, I believed my grandmother simply started knitting, without an end in mind, and on each occasion an unforeseen woolen item would magically take shape.
Read full story


The letter’s criticism is that, on the current numbers, it appears that the composition of NZ’s next Parliament will not be exactly proportionate to the outcome of voters’ party (non-electoral) votes. Hence the letter’s bold heading, Keep the “P” in MMP.

And there’s a cornel of inconsequential truth here.

Below is each party’s percentage of the party vote and its percentage of seats in Parliament, showing the differentials:



These differentials are nothing new. They result from the simple reality that, under MMP, voters have two votes; a vote for an electorate Member of Parliament and another vote for one’s preferred political party (one’s so-called “party list” vote).

Discerning readers will note the grossest distortion resulting from the election – that the Māori Party will achieve almost seven times the number of Parliamentarians that it would have if the composition of Parliament were decided entirely on proportion of the party vote (and without the party vote 5% threshold for entry into Parliament). Without the Māori electorates, the Māori Party would of course not be represented in Parliament at all.




From the very beginning of the electoral campaign, the Māori Party cunningly advocated, in each Māori electorate, for electorate vote Māori Party/party vote Greens or Labour. This split vote strategy significantly increased the chances of a Labour/Greens/ Māori Party/Opportunity coalition Government, and may still succeed when the final vote count is announced on Friday, 27 November.

Increased party voting for the Greens, resulting from the Māori Party’s vote splitting strategy, will give the Greens an extra two seats in Parliament. Palmer and his antidemocratic ilk don’t do irony, but there’s a rich irony here. The Leftists are only in contention to govern because of the Māori Party’s overt voting splitting strategy – the very strategy that the supercilious signatories are whingeing about.

All the bemoaned voting is entirely within the rules. There’s nothing illegitimate at work. No electoral system is perfect. New Zealanders, and some New Zealand political parties, are simply becoming more savvy about strategic voting.

The options that Palmer & his fellow Poops propose in their letter, in order to address their invented systemic flaw, are revealing…

“Increase the number of list MPs or reduce the number of electorate MPs so that the proportion of list seats in Parliament is higher and can more effectively ensure proportionality between parties”

This is an entreaty to make MMP more about party votes and less about electing local electorate MPs. It would increase the number of MPs who are not, personally, directly elected. Elitist intellectual snobs like Palmer are all into this stuff i.e., distancing the voting public further from their elected representatives and diluting direct democracy. If the last election demonstrates anything, it’s that National Party voters rejected its elite list MPs i.e., senior National MPs who come in on the list and are not elected in their electorates. Nicola Willis, Chris Bishop, Paul Goldsmith…all gone. Good riddance.

The supercilious signatories to the letter pick the “P” and deliberately ignore the “MM” (Mixed Member). The Mixed indicates the dual votes that every New Zealander enjoys and can cast differently. The Member is the electorate vote, that ghastly element that connects voters to their electorate MPs and, to a greater or lesser degree, results in disproportionality. Member voting was what New Zealand’s former electoral system, First Past the Post (FPP), was all about.

“Combine the proportional vote and the vote for your local representative so there is not the same split vote effect”

This is cynical, thinly veiled advocacy for the abolition of MMP. The right to cast one’s electorate and party votes in different directions is integral to MMP. Without that, it’s all proportional, with electorate MPs a thing of the past.

“Allow one or two overhang seats per party, but rule out large disproportionate overhangs through the German approach of requiring parties to have enough party votes to cover their electorate wins”

This is weak sauce, diluted MMP, where a voter’s electorate vote is explicitly subordinated to the voter’s party vote. Under this variant, a candidate could receive the most electorate votes, win his or her constituency, but nevertheless fail to enter Parliament because his or her party has insufficient party votes. That’s complete crapulence, resulting in “vacant” constituencies. Electorates would be entirely denuded of their own elected representatives. Deciding which electorate winners survive would require yet more arbitrary rules.

“Adjust the voting rules in Parliament so a party’s voting strength in Parliament is based on its party vote not its total MPs”

This is where the Letterites show their true form. Preposterously, they’re suggesting as an option, ostensibly sincerely, that MPs directly elected by their constituents in their electorate could be stripped of their rights to vote in Parliament. Electorate MPs would sit in Parliament, utterly neutered. Pull the other one.

The signatories mainly comprise the usual pseudo-intellectual Leftists e.g., Geddis, Rashbooke, Palmer….



But there are a few who should know better. For example, Dr Oliver Hartwich, Executive Director of the New Zealand Initiative. But then again, the NZ Initiative has opposed the abolition of Māori seats in Parliament.

INITIATIVE LACKING ON MĀORI SEATS

John McLean  6 November 2025


Nick Clark

On its website The New Zealand Initiative claims, “We are the organisation to sketch pathways towards a better future”.
Read full story


Could Oliver’s Army be Fabian wolves in sheep’s clothing?

Then there’s Dr Claire Robinson, who purports to be an impartial political commentator but has also shown her true colors.



Because, boiled down, the Open Letter is simply an expression of sour grapes. Most overtly, some deep down, all the signatories wanted a Labour-led neo-Marxist government. Their chagrin is that, despite frightful institutional and media bias, they may not get it. Ordinary, hard-working, clear-thinking New Zealanders have had a gut full of being talked down to by the likes of pontificating Palmer. People who pretend to want to improve New Zealand’s democracy, but secretly want to end it.

John McLean is a citizen typist and enthusiastic amateur who blogs at John's Substack where this article was sourced

No comments:

Post a Comment

Thank you for joining the discussion. Breaking Views welcomes respectful contributions that enrich the debate. Please ensure your comments are not defamatory, derogatory or disruptive. We appreciate your cooperation.