Pages

Wednesday, March 19, 2025

Karl du Fresne: Why shouldn't ACT have a go? The Left's been at it for decades


David Seymour’s announcement that ACT may stand candidates in council elections triggered a discussion on Nick Mills’ talkback show on Newstalk ZB this morning about whether political parties should get involved in local government. But that mischievous genie escaped from the bottle a very long time ago.

The Labour Party has long regarded local politics as fertile ground, both at district and regional levels, and always fields a slate of Wellington City Council candidates with the party’s formidable organisational resources behind them.

Frank Kitts, Wellington’s longest-serving mayor (1956-74), was elected on the Labour ticket; so were Jim Belich and Fran Wilde. Four of the current councillors owe their loyalty to Labour, though only one (Teri O’Neill) acknowledges her allegiance in her profile on the council’s website.

Wellington Regional Council chair Daran Ponter is a Labour man too, as is Lower Hutt mayor Campbell Barry. So Labour is a powerful force in local government, though it largely flies under the radar in terms of public visibility.

Then there are the Greens. Wellington got its first Green councillor, Stephen Rainbow, way back in 1989. Rainbow has moved a long way politically since then, shifting to the libertarian right to the extent that the current government felt comfortable appointing him as chief human rights commissioner, but there has been a more-or-less constant Green Party presence at the Wellington council table in the past few decades – to say nothing of two disastrous Green mayors, Celia Wade-Brown and Tory Whanau (who is Green in all but official designation).

So what about the other side? For decades Wellington had the conservative Citizens’ and Ratepayers’ Association, which was widely viewed as a National Party proxy. Its main purpose was to keep Labour out of power, in which role it was often successful. Sir Michael Fowler was a popular Citizens’ mayor (1974-83) and the Citizens’ Association often commanded a majority around the council table. But Ian Lawrence (1983-86) was the last Citizens’ mayor and the Citizens’ Association now seems defunct, not having stood a candidate since 1997. National itself has never stood candidates in council elections.

So now ACT is thinking about having a go – and why not? We should brace ourselves for howls of outrage, but ACT would only be doing what the Left has done (and very effectively) for decades.

Karl du Fresne, a freelance journalist, is the former editor of The Dominion newspaper. This article was republished from his blog which can be found at karldufresne.blogspot.co.nz.

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

Thanks Karl for printing all those inconvenient truths.....they will come in handy as the howls from he left, watermelons and the partly maori party begin in earnest......

Joanne W said...

Auckland has a group called Communities and Residents, which used to be Citizens and Ratepayers. These groups are National - orientated: indeed Deputy Mayor Desley Simpson is actually married to the former Chair of National, Peter Goodfellow. Labour stands as Labour in some wards / boards, or combines with the Greens in others as City Vision. This is all business as usual, so ACT adding their own candidates would just be offering a quite predictable alternative.