....where it’s the mayor who has ruffled staff
One or some of the delicate petals who work for the Mackenzie District Council again have triggered the procedure for handling code-of-conduct complaints.
PoO readers will recall The Press report just three months ago of an investigation into whether a Mackenzie councillor had pushed a council staff member and slammed the door in another’s face.
It cost ratepayers more than $29,000.
The code of conduct investigation was launched in May after a confrontation between 89-year-old Pukaki ward councillor Frank Hocken, Mackenzie District Council chief executive Angela Oosthuizen, and two staff members at the council’s chambers in Fairlie.
Among the outcomes, we learned the health, safety and wellbeing of the 89-year-old Hocken and/or council staff would be imperilled if he was allowed to deal with them directly.
The investigation had been requested by council chief executive Angela Oosthuizen.
The investigator, consultant Bruce Robertson, said in his report that as part of his review of the incident, concerns had been expressed about the culture at the chamber and communications between elected members and staff.
“It is clear through these discussions that there is a relationship matter to be addressed,” the report said.
“The performance of Council – at a relationship and operational level – is at risk if not addressed.”
Robertson said that some people he spoke to saw the general culture as a “health and safety hazard”.
He said that for some elected members, “direct and often blunt language” was about seeking better decision making and accountability of staff.
“However, it is difficult to accept that the tone and style of delivery and treatment of staff reflect the Code’s values of respect, nor can it be seen as designed to engender trust and confidence – in fact it delivers the opposite.”
Robertson said he made no specific recommendations on the issue, “but I observe the general approach to elected members working with staff, especially senior staff, needs to be addressed”.
Has anything been done to create a more agreeable culture so that staff and councillors can – yep, this is what it’s all about – talk to each other?
Apparently not.
This time it’s the Mayor who has done something so dastardly that it can’t be sorted out civilly over a cup of tea or some-such.
Stuff reports:
The Mackenzie District Council has called in an outside investigator to look into allegations against mayor Scott Aronsen.
Stuff understands the allegations arise from a complaint by a council staff member.
The council confirmed to Stuff that “allegations have been received”.
“There is an independent external review underway to consider the allegations raised and we will not provide any further comment at this stage.”
It is fair to suppose another hefty bill will be incurred because the mayor and someone unidentified can’t talk to each other without one of the two feeling imperilled, endangered or whatever it is that causes the modern-day worker to complain about feeling unsafe.
Let’s suppose the cost of the first code-of-conduct inquiry – $29,000 – is doubled.
Sorting out council tiffs would have cost almost $60,000.
That’s not a piddling sum for a council that is trying to flush as much as it can from visitors.
OneNews recently reported that visitors to Mackenzie will begin paying for toilet stops from Waitangi weekend next year, after councillors approved a district-wide user-pays strategy.
Mackenzie District councillors agreed to adopt user-pays charges for 33 toilet facilities in the district by Waitangi weekend 2027 at Friday’s council meeting, after the presentation of a report prepared by parks and recreation consultant Thrive Spaces and Places.
The report said installing payment systems would cost $165,000, with annual operating costs of $1.07 million, to be funded through a $2.5m grant from the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment and $507,873 from council funds.
The user-pays fees would be introduced at the Fairlie, Burkes Pass, Tekapo Tavern, Tekapo Footbridge, Tekapo Lakeside, Pukaki, and Twizel facilities, with charges already applied to Tekapo’s Hamilton Dr facilities.
It seems appropriate that the New Zealand-owned technology firm that will supply the payment mechanisms is named Penny.
A penny is what the writer of this article had to drop into the gadgetry to get into a cubicle in the underground public toilet near the corner of Dee Street and The Crescent in Invercargill, back in the late 1950s.
In the Mackenzie district, Penny will collect 20% commission on revenue alongside a monthly site fee, the council report said.
But under this fiendish plan, visitors to the district will be obliged to prepare well ahead of their travels.
The Penny system would require users to register an account and pay a $1.50 fee per entry using an app, website, or digital key, allowing the council to monitor usage and transactions and adjust pricing and settings through a SiteWatch dashboard.
Hmm. Here’s hoping you are not busting.
First, you must register an account.
Then you need the app to pay to pee and/or poo.
Chief executive Angela Oosthuizen questioned the champions of this scheme about how older users would manage the system, saying she couldn’t see “elderly residents creating a Penny account and actually using it”.
The response was far from convincing:
The council’s operations and regulatory services manager Neil Jorgensen replied, saying user-pay systems worldwide faced the same challenge but that he would continue working on ways to engage older users.
Jorgensen added that older people are “actually more tech-savvy” than one might think.
But this scheme is designed to benefit the bureaucrats rather than the visitors.
Thrive senior planner Samantha Strong, who prepared the report, told councillors Penny was “a really great tool” for the council and community.
“It’s a really great tool for future planning … to understand who is entering your district, where they’re from, how much time they’re spending, how much money they’re spending,” Strong said.
It sounds ominously like you will be accompanied to the bog by Big Brother.
The data are encouraging – revenue projections range from $86,000 at a 50% user rate to $667,000 at a 95% user rate.
Thrive senior planner Samantha Strong enthused:
“That’s a really great win for the district and … if we get all the way up to 95%, you’re looking at a $667,000 revenue which, in comparison to what your toilets cost, is a pretty good chunk of change.”
Council finances would look even better – of course – if councillors and officials could sort out their differences without having to invoke their costly code-of-conduct procedures.
Bob Edlin is a veteran journalist and editor for the Point of Order blog HERE.
Among the outcomes, we learned the health, safety and wellbeing of the 89-year-old Hocken and/or council staff would be imperilled if he was allowed to deal with them directly.
The investigation had been requested by council chief executive Angela Oosthuizen.
The investigator, consultant Bruce Robertson, said in his report that as part of his review of the incident, concerns had been expressed about the culture at the chamber and communications between elected members and staff.
“It is clear through these discussions that there is a relationship matter to be addressed,” the report said.
“The performance of Council – at a relationship and operational level – is at risk if not addressed.”
Robertson said that some people he spoke to saw the general culture as a “health and safety hazard”.
He said that for some elected members, “direct and often blunt language” was about seeking better decision making and accountability of staff.
“However, it is difficult to accept that the tone and style of delivery and treatment of staff reflect the Code’s values of respect, nor can it be seen as designed to engender trust and confidence – in fact it delivers the opposite.”
Robertson said he made no specific recommendations on the issue, “but I observe the general approach to elected members working with staff, especially senior staff, needs to be addressed”.
Has anything been done to create a more agreeable culture so that staff and councillors can – yep, this is what it’s all about – talk to each other?
Apparently not.
This time it’s the Mayor who has done something so dastardly that it can’t be sorted out civilly over a cup of tea or some-such.
Stuff reports:
The Mackenzie District Council has called in an outside investigator to look into allegations against mayor Scott Aronsen.
Stuff understands the allegations arise from a complaint by a council staff member.
The council confirmed to Stuff that “allegations have been received”.
“There is an independent external review underway to consider the allegations raised and we will not provide any further comment at this stage.”
It is fair to suppose another hefty bill will be incurred because the mayor and someone unidentified can’t talk to each other without one of the two feeling imperilled, endangered or whatever it is that causes the modern-day worker to complain about feeling unsafe.
Let’s suppose the cost of the first code-of-conduct inquiry – $29,000 – is doubled.
Sorting out council tiffs would have cost almost $60,000.
That’s not a piddling sum for a council that is trying to flush as much as it can from visitors.
OneNews recently reported that visitors to Mackenzie will begin paying for toilet stops from Waitangi weekend next year, after councillors approved a district-wide user-pays strategy.
Mackenzie District councillors agreed to adopt user-pays charges for 33 toilet facilities in the district by Waitangi weekend 2027 at Friday’s council meeting, after the presentation of a report prepared by parks and recreation consultant Thrive Spaces and Places.
The report said installing payment systems would cost $165,000, with annual operating costs of $1.07 million, to be funded through a $2.5m grant from the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment and $507,873 from council funds.
The user-pays fees would be introduced at the Fairlie, Burkes Pass, Tekapo Tavern, Tekapo Footbridge, Tekapo Lakeside, Pukaki, and Twizel facilities, with charges already applied to Tekapo’s Hamilton Dr facilities.
It seems appropriate that the New Zealand-owned technology firm that will supply the payment mechanisms is named Penny.
A penny is what the writer of this article had to drop into the gadgetry to get into a cubicle in the underground public toilet near the corner of Dee Street and The Crescent in Invercargill, back in the late 1950s.
In the Mackenzie district, Penny will collect 20% commission on revenue alongside a monthly site fee, the council report said.
But under this fiendish plan, visitors to the district will be obliged to prepare well ahead of their travels.
The Penny system would require users to register an account and pay a $1.50 fee per entry using an app, website, or digital key, allowing the council to monitor usage and transactions and adjust pricing and settings through a SiteWatch dashboard.
Hmm. Here’s hoping you are not busting.
First, you must register an account.
Then you need the app to pay to pee and/or poo.
Chief executive Angela Oosthuizen questioned the champions of this scheme about how older users would manage the system, saying she couldn’t see “elderly residents creating a Penny account and actually using it”.
The response was far from convincing:
The council’s operations and regulatory services manager Neil Jorgensen replied, saying user-pay systems worldwide faced the same challenge but that he would continue working on ways to engage older users.
Jorgensen added that older people are “actually more tech-savvy” than one might think.
But this scheme is designed to benefit the bureaucrats rather than the visitors.
Thrive senior planner Samantha Strong, who prepared the report, told councillors Penny was “a really great tool” for the council and community.
“It’s a really great tool for future planning … to understand who is entering your district, where they’re from, how much time they’re spending, how much money they’re spending,” Strong said.
It sounds ominously like you will be accompanied to the bog by Big Brother.
The data are encouraging – revenue projections range from $86,000 at a 50% user rate to $667,000 at a 95% user rate.
Thrive senior planner Samantha Strong enthused:
“That’s a really great win for the district and … if we get all the way up to 95%, you’re looking at a $667,000 revenue which, in comparison to what your toilets cost, is a pretty good chunk of change.”
Council finances would look even better – of course – if councillors and officials could sort out their differences without having to invoke their costly code-of-conduct procedures.
Bob Edlin is a veteran journalist and editor for the Point of Order blog HERE.

No comments:
Post a Comment
Thank you for joining the discussion. Breaking Views welcomes respectful contributions that enrich the debate. Please ensure your comments are not defamatory, derogatory or disruptive. We appreciate your cooperation.