Pages

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Dr Nicholas Tate: Whatever Happened to Common Sense?


In his book In Defence of Populism, published earlier this year, the sociologist Frank Furedi, in making his case for populism, invokes in support Hannah Arendt, to whom the book is dedicated. In a 1954 essay on ‘Understanding and Politics’, Arendt distinguished between political systems in which leaders are expected to adapt their ideas when faced with the real world and totalitarian regimes in which leaders alter the real world to ensure that it fits with their ideas. What distinguishes the two is the presence in the first of ‘common sense’ and its replacement by ideology in the second. Furedi sees populism as falling into the first category and, by implication, current Western liberal democracies into the second.

Arendt defines ‘common sense’ as “that portion of inherited wisdom which all men have in common in any given civilisation”, together with the habits of judgment that allow them to apply this wisdom to specific situations. It is this ‘common sense’ that Furedi feels people whom he describes as having a populist disposition are looking to see from their governments. Where governments turn their backs on ‘common sense’, people with a populist disposition are likely to transfer allegiance to populist movements committed to re-establishing it.

Although Britain is not totalitarian, it has become increasingly illiberal and authoritarian in the last three decades in response to the chaos resulting from the collapse in traditional cultural norms that the country’s technocratic-managerial elite has been keen to encourage. Restrictions on what we can say, interference in how we live our lives and look after our children and deference to ‘experts’ where common sense used to suffice, increase year by year. Even if not totalitarian, this elite, in addition to increasing ‘nanny state’ interference ‘for our own good’, has adopted progressive ideologies that push it firmly into the Arendtian category of a regime that, instead of adapting its ideas to fit the real world, adapts the real world to fit its ideas. The more I have thought about this phrase, the more I see how apt a description it is of the near-complete abandonment of common sense we have come to take for granted.

The disappearance of common sense from the public scene shows up in so many areas that it is impossible to enumerate them all. Let me begin with one of the more trivial.

What do most of the public figures much-lauded by politicians and the BBC who have in recent years fallen from grace have in common? They are people – Russell Brand, Jimmy Savile and Greta Thunberg, for example – whom, from their first appearance, normal people with common sense and good judgment will have found to be not just irritating but, in ways not always easy to define, morally suspect, but whom “society’s overlords”, as Furedi calls our elite, have lionised. Common sense told us normies that Russell Brand was a vulgar narcissist one would not want to get anywhere near, Jimmy Savile a creepy pseud playing on his northernness (as a northerner, I can tell one) and Greta Thunberg an opinionated and hysterical brat. Unlike our ‘overlords’, we have not been surprised to see the first sent to prison for a long spell, the second’s posthumously revealed secret CV put to shame all those who had sucked up to him over so many years and the third moved on to a new cause for which in 2024 she was deservedly nominated “Antisemite of the Year”.

But these are minor examples from an elite whose absence of common sense is much deeper. Although there are other major illustrations of its absence – the gradual undermining of parliamentary sovereignty and the response to Covid, for example – the two most glaring ones are climate and energy policy and mass immigration.

How could anyone with an ounce of common sense, one might ask, consciously inflict on this country the highest energy costs in the world and destroy a large part of its industrial production as the result of a Net Zero ideology that, even if one were to accept the contested theory about the causes of climate change on which it is based, would at most reduce the world’s carbon emissions by 0.74% and thus bring nil benefit to the country’s inhabitants?

The same is true for mass immigration. How could any political class have inflicted on its own country long-term immigration of 17.8 million people over the period 1997 to 2025, assuming as globalists that this would turn Britain into a “bazaar of world cultures” in which everyone would get along just fine, but without thought for the long-term consequences?

Seeing the problems that arose, how could a political class that had any common sense not then begin to ensure either that immigration was drastically reduced or, if it felt it could manage this influx, put in place arrangements to build the required new infrastructure and insist on cultural assimilation?

As a result of the failure of the political class to do any of these things, we now face the problems of managing the most difficult kind of society, a ‘plurally monocultural’ one in which different ethnicities and cultures keep themselves to themselves. “Society’s overlords” have not just allowed this to happen but encouraged it through the use of the globalist’s mantra ‘diversity is our strength’, which is so visibly a denial of reality that for those with common sense it has become a standing joke. The consequences of this failure are all around us, through having turned urban areas in many parts of the country into ones where the indigenous population is in a minority, plus the prospect that, on current predictions, the ‘White British’ will be a minority in the whole country by 2063, and England’s existence as a nation for more than 1,000 years will, in any meaningful sense, have come to an end.

In addition to these world-changing legacies arising from an abandonment of common sense, elites have also been captured by postmodern and poststructuralist nonsense about race and sex which they have tried hard to ram down the public’s throat, under the threat of ostracism at best and arrest at worst. The list includes theories about race concocted and promoted by US academics: white privilege, white fragility, white saviourism, intersectionality, institutional racism, systemic racism and anti-racism – all of which implode when confronted by anyone with common sense not working in a university, police force, arts organisation or HR department.

The same is true of the conceptual juggernaut surrounding gender ideology and queer theory. Whole academic industries sustain this, and elaborate arrangements have been put in place, inspired by egalitarianism and individualism taken to extremes, to ensure that the interests of ‘oppressed’ minorities can trump those of the majority. This was symbolised for me recently by the report of a large bearded male tutor at St Hilda’s College, University of Oxford, who gives lectures in a mini skirt, high heels and enormous fake breasts, and against whom, because of his inalienable right to self-expression, no action has been taken by the college authorities despite students feeling they have been given a front row seat at an exhibition of someone’s sexual fetish.

It is the ideology implicit in this example that has allowed outrages like transwomen competing in female sports, puberty blockers given to young girls, men in black leather pulled along on leads like dogs on Pride marches watched by children and drag queens taken into primary schools on the recommendation of England’s leading teaching union. Arendt’s view that one of the aims of totalitarianism is to replace common sense applies equally to the way we have been forced to allow these alien ideologies into our everyday lives. We are closer to a new form of totalitarianism than we might think.

Are populist movements part of the solution to this lack of common sense? Furedi hopes so, especially if they can foster a democracy in which citizens are active participants and power genuinely rests with the demos, and not with quangos, experts, judges and international bodies.

They might find, however, as Arendt did with totalitarian regimes, that the ideologies thrust upon us have undermined our ability to think for ourselves. It has even been suggested that the state’s total failure to stem the tide of illegal immigration, rather than provoking furious political activity, “has numbed the British public to the point of apathy”.

Common sense also did not serve us well during the Covid ‘pandemic’, when polls showed that the public repeatedly demanded stricter measures and earlier and longer lockdowns than a panicked and incompetent government was already introducing. Similarly, despite the Net Zero 2050 target visibly destroying our economy, a strong majority of the population continue to support it, maybe in this case because broadcasters and press illiberally restrict access to anyone who disputes ‘settled climate science’.

It is in this context that Furedi, summing up the prospects for populist movements, argues that, as well as making themselves more ‘professional’, they need to “create/attract an intelligentsia that can assist (them) to gain a degree of cultural authority” and “establish a presence in their country’s intellectual life”. This is neither Pareto’s ‘counter-elite’ nor the ‘virtuous elite’ committed to the common good recommended by the American political philosopher Patrick Deneen, as populists – and Arendt – reject the very idea of an elite. It is, however, a necessary reinforcement to a regime based on ‘common sense’. It is closest perhaps to Aristotle’s idea 2,400 years ago of a polity where “the wisdom of the multitude” and the specialist skills of experts work harmoniously together.

Are populist parties up to achieving such a synthesis? Even if not yet fully ready to do so, could they possibly, at least in Britain, do any worse than the legacy parties and the rest of the technocratic-managerial elite that in recent decades have so spectacularly turned their backs on common sense?

Dr Nicholas Tate was chief adviser on Curriculum and Assessment to England’s Secretaries of State for Education 1994–2000 and an adviser to French education ministers 2001–2007. He is currently Adviser to the Mathias Corvinus Collegium (MCC) in Hungary. This article was sourced HERE

No comments:

Post a Comment

Thank you for joining the discussion. Breaking Views welcomes respectful contributions that enrich the debate. Please ensure your comments are not defamatory, derogatory or disruptive. We appreciate your cooperation.