Pages

Saturday, November 21, 2026

Geoff Parker: Human Rights Commission - From Treaty Education To Constitutional Transformation


The Human Rights Commission has published two documents under its Ā Tātou Kōrero initiative: a 20-page booklet, Enabling Te Tiriti Conversations, and a supplementary factsheet, Te Tiriti in our constitution.

Both are presented as educational material intended to encourage an informed national conversation about the Treaty of Waitangi and New Zealand's constitutional arrangements.

But read them together and a clear political and constitutional direction emerges.

The Commission is not simply explaining the Treaty or encouraging discussion. It is promoting a particular interpretation of sovereignty, advocating greater constitutional protection for Te Tiriti and introducing proposals for sharing political power and transforming New Zealand's constitutional arrangements.

That raises serious questions about the role of a taxpayer-funded institution whose responsibilities include promoting human rights, racial equality and harmonious relations.

1. THE SOVEREIGNTY CLAIM

Both publications make the assertion that Māori rangatira did not cede sovereignty to the Crown.

The booklet states on page 9:

"In signing Te Tiriti the rangatira did not cede (give away) their sovereignty or authority to the Crown."

The supplementary factsheet repeats the claim and explains that rangatira expected kāwanatanga to operate alongside their own tino rangatiratanga, tikanga, governance and decision-making systems.

It further states that the rangatira and Governor would be equals, each responsible for their own people and territories.

The Commission attributes this interpretation to the Waitangi Tribunal's Te Paparahi o Te Raki inquiry.

But important context is missing.

The Tribunal's 2014 Stage 1 report examined the understanding of rangatira in the Bay of Islands and Hokianga who signed on 6 February 1840. Its findings were based on that particular inquiry. They were not a determination of the constitutional arrangements New Zealand must adopt today.

The distinction matters.

The English Treaty text expressly records the cession of sovereignty in Article One. The Māori text uses kāwanatanga. The differences between the two texts are historically important and deserve examination.

Even accepting that finding, it does not by itself establish that New Zealand must now operate under two equal and independent systems of political authority.

The Commission presents a contested constitutional interpretation without adequately explaining its limitations or the competing arguments.

2. THE MOVE TOWARDS SHARED POLITICAL POWER

The supplementary factsheet contains an especially revealing passage on page 2.

Referring to the Waitangi Tribunal's recommendations, it states that constitutional discussions:

"will occur in part at a constitutional level and will require a sharing of power as envisaged in te Tiriti".

This is a significant statement.

The Commission is not merely discussing recognition of Māori culture, language, customary interests or Treaty obligations.

It is introducing the question of how political power should be distributed between the Crown and Māori.

But what does sharing power actually mean?

Who exercises that authority? How is it accountable? What happens when the respective authorities disagree? What is the relationship between such arrangements and Parliament's responsibility to all New Zealanders?

Neither document adequately answers these questions.

These are fundamental issues affecting the government of the entire country. They cannot be resolved by presenting one interpretation of the Treaty as the accepted constitutional starting point.

3. THE EXISTING CONSTITUTION IS PRESENTED AS DEFICIENT

The booklet repeatedly describes Te Tiriti as the constitutional framework for New Zealand.

Page 13 states:

"Although Te Tiriti is our founding agreement and constitutional framework, this is not reflected in the rules and systems we currently have."

The factsheet makes the same argument, claiming that our constitution does not provide secure protection for the Treaty.

There is a fundamental difference between acknowledging the Treaty as a historical agreement signed in 1840 and accepting that it should determine or override how New Zealand is governed today.

New Zealand does not have a single codified constitution. Its constitutional arrangements comprise legislation, court decisions, conventions and other constitutional practices.

The Commission moves from asserting that the Treaty is our constitutional framework to arguing that the existing constitutional arrangements are inadequate.

That is a political and constitutional position, not an uncontested statement of law.

If the Commission believes New Zealand needs a different constitutional structure, it should explain precisely what it proposes and the consequences for parliamentary authority and equal citizenship.

4. PARLIAMENT IS IDENTIFIED AS A PROBLEM

Page 14 of the booklet states:

"With a system that gives significant power to government ministers and Parliament, both Te Tiriti and human rights can be ignored and overridden by law-makers."

This is particularly concerning.

Parliament's legislative authority is a fundamental feature of New Zealand's representative democracy. Elected MPs make laws and are accountable to voters.

There is a legitimate debate about whether particular rights should receive stronger legal protection.

But there is an equally important question: should unelected institutions and courts acquire greater authority to constrain decisions made by elected representatives?

The Commission emphasises the need to protect Treaty obligations from parliamentary decisions but gives little attention to the democratic consequences of transferring greater constitutional authority away from elected representatives.

Who ultimately decides what the Treaty requires? Who determines the limits of Parliament's authority? Who is accountable to the electorate?

These questions deserve answers before any constitutional restructuring is contemplated.

5. MATIKE MAI AND CONSTITUTIONAL TRANSFORMATION

Both publications refer to the 2016 Matike Mai Aotearoa report.

The factsheet explains that the report was based on more than 320 hui and considered what an inclusive, Treaty-based constitution might look like.

It also acknowledges that the report proposed a range of potential constitutional models.

That is an important admission.

Matike Mai was not simply about better consultation or improved relationships. It explored alternative constitutional arrangements involving different spheres of authority and relationships between Māori and the Crown.

The booklet, however, provides little explanation of what those models would mean for parliamentary democracy, political representation or the distribution of governmental power.

It introduces constitutional transformation as a subject for further discussion without adequately explaining the proposals themselves.

New Zealanders should be able to examine these models, understand their implications and decide whether they support them.

That requires more than a brief reference to a report and its recommended values.

6. THE UNITED NATIONS AND THE DOMESTIC CONSTITUTION

Both publications rely heavily on recommendations from international human rights bodies.

The booklet quotes the United Nations Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination (CERD), including recommendations to uphold Te Tiriti as a constitutional framework and counter what the Committee describes as misinformation and divisive narratives.

The factsheet goes further, advocating constitutional discussions in partnership with Māori and referring to international recommendations supporting the Matike Mai report.

International human rights recommendations can inform New Zealand's policies and public debate.

But they are not laws passed by our Parliament, nor do they automatically determine how New Zealand must organise its constitutional arrangements.

There is also a troubling implication in presenting disagreement about Treaty interpretations as misinformation or divisive narratives.

New Zealanders must remain free to question historical claims, challenge constitutional proposals and disagree with political interpretations of the Treaty.

That is democracy, not misinformation.

A genuine national conversation must accommodate disagreement rather than define acceptable conclusions in advance.

7. THE POSTERS: FOUR MESSAGES, IMPORTANT OMISSIONS

The Commission has also produced four downloadable posters for public display. Their messages deserve examination.

One declares that Indigenous peoples have the right to self-determination under Article 3 of the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP).

But it omits Article 46, which protects the territorial integrity and political unity of sovereign and independent states and requires the Declaration to be interpreted consistently with democracy, equality and non-discrimination.

Article 46 makes clear that self-determination cannot be interpreted as authorising the dismemberment of New Zealand's territorial integrity or political unity.

Another poster declares that the rangatira who signed Te Tiriti in February 1840 did not cede sovereignty.

That quotation comes from the Waitangi Tribunal's 2014 Stage 1 Te Paparahi o Te Raki report. But the poster omits an important qualification: the report examined the understanding of rangatira in the Bay of Islands and Hokianga. It did not determine New Zealand's present constitutional arrangements.

A third poster reproduces Article 2 of the Māori Treaty text, concerning tino rangatiratanga. But it offers no explanation of how Article 2 relates to Article 1 or the Crown's governing authority.

The fourth poster makes perhaps the most consequential claim. Quoting Justice Glazebrook's reasons in the Supreme Court's Ellis v R decision, it declares that tikanga as law is part of New Zealand's common law and describes this as a longstanding and uncontroversial proposition.

The quotation is genuine. However, the wider judgment provides important context. Justice Glazebrook states that the common law is in a state of transition, that case law on tikanga remains relatively limited, and that its further development will be gradual and incremental. The Court's majority also emphasised that the relationship between tikanga and the common law would evolve contextually, on a case-by-case basis.

The poster presents the statement but omits this important context.

These posters are short, emphatic statements intended for public display. They present complex historical, legal and constitutional issues as simple established propositions.

The problem is not that the Commission has produced educational material about these subjects. It is that important qualifications and competing interpretations are missing.

For an organisation calling for good faith and good-quality information, that is a serious failing.

8. WHERE IS THE BALANCE?

The Commission is entitled to discuss Crown breaches of the Treaty. There were injustices, land confiscations and failures by successive governments. These should not be denied.

But an educational publication should provide a broader historical picture.

New Zealand's history also includes the development of representative government, the extension of voting rights, individual property rights, public education, healthcare and the rule of law.

The Māori Representation Act 1867 established four Māori parliamentary seats. Māori men gained voting rights irrespective of property ownership, while non-Māori men remained subject to property qualifications until 1879.

These facts do not erase historical injustices. They are nevertheless part of the country's development and deserve recognition.

The Commission's publications devote considerable attention to Crown breaches and the alleged shortcomings of current constitutional arrangements, but offer little examination of the arguments supporting parliamentary sovereignty, equal citizenship or alternative interpretations of the Treaty.

The footnotes reinforce this concern. They draw heavily on the Waitangi Tribunal, Matike Mai, Claire Charters, Margaret Mutu, Moana Jackson and other sources associated with Treaty and constitutional reform.

These sources can legitimately inform debate. The problem is the lack of substantial competing perspectives.

A reference list does not make a publication balanced.

9. WHO AUTHORISED THIS CONSTITUTIONAL DIRECTION?

The Human Rights Commission has statutory responsibilities under the Human Rights Act 1993, including promoting human rights education and harmonious relations.

But those responsibilities do not give it the authority to settle New Zealand's constitutional future.

The two publications repeatedly advance the proposition that existing constitutional arrangements are inadequate and that stronger Treaty protection and some form of shared political authority are required.

They introduce constitutional transformation without adequately explaining its implications for Parliament, democratic accountability and equal citizenship.

That is not a minor omission.

New Zealanders have a right to know when a public institution is moving beyond explaining the Treaty and promoting a particular constitutional direction.

The Government should require the Commission to explain the basis for its claims, the selection of its sources and why its publications do not adequately present competing constitutional arguments.

If constitutional transformation is the objective, say so openly and put the proposals before the public for proper debate.

New Zealand does not belong to the Crown, iwi leaders, academics or the Human Rights Commission. It belongs to all its citizens.

Its constitutional future must be determined through democratic debate and public consent, not by gradually normalising one particular interpretation through taxpayer-funded institutions.

One country. Equal citizenship. One democratic system. One law for all.

Geoff Parker is a passionate advocate for equal rights and a colour blind society.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Thank you for joining the discussion. Breaking Views welcomes respectful contributions that enrich the debate. Please ensure your comments are not defamatory, derogatory or disruptive. We appreciate your cooperation.