....(and save ratepayers’ money) without a code-of-conduct investigation
Let the record show not all councils become unduly exercised by the use of robust, intemperate or offensive language.
Not if invoking code of conduct procedures is likely to cost plenty and accomplish little.
While there have been widespread demands for New Zealand First’s Michael Laws to be denounced, delisted and denied the place in Parliament he secured at the 2026 General Election, his seat on the Otago Regional Council looks more secure.
The howls for him to be kept well clear of Parliament were prompted several days after his 29 October broadcast on The Platform when what he said – tongue in cheek – was eagerly shared by newspapers and broadcasters with a much wider audience.
And so the public learned he had expressed an unchivalrous opinion on the attractiveness of some Opportunity Party candidates.
Those candidates demanded Laws stand down as a New Zealand First candidate and leave politics altogether while other politicians grabbed the opportunity to flourish their misogyny-condemning credentials.
Since the election, speculation and external pressure has been maintained over whether he should decline his NZ First list seat in Parliament.
PoO is unaware of similar campaigning to have him resign from the regional council.
There was an attempt to have him denounced by the council.
Councillor Kate Wilson drafted a notice of motion for the council to denounce the remarks and reaffirm Code of Conduct values.
But she explicitly declined to file a formal Code of Conduct complaint, telling the Otago Daily Times that the process was “ineffectual” and wasted ratepayer money.
Her example should serve as a model for councillors elsewhere to follow when their indignation overwhelms their common sense.
In the upshot, the council has done no more than endorse a letter from the chair which declares it does not share Laws’ views.
An account of what happened has been posted on The Wanaka App in a report headed
Otago Regional Council chair Hilary Calvert made it clear at yesterday’s meeting there would be no discussion about Michael Laws’ conduct, and there was no notice of motion tabled either.
Instead a letter from the chair was added to the agenda, regarding Cr Laws’ comments in the media recently, “which cast aspersions on the appearance and behaviours of some female candidates of another political party”.
“…we wish to make it clear that the comments and values expressed are in no way those of the Otago Regional Council,” Cr Calvert’s letter stated.
Cr Kate Wilson’s original attempt to put forward a notice of motion denouncing Laws’ remarks had been pulled by the chief executive last week, but was expected to be discussed at the meeting this week.
Calvert said it was not appropriate for a discussion to turn into council making any findings or decisions about anything in her letter.
“Where an alleged breach of code of conduct is an issue, the code provides an appropriate process for considering it. That is important to ensure fairness to everyone, and to provide natural justice,” she said.
It should be noted that Wilson employed the “safety” factor in her notice of motion:
The intention of Cr Wilson’s motion was to ensure the regional council worked actively to provide a safe environment free of fear of intimidation.
“It’s absolutely timely that we make sure that our community and our staff know that we want to uphold the code of conduct and the values expressed in it, and that they can feel sure and certain that we want to have a safe workplace,” she said at last week’s meeting.
The same concern for staff safety came into considerations when Laws was the subject of a formal Code of Conduct complaint in August 2021.
The complaint was not upheld following an independent (and no doubt costly) investigation.
On that occasion, council chief executive Sarah Gardner lodged the formal written complaint alleging Cr Laws breached the council’s Code of Conduct when he spoke robustly about council happenings to the Otago Daily Times.
Laws had said it was “extraordinarily embarrassing” that the council had given advice to a company against which it later took enforcement action over illegal dumping in the Clutha River.
He also described a staff report on public submissions for the Manuherikia River as “bogus” and “crap”.
The complaint alleged those remarks endangered staff psychologically and physically.
Really?
Wellington employment lawyer Steph Dyhrberg conducted the investigation and concluded in November 2021 that Laws’ comments did not breach the Code of Conduct.
The council subsequently commissioned an independent review and adopted a revised Code of Conduct in May 2022.
Bob Edlin is a veteran journalist and editor for the Point of Order blog HERE.
The howls for him to be kept well clear of Parliament were prompted several days after his 29 October broadcast on The Platform when what he said – tongue in cheek – was eagerly shared by newspapers and broadcasters with a much wider audience.
And so the public learned he had expressed an unchivalrous opinion on the attractiveness of some Opportunity Party candidates.
Those candidates demanded Laws stand down as a New Zealand First candidate and leave politics altogether while other politicians grabbed the opportunity to flourish their misogyny-condemning credentials.
Since the election, speculation and external pressure has been maintained over whether he should decline his NZ First list seat in Parliament.
PoO is unaware of similar campaigning to have him resign from the regional council.
There was an attempt to have him denounced by the council.
Councillor Kate Wilson drafted a notice of motion for the council to denounce the remarks and reaffirm Code of Conduct values.
But she explicitly declined to file a formal Code of Conduct complaint, telling the Otago Daily Times that the process was “ineffectual” and wasted ratepayer money.
Her example should serve as a model for councillors elsewhere to follow when their indignation overwhelms their common sense.
In the upshot, the council has done no more than endorse a letter from the chair which declares it does not share Laws’ views.
An account of what happened has been posted on The Wanaka App in a report headed
ORC chair ends discussion on Michael Laws’ conduct
Otago Regional Council chair Hilary Calvert made it clear at yesterday’s meeting there would be no discussion about Michael Laws’ conduct, and there was no notice of motion tabled either.
Instead a letter from the chair was added to the agenda, regarding Cr Laws’ comments in the media recently, “which cast aspersions on the appearance and behaviours of some female candidates of another political party”.
“…we wish to make it clear that the comments and values expressed are in no way those of the Otago Regional Council,” Cr Calvert’s letter stated.
Cr Kate Wilson’s original attempt to put forward a notice of motion denouncing Laws’ remarks had been pulled by the chief executive last week, but was expected to be discussed at the meeting this week.
Calvert said it was not appropriate for a discussion to turn into council making any findings or decisions about anything in her letter.
“Where an alleged breach of code of conduct is an issue, the code provides an appropriate process for considering it. That is important to ensure fairness to everyone, and to provide natural justice,” she said.
It should be noted that Wilson employed the “safety” factor in her notice of motion:
The intention of Cr Wilson’s motion was to ensure the regional council worked actively to provide a safe environment free of fear of intimidation.
“It’s absolutely timely that we make sure that our community and our staff know that we want to uphold the code of conduct and the values expressed in it, and that they can feel sure and certain that we want to have a safe workplace,” she said at last week’s meeting.
The same concern for staff safety came into considerations when Laws was the subject of a formal Code of Conduct complaint in August 2021.
The complaint was not upheld following an independent (and no doubt costly) investigation.
On that occasion, council chief executive Sarah Gardner lodged the formal written complaint alleging Cr Laws breached the council’s Code of Conduct when he spoke robustly about council happenings to the Otago Daily Times.
Laws had said it was “extraordinarily embarrassing” that the council had given advice to a company against which it later took enforcement action over illegal dumping in the Clutha River.
He also described a staff report on public submissions for the Manuherikia River as “bogus” and “crap”.
The complaint alleged those remarks endangered staff psychologically and physically.
Really?
Wellington employment lawyer Steph Dyhrberg conducted the investigation and concluded in November 2021 that Laws’ comments did not breach the Code of Conduct.
The council subsequently commissioned an independent review and adopted a revised Code of Conduct in May 2022.
Bob Edlin is a veteran journalist and editor for the Point of Order blog HERE.

No comments:
Post a Comment
Thank you for joining the discussion. Breaking Views welcomes respectful contributions that enrich the debate. Please ensure your comments are not defamatory, derogatory or disruptive. We appreciate your cooperation.