Pages

Showing posts with label The Treaty of Waitangi. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The Treaty of Waitangi. Show all posts

Friday, November 6, 2026

Bob Edlin: A reminder of the Dickson case....


......tribunal is ruling on real estate agents’ work for reasons unrelated to their beliefs

PoO has noted this news from Stuff:

Two real estate agents committed unsatisfactory conduct by assuring buyers all earthquake damage was repaired and failing to investigate red flags that would have revealed an uncompleted retaining wall claim and a $37,350 Earthquake Commission payout.

Wednesday, December 11, 2024

Barrie Davis: Our Colonial Heritage

There have recently been a number of pundits anguishing about the state and direction of the New Zealand economy; for example, Dr Peter Winsley (here). Furthermore, there have been a number of punters, including myself, who reckon it is only a matter of time before we are a third world country. I doubt it will last the rest of this century, which is a problem for those with children. The better informed have offered specific actions which they believe are necessary to rescue New Zealand from decline, for example Shane Jones (here).

Sunday, November 3, 2024

Clive Bibby: Violence of another kind

A never ending modern day topic of conversation - the correct version of Treaty of Waitangi interpretation has reached fever pitch. Most of the radical view is focused on a “made up” interpretation that has no basis in fact. 

Reputable Maori scholars of yesteryear, including Sir Apirana Ngata, concluded that a majority of chiefs at the signing were clearly motivated to bring a halt to the carnage being inflicted on their own people by rogue tribes and in order to bring peace to a troubled land, they were prepared to, amongst other things, cede sovereignty to the English Crown in exchange for a colonial army that would restore order. 

Tuesday, October 1, 2024

Gerrard Eckhoff: Them or Us

The Treaty of Waitangi is possibly / probably more contentious today than it was 184 years ago . Some call the Treaty of Waitangi a simple agreement between many peoples.  Others refer to it as Articles of Association to achieve a common cause.   It has been referred to as a contract between Maori and the Queen of England or as a promissory  pact  between the Queens representatives and a diverse grouping of Maori chiefs. What it was definitely is not - is a constitution for or of the country. 

Bruce Moon: A few things that need to be said

We must all by now have a pretty good idea that politics and political discussions, however necessary they may be, have a malignant effect on many things which are undoubtedly true and should be accepted as such by all. Nowhere is this more true than in the current and seemingly endless debate on the Treaty of Waitangi: what it meant and its consequences today.

There can be no doubt that the British Government of the day was acting from the highest principles of international law and practice and goodwill in despatching Captain Hobson to New Zealand in 1839 with the express objective of establishing British sovereignty over New Zealand with the free consent of the native population.

Thursday, September 12, 2024

Bruce Moon: Democracy at Work

Well now, perhaps the plot is thickening with that doughty veteran, Dame Anne Salmond, asserting the “breathtaking ... effrontery” of David Seymour in his “riposte” (her word) to Church leaders.

She seems to forget that Seymour is in fact a senior member of Parliament who happens to be a deputy Prime Minister and free speech being not quite dead yet in this country, he has every right to make this challenge to church leaders – or anybody else for that matter.  Equally, those church leaders have every right to reply to him should they wish to do so.  All good, surely when the topic is quite an important one.

Friday, May 31, 2024

Chris Newman: Treaty Principles Come Before Rhetoric

The principles of law must pre-exist Te Tiriti o Waitangi of 6th February 1840. Scholars recognise that principles represent the fundamental truth operating as the foundation for all subsequent statements. On “principles”, Black’s Law Dictionary declares, “A truth or proposition so clear that it cannot be proved or contradicted unless by a proposition which is still clearer”. Principles establish the legal maxim, “earlier in time, stronger in law’.

Bruce Moon: Twisting the Treaty has never stopped


A headline in the “Dominion Post” for 27 May 2024 reads “Maori ready their lines of defence of Treaty rights”.  This is followed by an article by K (Guru) Gurunathan, a former Mayor of Kapiti and, we are informed, a “regular opinion contributor”.

 

All very well perhaps but surely it is fair to ask just what are those “Treaty rights” and why indeed do they need “defending”?  Let us refer to the officially authorised 1869 translation of the treaty by T.E. Young of the Native Department.[1]  

Tuesday, March 5, 2024

Frank Newman: “Book burning” at the Hutt City Council


As many readers will be aware the NZCPR recently distributed some 600,000 copies of a booklet called The Treaty of Waitangi – An Explanation by Sir Apirana Ngata. These were distributed as an insert in 31 NZME and Stuff newspapers throughout the North Island. This followed distribution throughout the South Island in July last year. In total 1.1 million inserts have been distributed.

 The Treaty of Waitangi – An Explanation was written in 1922 and was considered of such importance that in 1963 the Ministry of Maori Affairs translated the work into English and distributed it to every Maori household in NZ. Given the current debate about the meaning of the treaty, and the high regard with which Sir Apirana Ngata was held and is still held (his portrait appears on our $50 banknote), the Explanation is a useful contribution to the debate.

 In early February we were tipped off that management at the Hutt City Council had ordered copies of the insert be removed from its premises, so I wrote to the Council’s Chief Executive Officer asking for clarification.

Tuesday, February 6, 2024

Tim Watkin: Let's Put Down Our Chisels And Let Te Tiriti O Waitangi Evolve


History is a living thing. The past not only tells us of where we’ve come from, it walks with us today and pushes us down certain paths to the future. It is an active, persistent, demanding presence; a stone in our shoe, a beam of light shining over our shoulders.

Yet as we confront another Waitangi Day full of debate, there are many eager to get out their chisels and carve our history into stone.

Monday, January 22, 2024

Sandra Goudie: Treaty of Waitangi

The Treaty does not need to be re-visited and nor is there any need for Treaty Principles.

What the government needs to do is honour the Treaty by ensuring we are all treated equally in the law.

That means wherever there is reference to the Treaty of Waitangi in law, the wording must be changed to reflect fact. Ergo, we must ‘have regard to the Treaty of Waitangi’ and not the words, ‘have regard to the Principles of the Treaty of Waitangi’ since none have been established. All legislation/regulation should be amended accordingly.

Tuesday, December 12, 2023

Chris Trotter: Contested ground


Last week The Waitangi Tribunal released Tino Rangatiratanga me te Kāwanatanga: The Report on Stage 2 of the Te Paparahi o Te Raki Inquiry(Wai 1040). For the sake of brevity, I shall refer to this spawling document as the Northland Report. Sadly, the Report seems destined to make the already fraught relationship between Māori and the Crown even worse. Questions relating to who wields sovereignty in New Zealand – including Northland – are fast acquiring the sort of weight and momentum that drives people irresistibly towards the conclusion that push is coming to shove.

Saturday, December 9, 2023

Jerry Coyne: A powerful University dean in New Zealand touts merging higher education with indigenous spirituality


This article from New Zealand’s Newsroom site was written by Julie Rowland, the deputy dean of the Faculty of Science at the University of Auckland as well as a geologist and the Director of the Ngā Ara Whetū | Centre for Climate, Biodiversity & Society. In other word, she’s a scientist.

One key to what the article is about is given by its subtitle, ”

Thursday, December 7, 2023

Bruce Moon: Response to Godfery

“Memories of emotional events are stamped on running water” - Aristotle

And now we have it ‒  in his view anyway ‒  from Morgan Godfery who has got himself a job as a senior lecturer in the law faculty at Victoria University of Wellington as reported by “The Post” for 30th November 2023.

While I emphatically do not identify with either the “radical left” or “libertarian right” to which he refers, I do agree with the point on which, Godfery says, they “probably agree”: emphatically the so-called principles of the Treaty of Waitangi are a sham.

Roger Childs: The Treaty belongs to all of us New Zealanders


Do the people who marched and gathered last Tuesday in protest at planned government policy changes, and given lead item coverage by the Leftist Mainstream Media, know what is actually in the Treaty?

The 1840 document – the only valid treaty – was a very far-sighted agreement at the time which guaranteed British sovereignty and protection; the rule of law; the protection of property ownership, and equal citizenship rights for all New Zealanders. In other words – democracy, equality and fairness. However, the process would only be complete when voting rights for all adults, with the exception of Chinese, came in 1893. (Chinese first voted in 1952.)

Friday, November 17, 2023

Bruce Moon: The Elephant in the Room?


“Democracy must belong to all of us” 
Dennis Chavez
 

For a hotbed of racist propaganda and dubious history one need look no further than a publication called “E-Tangata”. And for an extreme example from it, one need look no further that the article by Moana Maniapoto dated 12 November 2023.

Tuesday, October 31, 2023

Chris Trotter: The Demographic Fix.


It could not be recorded today, let alone top the charts. Blue Mink’s anthemic “Melting Pot”, released in 1969, was a product of that brief sunny moment in history when people genuinely believed the world would be a better place if all of its peoples could “just get together in a lovin’ machine” that turned out “coffee-coloured people by the score”.

The problem was that, by 1969, the world had already moved on from the idea of a single human family. Dr Martin Luther King’s self-sacrificial creed of non-violent civil disobedience had died even before he did, replaced with the “Burn, Baby, Burn!” of ghetto insurrectionists and Black nationalists. In New Zealand, too, the rise of Nga Tamatoa and the Polynesian Panthers offered a strong challenge to the 1960 Hunn Report’s policy of integration.

Thursday, October 26, 2023

Greg Dawes: Political Decolonization


There’s a lot of talk at the present time about ‘decolonization’. But despite the frequency with which the word is used, it’s hard to find an explanation of what it means. In an effort to understand the issues involved, I’ve been reading a historian and political theorist of the colonial period, Mahmood Mamdani.

Mamdani’s writings focus on the colonization of Africa and the rise of post-colonial African states. He is well placed to understand his topic. Coming from an Indian family, Mamdani was born in Mumbai, of parents who had been brought up in Tanzania. He himself was brought up in Kampala, the Ugandan capital, and studied in the United States, where he was involved in the civil rights movement. Shortly after returning to Uganda, he was expelled from the country because of his Asian ethnicity. After fleeing to Britain as a refugee, he returned to take up a university position in Tanzania, before returning to Uganda, where he was stripped of citizenship for criticizing the new government’s policies. But he outlived his political opponents and is now Chancellor of Kampala International University.

Sunday, October 15, 2023

Roger Childs: Yet another dreadful Stuffer article


Continuing bias in the mainstream media

Throughout the term of the Labour government and particularly since the 2023 election campaign began, The Post and fellow Stuff papers have pushed hard for the Left to prevail yesterday. The political writers, some columnists and most cartoonists have shown a strong bias towards Chris Hipkins and hjs allies. This has been obvious in–

Friday, October 13, 2023

Elizabeth Rata: The Treaty and Neotribal Capitalism


This paper was published in “Public Sector, The Journal of the Institute of Public Administration New Zealand”, Vol 26, No 3 September, 2003, pp. 2 - 6


The Treaty of Waitangi has become a talisman for a bicultural New Zealand. Such a leap from prior obscurity to ‘oracle’ status (Sharp, 2002) can be explained in a number of ways. The orthodox explanation is that Maori have overcome colonial-imposed subordination for the economic and political partnership promised by the treaty. In this paper I propose a different interpretation.