For TOP to be kingmaker, the party must persuade at least one voter in twenty to vote for it. Not easy.
I identify four very different TOP voters.
First, the protest voter. I have been a scrutineer. Some people go to the trouble of voting only to cross out every candidate. There were 16,252 informal party votes in 2023. TOP offers another way to register a protest.
Second, the single-issue voter.
Third, those who hate partisan politics.
Fourth, those who think TOP will make their preferred bloc the government.
If you cannot ride two horses, you should not be in the circus.
Quila Wong is riding four horses heading in different directions.
A party promising to do a deal with every established party is no longer a protest party.
TOP was founded as a single-issue party, advocating a guaranteed income funded by a land tax.
Wong can say the policy is still on the party’s website. That is where it will stay.
If it is not the priority before the election, it will never be after.
Seeking consensus is admirable. But we cannot do everything. In Parliament, MPs must vote Aye or No. There is no third lobby labelled future.
And those who want TOP to make their preferred bloc the government cannot all be satisfied.
The fourth horse is really two horses, left and right.
Whichever horse Wong chooses, many will feel betrayed.
The real question is not whether Quila Wong can ride five horses until Saturday, but which horse will she ride on Sunday?
The Honourable Richard Prebble CBE is a former member of the New Zealand Parliament. Initially a member of the Labour Party, he joined the newly formed ACT New Zealand party under Roger Douglas in 1996, becoming its leader from 1996 to 2004. This article was sourced HERE
Third, those who hate partisan politics.
Fourth, those who think TOP will make their preferred bloc the government.
If you cannot ride two horses, you should not be in the circus.
Quila Wong is riding four horses heading in different directions.
A party promising to do a deal with every established party is no longer a protest party.
TOP was founded as a single-issue party, advocating a guaranteed income funded by a land tax.
Wong can say the policy is still on the party’s website. That is where it will stay.
If it is not the priority before the election, it will never be after.
Seeking consensus is admirable. But we cannot do everything. In Parliament, MPs must vote Aye or No. There is no third lobby labelled future.
And those who want TOP to make their preferred bloc the government cannot all be satisfied.
The fourth horse is really two horses, left and right.
Whichever horse Wong chooses, many will feel betrayed.
The real question is not whether Quila Wong can ride five horses until Saturday, but which horse will she ride on Sunday?
The Honourable Richard Prebble CBE is a former member of the New Zealand Parliament. Initially a member of the Labour Party, he joined the newly formed ACT New Zealand party under Roger Douglas in 1996, becoming its leader from 1996 to 2004. This article was sourced HERE

3 comments:
Honest to God, why at this 11th hour before the election at midnight does anyone take TOP seriously as a party who has anything in common with the current government? Why?
It is painfully clear they are, as described by an ex staffer, woke Pakeha management class. They contain the worst of the stereotypical Wellington lanyard wearing bureaucracy lifers who despise the current government.
All their woke credentials are on display.
The simply infantile lethal take on law and order, raising the criminal youth age to 25.
Hugely invasive taxation including property followed by redistribution of wealth.
Te tiriti everything, (which that goes to the heart of this project).
Dedicated unquestioning worshippers of the climate change religion with all the sheer madness that accompanies that.
Thought and speech controllers.
TOP are in the Ardern league of wokeness. Oozing pampered middle-class cosseted "kind" people on the side of angels who care, but with that chilling Orwellian ability to turn on anyone and simply destroy their lives who dare think otherwise.
Their only point of difference was to hire an actress, a hither to unknown, to front a fictional story that they crossed over between the government and opposition benches.
Yet when their blatant hard left policies began to fall under the spot light, they were simply waved away to foster the illusion that they could work with anyone.
They are a very clever, deeply cynical, dishonest attempt to get an otherwise unelectable radical left block into power. End of story.
Increasingly politics will be less about left and right and more about ‘deprived’ youth vs ‘privileged’ age.
TOP represents the former so may well survive, provided deprived youth managed to get of their arses to enrol in time.
Good comment pete... A true WTF time in politics.
Post a Comment
Thank you for joining the discussion. Breaking Views welcomes respectful contributions that enrich the debate. Please ensure your comments are not defamatory, derogatory or disruptive. We appreciate your cooperation.