Speaking to Duncan Garner, Steve Gibson, the Hastings councillor described the region’s new water structure as “Three Waters in drag” and said the core problem is not Māori, but unelected influence.
“Nothing to do with Māori, it’s to do with the unelected officials running the show,” he said. His warning is that power is being shifted away from elected councillors and towards people the public cannot remove.
Gibson says the public already rejected co-governance. Labour, he argues, lost the 2023 election with Three Waters hanging around its neck, and Māori wards were rejected in referendums, including in Hastings. But councils are bringing it back anyway through advisory forums, appointed representatives and governance structures that sit further and further from the ballot box.
Gibson points to Article 3 of the Treaty, which promises equal citizenship under one system, not separate authority based on ancestry. “Where is the word co-governance or partnership in that?” he asks.
Councillor Hana Montaperto-Hendry said there was “nothing to be scared of in appointing a mana whenua representative”. Gibson’s answer is that the public is told there is nothing to fear, even as unelected voices gain more say over public assets and services.
He warns that if this model keeps spreading, iwi and other unelected appointees will gain the power to shape systems that charge the public for water without direct electoral accountability.
He also argues that too many councillors are too frightened of being called racist to resist it, blaming what he calls “woke women” and “emasculated men” for helping keep the agenda alive.
Meanwhile, a separate Far North dispute is also worth watching, after claims that as many as 15 unelected iwi and hapū representatives were sitting around the table with only six elected members in one committee setting, prompting calls for intervention and a request from Local Government Minister Simon Watts for officials to engage with the council, though he said the threshold for formal intervention remains very high. Garner said the mayor refused an interview and told him to “f*** off”.
Read more over at The NZ Herald and on YouTube
The Centrist is an online news platform that strives to provide a balance to the public debate - where this article was sourced.
Gibson points to Article 3 of the Treaty, which promises equal citizenship under one system, not separate authority based on ancestry. “Where is the word co-governance or partnership in that?” he asks.
Councillor Hana Montaperto-Hendry said there was “nothing to be scared of in appointing a mana whenua representative”. Gibson’s answer is that the public is told there is nothing to fear, even as unelected voices gain more say over public assets and services.
He warns that if this model keeps spreading, iwi and other unelected appointees will gain the power to shape systems that charge the public for water without direct electoral accountability.
He also argues that too many councillors are too frightened of being called racist to resist it, blaming what he calls “woke women” and “emasculated men” for helping keep the agenda alive.
Meanwhile, a separate Far North dispute is also worth watching, after claims that as many as 15 unelected iwi and hapū representatives were sitting around the table with only six elected members in one committee setting, prompting calls for intervention and a request from Local Government Minister Simon Watts for officials to engage with the council, though he said the threshold for formal intervention remains very high. Garner said the mayor refused an interview and told him to “f*** off”.
Read more over at The NZ Herald and on YouTube
The Centrist is an online news platform that strives to provide a balance to the public debate - where this article was sourced.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Thank you for joining the discussion. Breaking Views welcomes respectful contributions that enrich the debate. Please ensure your comments are not defamatory, derogatory or disruptive. We appreciate your cooperation.