Most people see James Cook as an iconic figure whose legacy in New Zealand is a modern, progressive, multi-cultural society. However, a small number of Maori extremists see him as a negative influence and claim he committed many crimes against the Polynesian inhabitants of the time. They do not disclose any evidence or sources and their case is flimsy at best.
In 1768, the barque Endeavour, captained by James Cook, sailed out of the English port of Plymouth in Devon. Its destination was the island of Tahiti, with the purpose of studying the 1769 transit of Venus. However, he was also instructed to do much more. This would be the first of three epic voyages to the Pacific and in the process Cook would visit every continent on the planet.
First landfall
You are … to observe the Genius, Temper, Disposition and Number of the Natives, if there be any and endeavour by all proper means to cultivate a Friendship and Alliance with them, making them presents of such Trifles as they may Value inviting them to Traffick, and Shewing them every kind of Civility and Regard… –Secret instructions to Captain Cook
Following his instructions, Cook established friendly relations with the people of Tahiti in 1769 and he was hopeful of doing the same with the people of New Zealand. Unfortunately the Natives he met in what he would call Poverty Bay on October 8, were aggressive when he first landed and on the following day. As a result of the hostility and misunderstandings over ownership and theft, six Maori were killed.
He did however establish good relations with the Natives in other parts of the country.
Cook’s achievements
James Cook and botanist Joseph Banks introduced new animals and plants to the country, and their widely disseminated journals told the world about the nature and resources of New Zealand.
As a result of his explorations, the work of scientists on board, and the paintings of the official artists, the lands around the world’s biggest ocean became known throughout Europe and America. So it was inevitable that the exploitation of New Zealand’s resources by European people would follow, as well as settlement and governance.
The Treaty of Waitangi and western development saved Maori from possible extinction. The Treaty ended the endemic inter-tribal warfare which may have killed as many as 40,000–50,000 in the first four decades of the nineteenth century. As a consequence of the Treaty, Maori women were freed from a life of insecurity where rape, abduction, slavery and murder following battles, were common.
There were breaches of the Treaty on both sides in the years following, mainly by Maori, but ultimately the people descended from the early Polynesian migrants have benefitted from the colonisation, economic growth, infrastructure development and social progress that were the long-term outcomes of Cook’s comprehensive reports on the country.
Over the last 200 years Maori people has had access to the cash economy, modern housing, hospitals, schools, retail outlets, transport, entertainment, sport and technology.
A great man who had a huge impact
Cook’s arrival in New Zealand is one of the most important events in our history. His charting or our shores and the reports, paintings and sketches from his three voyages set in train the modern development of the nation.
It is very appropriate that we should remember the iconic English explorer on the occasion of his 296th birthday.
Roger Childs is a retired teacher who taught History, Social Studies and Geography for 40 years. This article was first published HERE
8 comments:
If I recall Cook was a man of great restraint and would often under threat tread carefully. He was killed in Hawaii because he broke the code of not touching a royal.....
He was not the colonialist he is made out to be but he is an easy crutch on which to lean upon.
Cook is on the " woke black list" - and more widely than NZ. The reality of his remarkable achievements is cancelled by fiction.
it is just possible there was a Billy T among the maori and Cook's translator failed to realise the threats to kill were a joke. The notion that there was a misunderstanding at Gisborne is an artful modern construct by maori. Craftily utiised to sabotage the visit of the Endeavour a few years ago. Just as one of the maori took a risk snatching a sword from a sailor, so would a sailor snatching a mere have incurred a reduced life expectancy. Cook was even more indulgent of maori than recent governments. He forgave the Sounds tribe who murdered and devoured the crew of his sister ship.
Thanks for the reminder Roger. James Cook was a good man. I respect his memory and deprecate any, who through ignorance and ingratitude, think ill of him.
The myth that Maori were the "world's best navigators" is B.S. Cook was a far better navigator, and European methods of navigation are superior to traditional Polynesian. I'm speaking from 50 years of ocean experience in 5 yachts and 70,000 NM of offshore cruising and racing.
One example of the B.S. that part-Maori and their woke fellow travelers are pushing is the assertion by an NZ woman pseudo-Maori academic (you know one with the chin tats) that Maori discovered Antarctica on the basis of a Cook Island story (originally translated by a European in the early 1940's) that mentioned "white stuff" on the sea. This poser got a $50,000 grant to spout this nonsense.
Another example: I was anchored at Anchorage in Abel Tasman Bay last summer when 3 large double hulled replicas of traditional Polynesian sailing craft came in the bay (under outboard power) and anchored close by. They were due the next day at a big Polynesian celebration in Motueka. They had sailed down in stages from the N. Island, very carefully choosing fair-weather windows. The sailing rigs they all used for this offshore voyaging were actually copies of European style rigs, NOT the traditional rigs. After they anchored, they proceeded to change to traditional style looking rigs using extra spars that they carried on deck. This was obviously done to impress the woke gullible folks at the celebration, most of whom would not have a clue about sailing. Cook sailed so far South he sighed ice bergs yet never lost a man in those extreme latitudes. How many Maori craft were lost at sea before a few made it to New Zealand? If they were such great navigators, why didn't they push on to Australia?
After Cook's experiences all over the Pacific, he considered the Maori to be the most aggressive, and difficult to deal with of all the Pacific tribes. Cook showed huge forbearance in his dealings with them; refused to do utu on the Maori who cannibalized his crew.
Some Maori diehards, like children, refuse to face up to the reality that if it wasn't for Captains Cooks stupendous achievements, they would not be enjoying the life they live today
Hawaians do not regard Cook with favour since they believe his crew introduced VD to their islands. Perhaps they feel guilty because one of them killed him?
The modern stone age people dream of something that never was.
Post a Comment