Transcript:
Now, the other scandal I want to bring forward to you this morning… You've heard me talk in recent days, weeks - and I'll continue to talk about it - of the Marxist critical theory takeover of New Zealand institutions which started on our academic institutions sadly, and has now spread like a virus, like the Black Death really, through the intellectual and academic and public sectors of this country.
Well, the latest to be infected by it is the New Zealand Medical Council who have just published their draft called - now what's it called? I’d better get the name right. I don't want to offend anybody - Hauora Maori (*Maori heath and wellbeing).
It's a two to three page missive, very similar to the ones (except it didn't take 24 pages for the army) that the New Zealand Army top brass gave to all the army personnel last month. Very similar to that except they've put it on two or three pages, not 24. And it's from the New Zealand Medical Council to all people who work within its practices - all staff. And it is designed (and everything I'm about to quote to you is a direct quote. I'm not making this up. I'm not paraphrasing it) to advance Maori equity - as distinct from any other equity - and dismantle power imbalances.
That's what it says it's going to do straight away. That's its intention for every member of the health staff, public and private, in this country who is under the auspices of the New Zealand Medical Council.
What you immediately get with its instruction to advance Maori equity and dismantle power imbalances, is Marxist critical theory that attempts to overtake the medical profession in general. The buzzwords that they use are unfair, unsafe and equity. I'll come to that in a moment. But they seek all medical professionals to “engage in critical self-reflection to identify and address bias”. So in other words, there is this implicit belief that anybody, particularly non-Maori working in the public health sector of this country is biased and that they are to use “their professional privilege and influence to work in partnership with Maori to dismantle unfair systems”.
So the aim then is to politicize the public health sector in this country and to overthrow the status quo. It's there in the preamble to this particular draft. The medical council says it recognises the status of Maori as Tangata Whenua of Aotearoa New Zealand. It does a lot more than that - it puts them on a pedestal and says you are the most important people in New Zealand.
And then it says this: historical and ongoing colonisation (so apparently the colonisation is still ongoing in 2026) means that Maori are prevented from accessing resources that promote good health. I'm sorry - can you just explain to me any Maori folk in this country who are prevented by ongoing colonisation from accessing public health facilities in this country? I mean that is clearly a lie. It's a form of ideological madness. But there it is stated as fact by the New Zealand Medical Council in its instruction to all health practitioners.
It goes on to say that Maori experience higher exposure to health harms compared to non-Maori. They are over-represented in most socio-economic deprived neighbourhoods. That's fine. That's a fact. But they then link that to historical and ongoing colonisation, and the fact that we've decided that we're actually going to create Maori as second-class citizens by preventing them access to resources that promote good health.
They also say to health practitioners: it's important you understand and recognise inherent indigenous rights that Maori hold as Tangata Whenua, to health, self-determination, and equity.
So you're again politicising the health workforce of this country. They're now not responsible for treating a Maori person who just comes and says what's your ailment? They've actually got to make sure that they support them in their self-determination crusade, whatever that might be, and whatever equity considerations the politicos at the New Zealand Medical Council dream up for them.
So, the aim is to, as I said, politicise the public and private health forces of this country to revolution and to overthrow the existing order in this country. That is what the New Zealand Medical Council's draft intends them to do.
And then it goes on to say this, and this is just serious - I'm not sure there's word salads in this world; there are hallucinations and AI, but I think that those two concepts have merged brilliantly in the New Zealand Medical Council’s next phrase. In your practice - this is the demand that the Medical Council makes of every health practitioner in your practice - you must (it's not you will, you may, you could, we think you should), recognize and show respect for one, the diversity of Maori identities. What does that mean? The diversity of Maori identities - as distinct from any other identities, I assume.
Two, Maori experiences, must be recognised and shown respect.
And three expressions of culture - even if those cultures are obviously causing health problems:
You must approach each Maori patient and whanau with a willingness to listen and learn.
So who knew that you'd head into your medical practitioner - every Maori patient in this country - and it's your job to instruct the patient … sorry obviously the dumb ignorant and overprivileged person who is in actual fact treating you for your ailment.
And it's important to ensure - I'm saying all this again, this is all direct quotes - that the care you provide results in equitable outcomes for Maori - wait for this - compared to non-Maori. So your primary responsibility is to ensure that you're treating Maori as your primary consideration and that their equity is more important than non-Maori.
“So what, the rest of us get left to die then do we?” - exactly. I mean so it doesn't matter whether you're a Pacific Islander or Indian of South African extraction, of Pakeha, of English, Chinese, Filipino, your equity, the fairness, isn't as important as treating the Maori patient.
“So is that the new triage rules at ED now, if you’re Maori, through you go?” - if the New Zealand Medical Council gets its way with this particular draft to all its health practitioners.
And finally this: what is Hauora Maori? And they very kindly define what that is because that's what we're talking about here. Maori health and well-being is defined as Hauora Maori’s definition, as physical, mental, emotional, social and spiritual dimensions that support holistic health and well-being for the individual, whanau, the community and the environment.
So suddenly the doctor has become not somebody who practices medicine. They are responsible for the emotional support of Maori patients, the social support of them, their spiritual support for God's sake. They are also responsible for not just the individual you're treating, but the individual's whanau, the community, and I don't know how this got in there, the environment as well.
This is the indoctrination, and there's only one word that I can use in my entire history of public life, and of history, and of philosophy, and of political philosophy and this is state communism. This is old-fashioned Trotskyite, let's convert the masses, but we'll start on the professional classes first, communism.
And the aim is to turn every health practitioner in this country into an agent to overthrow the status quo and order, and to impose a new set of priorities that are inherently Maori and deal with the entire dimension including the spiritual, the social and the emotional.
That directive has gone out to every health practitioner as a draft for them to comment on. But can I tell you if that becomes - and it's already got the imprimatur of the New Zealand Medical Council - if that were to become the aegis under which doctors, nurses and anybody in primary health operates in this country, there'll be a lot more than just Jacinda Ardern and Clark Gayford looking for a home on the northern suburbs of Sydney. I would suggest to you the entire country will go.
Writer and former broadcaster Michael Laws, who served as an MP and Mayor, is now a councillor on the Otago Regional Council, and talkback host on The Platform.
15 comments:
The FSU recently sent us an email urging people to express their views to the NZMC. So I did. That's one way to counter this as we can't keep leaving just a few people to fight our battles. I forwarded my perspective to Simeon Brown as well. Is he actually aware we are now classed as Maori and non-Maori in the health system? If so, nothing has changed under this coalition government. In fact, talking to many acquaintances who constantly have medical procedures deferred, we are no further ahead. I believe too much emphasis is being put on these inane cultural requirements and not enough on actual strait forward health strategies.
A fish rots from the head down. So the Chair of the NZMC must bear primary responsibility for this debacle which insults both the entire NZ medical profession and all its patients . Or, will Maori ancestry exonerate this official?
This is union sanctioned. I saw plenty of nurses and teachers on that protest down Queen Street holding maori flags and socialists for nz flags. No actual nz flags in sight. Just like in Germany in the 1930s, people were easily brainwashed. The same appears to be true in nz in 2026. It is quite frankly embarrassing. The marxist unions have infiltrated everything. How will the said dictors know if you have naori dna or not? And if you do will they have to hold your hand and say a karakia before the consult can begin?
I made my submissions to both the nursing and medical council draft codes and both pointed out the dire impact on the ability of nz to retain and attract doctors and nurses- plus clause 7 of the medical one for doctors also subjects doctors to a patient survey and recertification if they fail the subjective survey of whether or not their Maori patients achieved healthcare equity….i pointed out that the survey would simply mean that doctors would find all sorts of reasons why they shouldn’t treat Maori patients in particular in cases where the “equitable” outcome component is likely to fail because the patient drinks/smokes/ lives on kfc….& simply won’t recover after their medical treatment as well as a person who doesn’t drink/smoke/eat kfc….it places doctors in a situation where they shouldn’t touch those cases where people are sick (& maori) because they will need to be recertified all the time.
The whole thing is a disaster that should see heads chopped off by simeon brown yet where is he?
Is it a case of where is Simeon Brown, or more a case of who is holding him back?
"The raising of nurses’ critical awareness of the structural conditions experienced by Māori, including ongoing colonisation and systemic injustices, requires that Te Tiriti o Waitangi is a natural part of nursing practice. The expected outcomes for nursing and Māori health practice are that all nurses will be active Tiriti partners as Crown agents, and will be culturally safe, advocate for systemic change, challenge racism and contribute to the delivery of health services that advance equitable outcomes for Māori."
The foregoing a direct quote out of the latest "GUIDANCE FOR NURSING EDUCATION AND PRACTICE"
So, like education and everything else these days in "Aotearoa", Maori are the primary concern for "equitable outcomes". Never mind all the other citizens of NEW ZEALAND, Maori are to come first and foremost, period. Just like the Medical Council's missive, it's all based on a false ideology about the Treaty and a patent bias to members of one race.
Is NZ systemically racist? The expletive, once stated by Taika Waititi to that question, now proven beyond all doubt. As for the Councils of our Medics and Nurses, what absolute DISGRACES! Heads surely need to roll.
Ascribing this intervention from the NZ Medical Council as inspired by "Marxist critical theory" or "old-fashioned Trotskyite communism" is just a lazy slur, coming from ignorance or bad faith, or both.
Genuine Marxists or communists, Trotskyite or any other variety, would have nothing to do with this approach of Medical Council.
We all know the statistics - Maori have lower life expectancy, higher rates of contracting a whole range of illnesses etc., than the rest of the population. Marxists would put this down to class rather than race, although the influence of historic racial discrimination must also be also a factor. But whatever the explanation for its origin, any decent society would find this situation unacceptable and seek to "close the gaps," as Helen Clark's government once put it.
How? Certainly not by top-down pronouncements from woksterist middle class bureaucrats, shaking a censorious finger at medical professionals, most of whom do more through their daily work to try and meet the health needs of all the people, including Maori, than the virtue signalers in Wellington ever will. No, getting rid of the disparities in health outcomes between different segments of the population will have to be part of a movement of wider social change, driven from the bottom up by working people themselves.
A body is a body.
Stop inferring that some of them are special as they have any amount of long term Taiwanese DNA.
This is politics, pure and simple.
Nothing to do with health.
What has Luxon or the National Party got to say about this travesty ?
Being somewhat of a purist when it comes to language and labels, I am very sympathetic to Terry Coggan's case. I have noticed many times on this website that terms such as 'socialist' and 'Marxist' tend to be used as derogative put-downs rather than being used properly in the sense of their literal meaning.
However, NEO-Marxism is certainly the parent of 'critical [race] theory'. I doubt whether Karl Marx would have had much time for it, but Antonio Gramsci certainly did.
It is worthy of note that in the final couple of decades of the USSR the Soviets strongly supported (in some instances, in military terms as well as through propagandising) indigenous movements in developing countries that sought to boot the 'colonisers' out. So we had what was still an officially Marxist-Leninist government taking actions guided by Neo-Marxism (specifically the Structuralist version appearing in the 1960s).
And that is where you go wrongTerry Coggan, thinking that it'll be driven from the bottom-up by working people. That's the issue - a significant many of them are not working, let alone get themselves to a doctor, medicine dispenser, or vaccinator in reasonable time. It's overdue that they took some personal responsibility for what they consume, be it food stuffs or drugs; got some exercise; and sought advice promptly when their body signals a change. But, no. Far easier to claim colonisation and put the responsibility and blame on someone else. Meantime they'll continue to eat junk food, take drugs, avoid doctors and vaccinations, and maim and kill their own children. Moreover, most violent crime is perpetrated by Maori on Maori, and how does one think that impacts on their health and mortality stats? If they don't give a brass razoo about their own kind, more especially their own kids, why should it fall to everyone else to carry the can?
Maori experience at KFC and McDonald's must be acknowledged and shown respect? Warning: health alert....
We are supposed to be encouraging valuable skilled medical people from offshore to make NZ their home.
Does the Medical Council expect anyone of these people to acceed to their demands that they treat pigmented people with greater priority and respect because they claim to be indigenous?
Even thinking like that, to the point of putting that in writing classifies the leaders of the Medical Council as evil people - the sort that were prevalent in the Third Reich.
I totally agree with anonymous at 4.13. Healthy living is a lifestyle choice. If people are grossly overweight and eat abundant takeaways they will suffer consequences. Smoking, drug taking and alcohol intake also have consequences. We can't be responsible for others lifestyle choices. Our enlightened society is constantly pointing out the consequences of certain actions.
Honestly Terry, why do Maori have lower life expectancy rates? Since "colonisation" their life expectancy has increased dramatically. I know many non- complaining "non-Maori" who require urgent medical intervention. This, as I told the MCNZ and Simeon Brown, is apartheid in action.
Ah, anon@5.18, good point! Another systemic colonialist oversight - not printing those obviously necessary 'Health Warnings' in te reo. How could we've expected a different outcome? My, we do reap what we sow, for all that protection was there in the Treaty - wasn't it?
"Apartheid in action", Janine, indeed it is - and I'm very pleased you told them so!
Post a Comment
Thank you for joining the discussion. Breaking Views welcomes respectful contributions that enrich the debate. Please ensure your comments are not defamatory, derogatory or disruptive. We appreciate your cooperation.