Pages

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

David Lillis: NO MINISTER - A free and frank analysis of the public service


The New Zealand Initiative has just released a report on New Zealand’s Public Service - NO MINISTER - A free and frank analysis of the public service.

See:

https://www.nzinitiative.org.nz/reports-and-media/reports/no-minister-a-free-and-frank-analysis-of-the-public-service


Two major foci of the report concern political neutrality and the provision of free and frank advice. In order to tease out the necessary detail, the researchers interviewed 40 people who have worked within the Public Service. In addition, they surveyed 718 current and former public servants, presenting 23 questions about the role of the public service in New Zealand’s democracy.

They remind us that in the Public Service Commission’s own census, 95 percent of public servants claimed to understand political neutrality. However, in the New Zealand Initiative survey, only 59 percent agreed that officials should do their best to make a lawful policy succeed when they believe it to be misguided. Seven in ten said that the public service serves the public rather than the elected government.

The publication of this critical report is very timely, as we anticipate the outcome of the 2026 elections that will introduce inevitable change. We hope that our new Government can establish more exacting standards and expectations and bring about the necessary improvements. Given various concerns about our Public Service (which, as a former public servant of twenty years, I share), this report can form the basis of ongoing discussion about the issues and how to address them.

This report is recommended reading for all who desire a public service that supports elected governments to achieve what voters elect them to achieve.

Dr David Lillis trained in physics and mathematics at Victoria University and Curtin University in Perth, working as a teacher, researcher, statistician and lecturer for most of his career. He has published many articles and scientific papers, as well as a book on graphing and statistics.

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

A friend of mine was elected to the Nelson City Council some years ago. She told me that the non-elected public servants referred, among themselves, to elected Councilors as THE VISITORS. Their attitude was that Councilors came and went, but the employees ran the show and pretty much did what they liked.

Post a Comment

Thank you for joining the discussion. Breaking Views welcomes respectful contributions that enrich the debate. Please ensure your comments are not defamatory, derogatory or disruptive. We appreciate your cooperation.