Pages

Saturday, October 18, 2025

John McLean: Poor Goldsmuck


Paul Goldsmith shows why The Nats are doomed as a major political party

The Broadcasting Standards Authority (BSA) has launched a surprise attack on media channel The Platform, aiming to lynch Platform head honcho Sean Plunket.

The attack has taken the form of an unlawful assertion that The Platform falls under BSA’s umbrella, such that BSA can consider complaints against The Platform. BSA’s tactic is to open the floodgates in order to drown The Platform in upheld BSA complaints.

BSA’s evil scheme was to draw The Platform into the BSA’s lethal embrace, on the sly. Broadcasting Censors Aotearoa tried to secretly tether and strangle The Platform by picking up an infantile complaint from a lame-arse Leftie named Richard Fanselow. Fanselow complained to BSA that it was racist for Sean Plunket to label Maori Tikanga as “mumbo jumbo”. BSA’s attack on free speech has been orchestrated by BSA chair, Susie Staley:



In accosting Plunket with the complaint, BSA issued The Platform with a “PROVISIONAL INTERLOCUTORY DECISION” that BSA can rain on The Platform’s free speech parade. BSA plastered “NOT FOR PUBLICATION” all over its absurd, unlawful decision, hoping The Platform would meekly submit to BSA’s hegemony. But BSA’s shenanigans have back fired big time, because Plunket decided, quite rightly, to publish BSA’s balderdash on The Platform’s website. You can read it all here:

https://theplatform.kiwi/opinions/correspondence-from-the-broadcasting-standards-authority-to-the-platform

This is Woke Cancel Culture made manifest, in full activist form. Much incisive stuff has already been written on this sad and sinister BSA attempt at media censorship domination. You can look it all up, dear readers.

My focus is on the jarring juxtaposition between the reactions to this sordid assault on free speech from NZ First Party leader Winston Peters and ACT Party leader David Seymour, on the one hand, and – on the other hand - National Party Minister for Media and Communications, Paul Goldsmith.




Winston Peters immediately announced, “Why does the Broadcasting Standards Authority think they can make up their own rules in secret meetings to act like some Soviet Era Stasi”, accusing BSA of “censorship”, “blatant overreach” and “outrageous action” and describing BSA’s bunkum as “highly concerning”.

David Seymour chimed in with:

“The Broadcasting Standards Authority has secretly decided to expand its regime to the internet. This is a power grab by unelected bureaucrats who think they can regulate speech online without any democratic mandate. It’s outrageous and unacceptable. If the BSA wants to regulate online broadcasters, it should go through Parliament like everyone else. Sneaking around behind closed doors and ambushing people with complaints is not how a free society works.”

ACT MP Todd Stephenson backed his leader:

“Unelected bureaucrats have no mandate to police the internet. When Parliament created the BSA in 1989, it was to uphold standards for traditional broadcasters. There was no YouTube, no podcasts, no livestreams. The BSA now claims it can regulate platforms like The Platform because podcasts include sound, and sound equals broadcasting. That’s a dangerous leap in logic.”



In stark, abysmal contrast, Paul Goldsmith demurred that he “could not comment on operational matters”. As if the BSA’s unlawful attempt to unilaterally extend its jurisdiction is an “operational matter”!?

AND GET THIS…BSA gave Goldsmith prior notice of its decision to try and capture The Platform and Goldsmith…let BSA go right ahead.

This is the very essence of the current National Party. Labour Light, with concealed addictions to State censorship, crafting of “official” Orwellian narratives and general Wokery. Which is fundamentally why the National Party is in freefall.

Prime Minister Christopher Luxon has steadfastly refused to appear on The Platform. Just as Luxon said there was “nothing he likes” about the ACT Party’s Treaty Principles Bill, there is nothing Luxon likes about Sean Plunket or The Platform. In his marshmallow heart of hearts, Luxo would simply love BSA to “disappear” The Platform.



I’m not an insider and rarely get juice. But here’s a titbit you can take as read…The Chris’s are talking. Prime Minister Christopher Luxon and Labour leader (and former Prime Minister) Chris Hipkins have been secretly talking about forming a “grand coalition” Nats/Labour Government after the next election, with a view to marginalizing the NZ First and ACT political parties.

And we know, don’t we - beyond a shadow of a doubt - that such a Government would have no hesitation in extending the BSA’s remit to cover all media. That prospect is nothing short of a dystopian nightmare. Behold, Big Brother Luxkins…

John McLean is a citizen typist and enthusiastic amateur who blogs at John's Substack where this article was sourced.

13 comments:

anonymous said...

The BSA is yet another example of the dangerous appointments made to these quango-type bodies. The Electoral Commission is another one. How quick these persons are to overreach their authority to advance personal agendas - and to avoid all and any consultation with citizens. NZ's governance is a very murky swamp.

Anonymous said...

Labour Mum, and National Dad, in bed together, fighting over the blanket and the sheets…

Anonymous said...

There are stellar performing national ministers, unfortunately goldsmith doesn't make that list.

Goldsmith actually said making cartels illegal would be bad for competition..... WHAT?

Much as I dislike Sean plunketts bar room brawler, low brow, loud mouth interview style, I am flattered by his copying of my oft repeated Maori mumbo jumbo line, used to describe Maori nonsense used by politicians for personal agendas.

I also fully support Plunkett having the right to call out Maori jumbo jumbo when he sees.

Perhaps the BSA would be better served investigating D Farrars many maori bashing articles, written to distract kiwi battlers from the nz oligopolies robbing them of their wages.

Anonymous said...

A “grand coalition” Nats/Labour Government after the next election, with a view to marginalizing the NZ First and ACT political parties. Let us be quite clear about this, it would be a grand coalition indeed, effectively led by and including the iwi chairs. Anyone voting for this would need their heads examined!

Basil Walker said...

Mumbo Jumbo has been used for decades. A browse through the BSA complaints is enlightening because it reminds you that "Dame Jacinda Ardern" called the ACT leader in Parliament a name which was a "significant disapproval" and that was brought to the BSA complaints process and not upheld . Numerous Minto complaints , Jewish insults and degradation , real coloured racial slurs et al all not upheld . It will be a lawyers dream for evidence and if the legal profession havent the guts to defend The Platform , the public will.

Anonymous said...

I wonder if the low IQ lefties in the BSA will think it's mumbo jumbo when their house or land they own is declared as tikunga or of special influence to maori. They are just useful idiots for the activists.

Robert Arthur said...

The Platform claims a huge following. Has certainly captured me. Laws the best commentator since Brian Edwards. The BSA seem to have chosen a most unlikely incident on which to attempt jurisdiction. Hopefully the publicity will draw even more to The Platform and perhaps persuade the msm to modify their approach to be similarly balanced, rational and appealing. The BSA seems to be a huge organisation and like so many others (including the legal profession) forever looking for soft make work.

Anonymous said...

Anon 10:10 - although few might actually intend to vote for a Lab/Nats coalition, MMP could easily deliver one if Luxon and Hipkins decided to cobble together a coalition agreement.

Anonymous said...

Why is democracy in NZ determined by the personal views of Luxon ?
He was elected with a mandate to stop this Maorication of absolutely everything, and now he intimidates every National Party MP into following his personal line.
Who is going to stand up to him ?
He has to be rolled ASAP.

Doug Longmire said...

Message to Luxon :-
GET ON with the removal of all "co-governance" and racist Maori nonsense.
That's what you were VOTED IN TO DO.

Anonymous said...

Anon 10:10 again, Precisely! With both consistently down so badly in polls and both clearly in favour of pursuing the He Puapua agenda, this scenario is decidedly possible. I would bet the farm that the iwi chairs are eagerly being strategic along these lines as the puppet masters. One hopes that Peters and Seymour can counter this potential pact with the devil.

Anonymous said...

The iwi chairs will not allow that!

anonymous said...

And what is the exact authority accorded to the Iwi Chair Forum by NZ citizens ?

Solution : referendum on NZ's democracy and citizen equality now!