Tuesday, February 27, 2024

Bruce Cotterill: It's a big mess. We need to be patient.

It hasn’t taken long has it.

Since returning from the summer break I’ve been watching the reaction to the new government. There is already plenty of criticism. I’m hearing and reading views that they’re not moving quickly enough, that the new PM is not aggressive enough and that the new Police Minister is too soft.

Hang on a minute! I think we’re being impatient.

A lot of the early criticism is coming from individuals and organisations that established themselves as campaigners against the policies of the last Labour government. Those campaigners variously had misgivings about Three Waters, co-governance, education, crime and plenty of other aspects of our lives that they thought were poorly managed.

The great majority of those organisations and their spokespeople appeared to receive what they wanted when last year’s general election delivered a new government. That new government was sworn in on November 27th, 88 days ago.

They brought with them a new 100 day plan with relatively aggressive timelines. It featured plain simple wording that was easily understood with objectives such as “repeal Labour’s Ute tax by 31 Dec 2023” and “cancel Labour’s Auckland Light Rail project”. A large component of the objectives set out in that 100 day plan were what many of those anti-government campaigners had been seeking before the election.

And yet, here they are , just a couple of months later, in the cafes, on the street, various media vehicles and on social media, continuing their campaigns for change and complaining that the new government isn’t doing what it said it would do.

From the outside looking in, that 100 day plan seems to have enabled plenty of clarity and focus, and despite parliamentary process typically being appallingly slow, the government is making real progress on the matters they campaigned on.

A number of the new government’s major policies have been initiated. Three Waters is gone. Light rail and the ute tax too. Unravelling the financially disastrous Te Pukenga polytech merger is underway.

Those 88 days have included weekends and the Christmas break in a country notorious for the length of it’s summer closedown. And yet, we are receiving good communication and seeing real progress on the topics the new government stated as priorities.

Transformation in any organisation is difficult. It takes time. You need to be very clear on what you are trying to achieve and you have to convince the people who you need on board to take you where you want to go. Often you have to unravel a mess before you can start building the new way.

But transformation in government is doubly difficult. Firstly, governments and the bureaucracies that accompany them are huge organisations and operationally slow. In most cases, the parliamentarians with the plans and policies are not in direct control of the people working in those organisations, people whose support is needed to make things happen. In this instance, and as reflected in the way people voted in the capital, many of those bureaucrats will have been supporters of the previous government, having owed their job or at least their inflated salaries to the policies of the predecessor.

On top of those challenges, the previous government left behind a vast number of challenges, not the least of which was the state of the financials. Transformation is difficult at the best of times. But it’s extremely challenging when there is no money.

The Prime Minister set out some of those challenges in his State of the Nation address last weekend. Citing the state of the economy and our cost of living challenges he described our position as fragile. He talked about our biggest challenges, including the level of government spending and our inadequate productivity. He noted the importance of getting kids back to school and to have them learning the right things. And he even had a crack at those who’ve been abusing the welfare system for far too long.

The intent on these issues is difficult to argue with. Many of them are what the above mentioned ‘campaigners’ have been looking for. The already aggressive 100 day plan is well advanced after just 88 days, notwithstanding that thirty of those days have been weekends and public holidays.

There is no question that the jury is still out on the capability of this new government to deliver. It is very early days in their parliamentary term. Many of us are, quite rightly, impatient to see the improvements that we expect from them.

But we need to give them time. I’m sure that many of the ‘campaigners’, those whose soapbox became prevalent during the six years under Labour, are as impatient as the rest of us. I’m equally sure that some of them rather like their soapbox, and a reluctant to leave it behind. However, for the moment they could take a break.

In the meantime there is a massive, complex turnaround job to be done. A job that requires changes on every front. Reviews of priorities and spending. Reassessment of policies and changing of behaviours. There will be interruptions along the way, creating urgency around infrastructure and recovery.

But the long term priorities won’t change. Can’t change. We need education, productivity and a cost regime that fits our income. We need debt levels reduced so as we can invest in opportunity. And we need every New Zealander to have the opportunity to do something special with their lives.

Bruce Cotterill, a five time CEO and current Company Chairman and Director with extensive experience across a range of industries including real estate, media, financial services, technology and retail. Bruce regularly blogs on - where this article was sourced


Anonymous said...

I think David Seymour will gain in popularity and be pm next election time. He has courage and stands up to the left fools brilliantly I enjoy watching him get interviewed by dumb left media like jack tame. He just destroys them with his common sense Or on woke newshub with the green hamas party. Chloe spouts all this woke gibberish and then david's response.

DeeM said...

I'm pretty happy with what the Coalition government have achieved up to now, Bruce.
But there's one thing we need that you omitted from your article. And, it's a biggie.

It's to restore and strengthen democracy in NZ, which under Labour got a hiding. That's a massive reason Labour got rejected.
And a big part of that is to have an open debate around the Treaty Principles Bill, which simply expresses that we ALL have the same rights, as opposed to preferential treatment for part-Maori.

The big problem we have here is our PM. Rather than keep an open mind and listen to all the arguments, he has come out in the media and said his party will NOT support it past the first reading. He hasn't justified his statement.
That's a big problem for me, Bruce. A PM who won't support equal rights for all and will keep in place the racist principles we currently have.

Mr Luxon has shown that he takes the path of least resistance when pressured by the MSM and that's what he's doing now. We, the public and independent media have to heap more pressure on him to force him up the right path.
And if that involves people getting on their "soapboxes" then so be it.

Oh, and another thing I'd like. This government to tackle the blatant bias and favouritism by our state-funded media.
Without balanced coverage, the nation cannot make the best decisions, and we are being let down greviously by our current batch of Left-wing journo fanatics. They are in breach of the Charter and should be punished accordingly.

Anonymous said...

DeeM: 100% agree. As a long-time Labour supporter, I feel utterly betrayed by Labour and its anti-democratic, race-based policies that it's *still* espousing.

Heck, I wouldn't rule out voting Act at the next election if that's the only way to restore democratic government in New Zealand. (Mind you, I'm no fan of Act's economic policies, etc.)


Anonymous said...

Deem - exactly.

Anonymous said...

You're right Bruce but we're holding our cynical breath in hope that things will change. A biggie is definitely doing something to/for/with the media screeching that is deafening while undermining whatever the government is doing.
Also agree with DeeM 100%. We gotta sort the Treaty bulldust. The Treaty is not our constitution and neither the Waitangi Tribunal nor the Supreme Court write the laws in New Zealand.
Christopher Luxon needs to get it through his shiny head that the government makes and enforces the laws of our land.

Tom Logan said...

Well there's the separate Maori health system gone , the Waitangi Tribunal feeling more and more powerless every day, three waters gone, co -governance gone, the gangs starting to feel worried. And that's not all he's done in 88 days.

Mr Luxon must know how to swing the big bat after all !

Anonymous said...

No Tom, Luxon is not making any commitments to the other 85% of the population regarding removing bias and benefits for the 15% part Maori population.
Shame on him .

Tom Logan said...

Well Anonymous, the rate and breadth of change by which this Government is removing the previous Governments biases and benefits towards Maori is quite unprecedented in our political history.

How many times does Mr Luxon have to repeat things. What more does he have to do to level the playing field ? Co -governance is dead. Three waters is dead. The Maori health structure is dead. The Waitangi Tribunal neutered. Maori local body seats no longer permanent. And more to come.

The opposition parties have frothing been frothing at the mouth in Parliament the last few days. Is the Labour Party in it's death throes ? They're eating their own now, if you saw Nash's dummy spitting.

Mahuta gone, Rob Campbell gone, Kiri Allen gone. Willie Jackson, Rawiri Waititi, Debbie Ngarewa Packer and Marama Davidson running round barking like mad dogs.

Those policies of the prior government that dippy chippy didn't burn Luxon has smashed . Luxon's convinced me he's got the task in hand .

What do you want, Masseys Cossacks back ?