Pages

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Rodney Hide: Two standards of citizenship


Otago University has published its 2026 medical school admissions figures. They make for uncomfortable reading.

https://www.otago.ac.nz/__data/assets/pdf_file/0021/640290/MB-ChB-Admissions-Statistics-2026.pdf

This year Otago admitted 347 students to medicine. At least 72 came in through the Māori pathway. 167 came in through the General pathway, the one most New Zealanders must use.

Of the students who applied through the General pathway after first-year health science, 29% got in: 110 of 379. Of those who applied through the Māori pathway, 82% did: 59 of 72.

The marks tell the same story. The lowest General-pathway student offered a place averaged 93 per cent. On the Māori pathway, offers went as low as 65 per cent. That's a gap of nearly 28 points.

For graduates the gap is complete. Every General-pathway graduate offered a place had a higher grade average than every Māori-pathway graduate offered one. The ranges don't even overlap.

Do they graduate at the same rate? Nobody publishes it regularly. Otago released one cohort under the Official Information Act: of the students who started second-year medicine in 2019, all 42 on the Māori pathway and all 97 on the General pathway finished on time. When asked for drop-out rates by pathway over several years, Otago withheld them. At Auckland, the only published study, of students admitted from 2002 to 2009, found 80% of those on the Māori and Pacific scheme graduated, against 95% on the General pathway.

So students admitted on 65 per cent can finish the degree, pass the same finals and become doctors. That tells us something. The 93 per cent bar is not a measure of who will make a good doctor. It's rationing. Otago has far more able applicants than places, so it ranks them on first-year marks because marks are easy to rank. Being able to score 93 rather than 85 in a first-year chemistry paper may bear no resemblance to being good at doctoring.

That makes the ancestry rule harder to defend, not easier. If marks are the right test, it's wrong to wave some students through on 65. If marks are a poor test, it's wrong to turn away a General student on 92 who would make a fine doctor. Either way, two young New Zealanders from the same school get very different chances because of who their great-grandparents were.

This is two standards of citizenship, decided by ancestry.

The defence is that it produces more Māori doctors to serve Māori patients. The honest answer is to fix the test, not the race of the people who sit it. Choose students on what makes a good doctor: judgement, character, how they deal with people, and the will to work in the places that need doctors. Then apply that test to everyone.

Citizenship should mean one standard for everyone. Our medical schools have two.

Rodney Hide is former ACT Party leader, and Minister in the National-ACT Government from 2008 to 2011. This article was first published HERE

7 comments:

Anonymous said...

This does a disservice to ordinary Maori. Assuming that Maori patients are more likely to use Maori doctors, Maori will be getting substandard health care.

It's worth remembering that this apartheid system partly came from lobbying from the medical association. Who was deputy of that? Vanessa Weenink.

Anonymous said...

Thomas sowell has some interesting things to say on dei and its role in access to hard to access courses (hard to access for some). Basically he says it’s BS and results in lowering the overall trust and capability in the profession, as well as lowering the trust of the public in any resulting professionals of a particular race.
Not to mention the lowering of self esteem of the students themselves…because they then see themselves as less than capable as do their peers who don’t share their race….which results in (wait for it)….RACISM!
Imagine that, a Harlem born, 80 something yr old black man saying that dei initiatives such as what we are seeing in Otago, not only fail the profession, but the students, the public’s trust, but also create racism where it didn’t previously exist. (If it did previously exist it was in small pockets of individuals - as opposed to widespread across an entire body of students and public that must be served by the resulting professional.)

Anonymous said...

De-fund OU till it gets rid of this policy - in breach of article 3 of the TOW.

K said...

A worst kept secret...
But anecdotally, some say the 'maori' grads stay in NZ while most of the 'others' head overseas. Maybe they wish to pay student loans and get experience.
Maybe quite a few of the maori grads have been funded from other sources? Student loans not an issue?

Anonymous said...

Well there you go. Don't go to a part maori "Doctor". Because they aren't

Rob Beechey said...

Separate development was an ideological evolution of apartheid introduced into South Africa to maintain white minority political and economic dominance while stripping Black South Africans of their citizenship rights. 
“Citizenship should mean one standard for everyone. Our medical schools have two, duplicating the very practice the rest of the world thought abhorrent in South Africa. 

Barend Vlaardingerbroek said...

>"Being able to score 93 rather than 85 in a first-year chemistry paper may bear no resemblance to being good at doctoring."
Are there any longitudinal studies that relate performance in pre-med courses used as filters to get into med to subsequent performance in MBBS courses?
I am all for applying academic filters, but we need to know that they are fit for purpose - that they serve as indicators of how students will perform once they have been admitted to a programme (in this instance, med) on the strength of their performance in the filter courses. There is no point in using those filters otherwise.
I realise the article is not about this aspect of the admission to MBBS programmes, but the issue I raise here is a highly relevant one.
I was once consulted about an admission test to a particular programme administered by a university dept. I conducted correlations and regressions between marks on the test and marks at the end of the first year and found that the test was a fair predictor albeit not a great one. Just for fun I then conducted the same exercise using the external exam scores at the culmination of high schooling attained by students in relevant subjects and found that those were much better predictors than the dept's own test. My advice: consign your test to the Irish filing cabinet and just use the results from the terminating high school external exams! Problem solved!

Post a Comment

Thank you for joining the discussion. Breaking Views welcomes respectful contributions that enrich the debate. Please ensure your comments are not defamatory, derogatory or disruptive. We appreciate your cooperation.