Pages

Saturday, November 21, 2026

Colinxy: How Councils Weaponise “Process” to Silence Dissent


When procedure becomes a shield, transparency becomes theatre, and democracy becomes optional

Local government in New Zealand has always had its quirks: slow paperwork, labyrinthine committees, and a fondness for consultation documents nobody reads. But in recent years, something more troubling has emerged: using “process” as a political weapon.

Roger Partridge: Shrinking to Greatness


New Zealand's two largest political parties have made good progress towards becoming smaller ones. On election night, neither National nor Labour reached 30 percent. Together they managed just 58.6 percent, a record low for their combined vote.

Years of careful work have gone into making the parties small targets. Too many principles can frighten voters. Clear policies give opponents something to aim at.

Richard Prebble: Who decides how taxpayers’ money is spent?


Mr Justice Paul Radich has ruled that the Government’s 2025 amendments to the Equal Pay Act were principally motivated by fiscal considerations.

“The documents, viewed as a whole, show that the main driver was fiscal.”

But determining fiscal priorities is Parliament’s responsibility, not the courts.

Breaking Views Update: Week of 15.11.26







Saturday November 21, 2026 

News:
New Plymouth backs voting rights for non-elected committee members

New Plymouth has joined calls for the Government to allow non-elected committee members to keep their voting rights.

At a meeting on Wednesday evening, New Plymouth District Council (NPDC) voted 12-3 to send a letter asking for an exemption to the new law restricting committee voting rights to elected councillors, in step with other district councils including Far North, Hastings and Porirua.

Geoff Parker: Human Rights Commission - From Treaty Education To Constitutional Transformation


The Human Rights Commission has published two documents under its Ā Tātou Kōrero initiative: a 20-page booklet, Enabling Te Tiriti Conversations, and a supplementary factsheet, Te Tiriti in our constitution.

Both are presented as educational material intended to encourage an informed national conversation about the Treaty of Waitangi and New Zealand's constitutional arrangements.

But read them together and a clear political and constitutional direction emerges.

Ashley Church: Is MMP really broken?


Or have voters just, finally, discovered their power?

I was never particularly a fan of MMP – in fact, back in 1993 I toured Hawkes Bay with Michael Laws debating its merits at public meetings.

Michael was in favour of MMP and, in those days, a considerably better public speaker than I was – so the audiences usually went away resoundingly in favour of the new electoral system.

LilBaP: Democracy Has Had Its Day.....


.......Only if the wrong people are in charge of it.

Auckland Mayor Wayne Brown has come back from China and told Stuff that democracy has had its day. The system is unfathomable, the American election produced a non-working government, Europe has not had a good one for years and it is time for something else.

The something else, he made plain, is China’s centrally managed capitalism – the version that allows failure and gets results. Western countries, by contrast, prop up ‘dogs’ such as Fletcher’s and pretend they still have capitalism.

Eric Garland: Why Iran Cannot Simply Surrender


Observers might wonder why the Islamic Republic of Iran has not yet folded. Perhaps the remaining senior leaders were hoping for a shift coming from the U.S. and Israeli elections, but their situation has been dire. Iran’s air force and navy have been laid low. Much of its leadership was eliminated by air strikes. The U.S. Navy has reduced its oil at sea to zero and the U.S. Treasury has cut off its finances around the world. History tells us that most regimes in their position would surrender.

David Farrar: Comrade Wayne


Stuff reported:

Auckland Mayor Wayne Brown says “democracy’s had its day” after recently visiting China and witnessing its rapid economic growth. …

Brown was asked by Stuff what the alternative to democracy could be.

Mike's Minute: Too many dumb ideas and it's only Thursday


Is Wayne Brown what you get when we don’t have a Government?

Is the Government and its every move so vastly covered in this country that when we don’t have one, any idiot gets to say weird stuff and it makes news?

I thought the open letter, another outworking of the bored and attention seeking, was bad enough but it would seem Brown has managed to bump some academics off the top "click chart" with some jet-lagged ramblings about democracy.

Rodney Hide: Experts gang up on the voters


Here's a tip. Always be alarmed when experts gang up to sign a letter telling us what to do. If they had a good argument, one author would be enough.

This week 46 of them signed an open letter titled "Keep the 'P' in MMP". It's addressed to the new Parliament. And experts? Give me a break.

LilBaP: Net Zero Is Not a Product – But Could Be a Ponzi


A Ponzi scheme is a money ‘merry-go-round’. It compensates early investors with money taken from subsequent investors. It doesn’t generate real returns but creates the appearance of profitability as long as new capital is continually being introduced. When that new money stops, the scheme collapses.

The name originates from Charles Ponzi, a con artist in the 1920s. In more recent times Bernie Madoff used the same scheme with a roughly $65 billion scam in the 1990s.

Friday November 20, 2026 

                   ⇩

Friday, November 20, 2026

Michael Laws: Let's Not Forget: Opportunity Are The 'He Puapua' Party


Michael Laws chats about the Opportunity Party and the He Puapua plan. And how Kayla Kingdom-Bebb said He Puapua was only an option which Michael called a lie and wondered whyJack Tame didn’t call her out on it in the Q&A interview.

Click to view

Clive Bibby: Retirement isn’t about where you live but who you share it with


All the money in the world or the opportunity to spend your twilight years living in some of this Country's most stunning landscapes amounts to nothing if you are doing it all on your own.

Those of us who are either forced into retirement prematurely or voluntarily decide to ride off into the sunset, usually come to the same conclusion if there is nobody to share the remaining good times and bad.

Ani O'Brien: RNZ can sell land, but who’s buying its excuses?


An $11.8 million loss has exposed the gap between reassuring platitudes and the numbers underneath.

Radio New Zealand was expected to lose $470,000 this year. A loss, but one that would be relatively easy to swallow. Instead it lost $11.846 million after tax in the year to 30 June 2026. A loss twenty-five times larger than forecast and we did not find out about it until the opportunity to manage and mitigate had passed.

Colinxy: The Fatherless Society......


.....How Ideology, Law, and False Expectations Broke the Family

This article was sparked by this YouTube video analysing the rise of fatherless households and the long‑term social consequences. The presenter focuses on absent fathers: both literally absent through divorce and functionally absent through passivity or disengagement. She acknowledges maternal neglect too but emphasises the paternal side. Fair enough. Perhaps she’ll tackle the other half of the equation in a follow‑up.

Ivan Barnett: UNDRIP, He Puapua, and Democratic Accountability in New Zealand


Executive Summary

This paper examines the relationship between the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP), the He Puapua report, and the wider constitutional debate taking place in New Zealand. It does not seek to attack individuals, political parties, or Māori aspirations. Rather, it examines a more fundamental question:

How did a non-binding international declaration become connected to proposals for constitutional transformation in New Zealand, and what democratic mandate exists for such change?

Simon O'Connor: The Voters Are Always Right


A National MP’s answer to her defeat was to blame a supposedly right-wing turn. Instead, both National and Labour should be asking why voters increasingly preferred other parties.

There is an awkward feature of democracy: the voters get the final say. They are not obliged to endorse a politician's judgement, reward their efforts, or understand how sensible politicians consider themselves to be.

Kerre Woodham: I don't understand some of the overhang complaints


A group of 45 academics and constitutional experts has written an open letter calling for changes to the MMP electoral system to avoid undemocratic elections going into the future. The 11 seat overhang, which initial results are giving us before final votes are counted, is not what most voters of any side surely wants to see.

Bob Edlin: Opportunity’s “clean-up politics” pledge......


......is sullied before the election count is announced

Opportunity Party bigwigs will be a treat to listen to when they explain how they reconcile the headline below, about the identities of advisers being kept secret, with their policy pledge about transparency…


Rodney Hide: Clean up politics, but not ours


The Opportunity Party campaigned on cleaning up politics. It was one of their five non-negotiables. Their policy promised to "hard-wire honesty, transparency, and genuine public participation into our democracy." Good on them. Who could be against that?

Then they won seats, and we got to see how it works in practice.

Mike's Minute: Is the public sector side of TVNZ and RNZ the reason for its failures?


Is it too long a bow to draw if I conflate the various media problems that are making news at the moment with the fact they are to be found solely in the public sector?

As a seasoned observer of this great industry, I have NZME, the owner of this station, if not the most successful then certainly up there, along with Sky TV who seem robust and broadly travelling well.

Thursday November 19, 2026 

                   ⇩

Thursday, November 19, 2026

Simon O'Connor: Heads We Win, Tails It’s Illegitimate


Those on the left now accusing others of gaming the system want to change that system to suit themselves. The real problem is the idea that voters must vote a certain way.

There is a simple test of whether someone believes in democracy: do they still believe in it when they lose?

Perspective with Heather du Plessis-Allan: Do we need to get rid of the overhang?


It was bound to happen, wasn't it?

A group of political academics and researchers has written an open letter calling for a fix to stop overhangs from happening again. They're worried this could be about to take off. Now that people have figured out how to create an overhang on either side of politics, the academics fear it could spark an arms race to see who can create the biggest one and, in doing so, win the election.

Gravedodger: Will They Listen, Will they work it out, Likely not!


Radio New Zealand, the free to air entirely taxpayer funded via NZ On Air, not able to augment funding from sponsorship or advertising revenue is in a world of trouble after a predicted budget loss of around NZ$470 000, ended it last full year on june 30 2026 with a near NZ$12 000 000 loss. That would take some doing.

Bob Edlin: Great Scott – more rancour in the Mackenzie Country....


....where it’s the mayor who has ruffled staff

One or some of the delicate petals who work for the Mackenzie District Council again have triggered the procedure for handling code-of-conduct complaints.

PoO readers will recall The Press report just three months ago of an investigation into whether a Mackenzie councillor had pushed a council staff member and slammed the door in another’s face.

It cost ratepayers more than $29,000.

JC: Goodbye to You and You and You


If the headline rings a bell in the ears of the more mature of the Good Oilers it should. It’s a line from a song in the Sound of Music. The song is “So Long Farewell”. Post election, I suspect the sound of music is not what’s ringing in the ears of the National Party. But I suspect ‘So Long, Farewell’ is. Because it really is time to say good bye to you and you and you.

LilBaP: They Keep Moving the Centre


So now I’m far right.

When will people notice the centre has moved? Both the election and prior polling showed National losing support, most of it shifting to either ACT or New Zealand First.

Rodney Hide: Labour's route to power is all uphill


Last week I wrote that I couldn't see what Labour could do about 2029. So I had the numbers run.

Start with the board. Say National again wins 42 electorates, and that more National voters split their vote, say another 225,000. ACT and New Zealand First then take 15 per cent of the party vote each, assuming an even split. On that model the House grows to 142 seats. National's overhang jumps from 7 to 18. The right has 78 seats. It needs 72. That is a majority of six, not one.

That is Labour's hole. There are four ways out.

Mike’s Minute: National would do well to bin the supermarket blow-up


It's 1-1 on Nicola Willis, for me.

Three economists were asked in an article last week what her legacy was. "Inconsequential" was the reply.

A good politician but made no real difference as minister.

Wednesday November 18, 2026 

                   ⇩

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Ryan Bridge: The P in MMP, the D in democracy


A bunch of academics have written an open letter this morning wanting to put the P back in MMP.

That is, to stop Harry Mowbray's highly successful campaign to engineer an overhang on the right. And Te Pati Māori's highly successful campaign to engineer the same on the left.

They want an urgent select committee inquiry into the matter and changes made within three years.

Pee Kay: What Happens on Day One if the Left Wins?


What is at stake?

New Zealand is currently suspended in political limbo. While the preliminary count from the 7th November general election leaves the existing centre-right coalition clinging to a razor thin 67-seat majority in a 131-seat Parliament, the true outcome will not be known until Friday, 27 November. That is the day the Electoral Commission releases the official results after scrutinising and counting approximately 399,365 special votes.

Pee Kay: “…simply to hold a national conversation on Indigenous rights…” Yeah Right!


Kingdon-Bebb; Another Enemy Within?

Traditionally, international law relies on formal treaties and conventions, which require strict parliamentary ratification before becoming legally binding. Increasingly, however, global bodies have turned to “soft law”—non-binding instruments like the 2007 United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP). Though aspirational and lacking formal ratification, these declarations are now routinely used to bypass traditional democratic consent and to pressure domestic policy.

Brendan O'Neill: The nauseating hypocrisy of Greta Thunberg


She now laughs at eco-activists because she has moved on to the new Current Thing: blindly hating the Jewish State.

Has the high priestess of planetary doom finally tired of her own apocalypse? That clip of Greta Thunberg guffawing upon being told that kids are still bunking off school every Friday to bewail Man’s burning of Earth suggests she might have. She was being interviewed for a documentary about 21st-century activism. There’s a ‘Fridays for Future’ gathering in Berlin today, the host tells her. ‘Really? They still do that?’, she says, before cackling wildly in her dumb Richard III haircut. ‘Cut!’, she then cries.

Kerre Woodham: The Microsoft outage was a wake-up call


For many people, the Microsoft outage on Friday was the opportunity to down tools and make an early start on the weekend. For others, it was costly, frustrating, and time consuming. But either way, the Microsoft global outage is a wake up call to ensure we always have a plan B and to try to build digital resilience into everything we do. A reminder that you can't just expect to turn it on and it be there.

Bob Edlin: When the Environment Court ruling on culturally sensitive sites is disappointing .....


.......well, let’s try the Maori Land Court

RNZ reports that Environment Court Judge Jeff Smith has dismissed a case involving earthworks that damaged culturally significant sites in the Far North.

“Culturally significant sites”, it’s fair to suppose, does not refer to an opera house, library or botanical gardens.

Sure enough, the case – brought by Heritage New Zealand’s against Valentina Trustees – was triggered by the damaging of a pā site.

David Farrar: Without the Māori seats, National would probably not have an overhang


The Māori seats didn’t only produce an overhang for the left, but their existence helped National have a seven seat overhang on the right.

This is because if Māori on the Māori roll were all enrolled in general seats, National would win far fewer. Based on the provisional results, this is what would happen in marginal National-held seats if there were no Māori seats.

Rodney Hide: Two votes is not a loophole


The Post ran two pieces on the election a day apart. Read together, they don't make sense.

https://www.thepost.co.nz/nz-news/361116825/big-money-and-electoral-loopholes-tilt-playing-field

https://www.thepost.co.nz/politics/361116344/andrea-vance-why-are-we-letting-rich-hobbyists-buy-parallel-election

Max Rashbrooke says voters should be "deeply disturbed". Big money, dark money and engineered overhangs, he says, may have swung the result. The government won not on argument but on cash and "cynically distorting the process".

Tuesday November 17, 2026 

                   ⇩

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Andrew Dickens: I blame the supermarket breakup for National's poor election result


I'm quite a fan of Herald journalist Kate MacNamara.

I first noticed her business reporting, but she really stood out during Covid. She's the kind of reporter who digs through mountains of documents to uncover facts and hold politicians to account.

David Lillis: NO MINISTER - A free and frank analysis of the public service


The New Zealand Initiative has just released a report on New Zealand’s Public Service - NO MINISTER - A free and frank analysis of the public service.

See:

https://www.nzinitiative.org.nz/reports-and-media/reports/no-minister-a-free-and-frank-analysis-of-the-public-service

Anglo Saxon: Tax payer funded academic debunked on New Zealand's "illegal founding."


Anglo Saxon says Claire Charters is a radicalised academic with some outrageous claims and wild theories. Her salary comes out of our pockets.

Click to view

Chris Lynch: RNZ staff blame HR for the crisis. Now HR is in charge of the job cuts


Paul Thompson’s early departure from RNZ will do little to address deeper problems within the taxpayer-funded broadcaster, according to current and former staff.

The chief executive and editor-in-chief will leave on Monday 16 November, more than six weeks earlier than his original departure date of 31 December.

Pee Kay: The Cost of Democracy


The 2026 election has undoubtably opened a large number of eyes to, not only the pitfalls but also the potencies of MMP. It also needed to open a few prominent politicians eyes! Do you think Chris Luxon has finally grasped how MMP elections are won, or nearly lost?

The sheer arrogance of the National hierarchy is staggering when you look at the provisional data from the Electoral Commission. Seven out of every ten voters explicitly refused to give National their party vote! Do National finally comprehend that indicates that over 70% of the public are simply not enamoured enough with their performance to offer them further support?

Rodney Hide: Two standards of citizenship


Otago University has published its 2026 medical school admissions figures. They make for uncomfortable reading.

https://www.otago.ac.nz/__data/assets/pdf_file/0021/640290/MB-ChB-Admissions-Statistics-2026.pdf

This year Otago admitted 347 students to medicine. At least 72 came in through the Māori pathway. 167 came in through the General pathway, the one most New Zealanders must use.

Mike's Minute: The rot in the public service


People may not remember, or indeed may not even realise, this station was once a part of Radio NZ.

I can tell you the Newstalk ZB of today is a world away from the ZB under Government ownership.

I can also tell you the Radio NZ that exists today, who I also worked for separately for several years before being sprung back to the real world, does not appear to be materially different at all.

Dr Nicholas Tate: Whatever Happened to Common Sense?


In his book In Defence of Populism, published earlier this year, the sociologist Frank Furedi, in making his case for populism, invokes in support Hannah Arendt, to whom the book is dedicated. In a 1954 essay on ‘Understanding and Politics’, Arendt distinguished between political systems in which leaders are expected to adapt their ideas when faced with the real world and totalitarian regimes in which leaders alter the real world to ensure that it fits with their ideas. What distinguishes the two is the presence in the first of ‘common sense’ and its replacement by ideology in the second. Furedi sees populism as falling into the first category and, by implication, current Western liberal democracies into the second.

David Harvey: Decrypting Bureauspeak


Why We Need a Rosetta Stone to Interpret Public Service Publications

Remember the BBC programme “Yes Minister”. It was a brilliant satire on the machinations of the English Civil Service. Many of the better bits can be found on YouTube. An example can be found here.

An Australian satire – “Utopia” – about the civil service and its obfuscations was recently available on Netflix. An example can be found here. It was sharp, often not too subtle and very recognizable for any of us who have had to endure dealing with the public service.

Andi Cockroft: Is Artificial Intelligence Taking Over Government Policy?


Government departments are increasingly embracing artificial intelligence (AI), promising greater efficiency, faster processing and improved public services. There are undoubtedly benefits, but an important question remains largely unanswered. At what point does AI cease being an administrative tool and begin influencing the policies and decisions for which elected representatives and public officials are accountable?

Brendan O'Neill: The left’s despicable absolution of Hamas


It was Hamas’s cannibalisation of Gaza’s infrastructure that made the current floods so bad.

Israel has a new weapon for its genocide: rainfall. Bored with using bombs and starvation to achieve its Nazi-like goal of eradicating the Palestinian people, now it has brought out the big gun of precipitation. That, at least, is the unhinged cry of the West’s tireless army of Israelophobes. Following the battering of Gaza by winter storms, the keffiyeh classes have been out in force doing what they do best: attributing every sad, bad and even natural event to that all-powerful, all-dastardly Jewish state.

Yvonne Van Dongen: Ideology Dressed as Research


The Flaws in the Areto Labs Report on Political Abuse

If nothing else, being a TERF helps sort ideology from reality in all sorts of spheres.

As soon as I saw the word “transphobic” in last week’s story on sexist and racist abuse in politics courtesy of a report by an outfit called Areto Labs, I knew we’d strayed into the realm of ideology.

Monday November 16, 2026 

                   ⇩

Monday, November 16, 2026

John Denton: Post Election Prattle


There’s a great deal of blather being skited across the media in the aftermath of the election.

From Hipkins’ claim that “National was only holding on to the prospect of power because they’ve manipulated the electoral system” (When Labour’s co-conspirators, TPM, apparently did not). To claims that “National had been pulled too far right” (Excuse me whilst I laugh. Hysterically).