Pages

▼

Thursday, November 19, 2026

Perspective with Heather du Plessis-Allan: Do we need to get rid of the overhang?


It was bound to happen, wasn't it?

A group of political academics and researchers has written an open letter calling for a fix to stop overhangs from happening again. They're worried this could be about to take off. Now that people have figured out how to create an overhang on either side of politics, the academics fear it could spark an arms race to see who can create the biggest one and, in doing so, win the election.

They're concerned Te Pāti Māori might try to maximise its potential overhang at the next election, which could be as many as seven seats. People on the right might try to maximise the National Party's overhang, which is considerably larger than seven, I can tell you.

At its worst, the prediction is overhangs could lead to a Parliament of 191 MPs instead of the 120 we're supposed to have.

I guess the question I'm asking right now is: why?

We've had overhangs in Parliament for 21 years. The last one took Parliament to 122 seats. At times it was 123; it's complicated but it was essentially a two-seat overhang created by the Māori Party.

A generous explanation for why this has become an issue now is that this is the first time the system has been deliberately and transparently gamed. In previous cases, it happened organically. This time, people actively tried to make it happen.

A less generous explanation is that this is the first time the right has benefited from it. If it continues, the right could end up winning elections more often because it has the potential to generate a larger overhang than the left.

Personally, I'm not hung up on the overhang. Frankly, I don't care whether it's there or not. I don't particularly want to pay for 191 MPs and all their associated costs, so perhaps we should get rid of it.

But if we're going to abolish overhangs in the name of proportionality, then I'd like to see that traded for the removal of the Māori seats because they also affect proportionality and have done so for years.

In fact, they're the reason overhangs started in the first place. It was the Māori Party winning Māori electorates that created these overhangs and the Māori seats have been influencing proportionality for years.

They also affect the proportionality of Māori representation in Parliament. Twenty-seven percent of the new Parliament is made up of Māori MPs. That's almost double their share of the general population.

Now, that doesn't really bother me but it does make those seats seem largely irrelevant, doesn't it? They were originally established to ensure there was Māori representation in Parliament. That's no longer a problem. We don't need them anymore.

So let's do it. Sure, let's get rid of the overhang. But if we're going to do that, let's do all the things that need to be done. Let's not just fix the one issue that happens to skew things in favour of the right.

Heather du Plessis-Allan is a journalist and radio broadcaster who hosts Newstalk ZB's weekday Drive-Time Show – where this article was sourced.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Thank you for joining the discussion. Breaking Views welcomes respectful contributions that enrich the debate. Please ensure your comments are not defamatory, derogatory or disruptive. We appreciate your cooperation.