Pages

▼

Saturday, November 21, 2026

Roger Partridge: Shrinking to Greatness


New Zealand's two largest political parties have made good progress towards becoming smaller ones. On election night, neither National nor Labour reached 30 percent. Together they managed just 58.6 percent, a record low for their combined vote.

Years of careful work have gone into making the parties small targets. Too many principles can frighten voters. Clear policies give opponents something to aim at.

Labour's approach under Chris Hipkins was described by government relations adviser Georgina Stylianou as 'controlled visibility, or a minimum viable opposition.' When the government is unpopular, there is no need to distract voters by telling them what you would do. They might discover a preference for the problems they already have.

In Britain and Australia, the small-target strategy helped Keir Starmer and Anthony Albanese win clear parliamentary majorities. Hipkins imported the strategy. Unfortunately, he could not import the electoral system.

Under MMP, a third of the vote generally buys only a third of the seats. By election night, Labour was so small a target that voters had trouble seeing it.

National under Christopher Luxon took similar care. It preferred policies other parties had already offered to voters. Why risk something new when you can recycle someone else's ideas?

Even National's campaign slogan, 'No new taxes', came with a claim of prior ownership from ACT. When National adopted New Zealand First's Foodstuffs break-up, Winston Peters called them the 'Copy Nats'.

National also found a use for Labour's old compulsory KiwiSaver policy. Workers would be compelled to save by a party committed to individual choice. National saw no contradiction. Voters could still choose which party would force them to save.

Anyone uneasy about buying a policy from ACT, New Zealand First or even Labour could now get it through National. Except that voters happy with the originals could buy direct. New Zealand First rose from 6.1 to 9.8 percent and ACT from 8.6 to 10.9, while National fell from 38 to 29. National had done the advertising for its partners.

Both major parties will face calls for clearer beliefs. But a party could spend months defending a proposal it need never have made. Someone might even expect it to be carried out.

Better to leave the difficult policies to the smaller parties. With nearly 60 percent of the vote between them, Labour and National still have a great deal left to lose.

Roger Partridge is chairman and a co-founder of The New Zealand Initiative and is a senior member of its research team. He led law firm Bell Gully as executive chairman from 2007 to 2014. This article was sourced HERE

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

Smaller parties? They don’t have any kind of mandate. Look at what happened with the bizarre waste of taxpayer money with the virtue signaling treaty principles bill. This is no way to run a country. 8% (or 10%, whatever) parties need to know their place and it isn’t policy leadership.

Valid Point said...

Anon 9.34 misses the point of MMP. The smaller parties aren't 8-10%. Once they're in a bloc, they make up over 40% of it, giving them the weight to add more ministers and shape policy decisions. Now, whether you agree that is right or wrong is a moot point. It's how the system delivers our government.

Post a Comment

Thank you for joining the discussion. Breaking Views welcomes respectful contributions that enrich the debate. Please ensure your comments are not defamatory, derogatory or disruptive. We appreciate your cooperation.