Pages

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Bob Edlin: When the Environment Court ruling on culturally sensitive sites is disappointing .....


.......well, let’s try the Maori Land Court

RNZ reports that Environment Court Judge Jeff Smith has dismissed a case involving earthworks that damaged culturally significant sites in the Far North.

“Culturally significant sites”, it’s fair to suppose, does not refer to an opera house, library or botanical gardens.

Sure enough, the case – brought by Heritage New Zealand’s against Valentina Trustees – was triggered by the damaging of a pā site.

The damage had been done during the clearing of land “on a site of great significance for the descendants of Muriwhenua and Ngāti Kahu”.

But who did the damage?

That’s where the case came unglued.

As the RNZ report says:

The archaeological damage was obvious. The culprit was not.

In a stinging ruling, an Environment Court judge has dismissed a prosecution over earthworks at an ancient Far North pā site, finding that critical gaps left a fundamental question unanswered.

Who actually destroyed the site?


Mind you, there are other ways of handling issues like this. Rather than require the prosecution to prove its case, why not demand “tougher laws to prosecute those who damage waahi tapu (see the Facebook post at the top of this article)?

The RNZ report continued:

Valentina Trustees was charged over alleged damage to six archaeological sites on its property at Takarau Bay in the Far North.

The 70ha block stretches from the Hihi Peninsula to west of Taemaro and contains the spiritually significant Puketakahia Pā kāinga (home) site on Maunga Whakaangi.


When the case was heard last month, the prosecutor said Valentina Trustees “ought reasonably to have suspected” there may have been additional archaeological sites.

The defence case was that they did not know they were archaeological sites or that they required an authority.

During the proceedings, Judge Smith questioned whether the Crown’s argument would effectively require authorisation for earthworks across much of Northland.

“I just need to warn you that I’ll be looking at that with a grain of salt because we need to understand that much of Northland has been heavily occupied and modified over the years, not only by Europeans but by Māori as well,” Smith said.

“The suggestion that you couldn’t do anything in Northland because there might be an archaeological site there would be problematic because there are sites everywhere.

“It can’t be the case that Heritage New Zealand has to grant a consent for all earthworks that are conducted in Northland?”


To succeed with its prosecution, Heritage NZ had to prove that Valentina Trustees knew or ought reasonably to have suspected that the sites contained archaeological features.

Only two of six areas were officially recorded with authorities.

The work was done by a company called Tahere Contracting.

Judge Smith accepted that the company had permission to be on the land to upgrade tracks.

What remained unclear was what further work the contractor had been instructed to do, after one pā site was flattened.

Heritage NZ told the court that it tried to contact Tahere Contracting, but the company declined to engage.

No contractor witnesses were called to the trial, and no evidence of communications or terms of agreement between Tahere and Valentina was submitted.

“There is absolutely no detail as to what the instruction was from Valentina to the company,” Judge Smith said.


The RNZ report gives an account of the evidence from archaeologist Justin Maxwell and local kaitiaki (caretaker) Sandra Heihei.

In the upshot, the judge rejected Heritage NZ’s argument that recorded archaeological sites elsewhere on the property should have put the company on notice.

“If Heritage New Zealand are contending that an archaeological site identified on a land title means no works can be undertaken anywhere else on the property without a full archaeological assessment, they go considerably too far,” he said.

“This would blight most of coastal Northland from even permitted activities, such as track maintenance.”


When dismissing the charge, the judge criticised shortcomings in the investigation, saying key questions were never put to witnesses at trial.

“I acknowledge the stress that this has caused for tangata whenua. It is regrettable that a full inquiry was not made.”

He said future prosecutions would require stronger evidence about what contractors and landowners knew, before charges were filed.


The judge also said that, given the serious nature of the modifications in this case, he concluded

“… that the defendant is fortunate that the investigation was not more thorough. Given the damage involved, this would have been regarded as a serious charge, if proved.”

But rather than agree on the need for the prosecution to come up with a more convincing case, Maori Party MP Hana-Rawhiti Maipi has other ideas:
  • Tougher laws are needed to prosecute those who damage waahi tapu; and
  • A Maori Land Court Judge would have been a better choice to judicate over this case.
To buttress that argument, she has assumed Tahere Contracting is a Maori-owned company.

PoO harnessed Google and learned that Tahere Contracting Limited is a New Zealand excavating and earthworks company based on the Karikari Peninsula in Northland.

The company was incorporated in December 2021.

Company records list two directors, Jade Tahi Tahere (appointed at incorporation in December 2021) and Melanie Joy Sutton (appointed in March 2023).

The MP is not alone in wanting environmental and Māori land disputes sorted out in the Maori Land Court.

Many Māori legal scholars, tribal organisations, and Māori political leaders have argued that matters concerning Māori land should be dealt with by that court because it has specialist expertise in tikanga Māori and Te Ture Whenua Māori Act, rather than by the Environment Court, whose primary focus is resource management law.

Bob Edlin is a veteran journalist and editor for the Point of Order blog HERE.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Thank you for joining the discussion. Breaking Views welcomes respectful contributions that enrich the debate. Please ensure your comments are not defamatory, derogatory or disruptive. We appreciate your cooperation.