You can download the book here:
https://bit.ly/election-forensics
All nations deserve elections that are conducted with integrity, and election forensics include statistical methods that identify whether or not election results reflect actual voting behaviour. Often, such methods are centred at the level of individual polling stations, ballot boxes and voting machines.
Professor Kovačić’s book begins from the premise that election forensics comprises more than a set of methods for detecting unusual patterns in election data, but form part of a broader democratic infrastructure. If forensic analysis is to be useful, much more than statistical tests and graphs are necessary. We need open election data, machine-readable formats for files that hold relevant information, reliable polling-station protocols, a clear chain of custody for election materials, post-election audits, rules on evidence, courts that understand statistical findings, independent electoral institutions, protected observers, free media and a political environment in which an opponent is not treated as an enemy of the state.
The central aim of Professor Kovačić’s book is to show how election forensics can be embedded in the electoral process - not as an occasional analysis following disputed elections and not as a tool of one side against another, but as a permanent mechanism of public verifiability, legal protection and democratic accountability. In that sense, the book is not only analytic but also practical. It is a reaffirmation of the need to institutionalise the forensic verification of elections, to open all relevant data to public scrutiny, to clarify the rules, to make political competition more level, and to build trust in elections through verification rather than by appealing to trust.
Professor Kovačić asked me to edit the book for speakers of English. I have no doubts that in New Zealand we hold our elections on the basis of robust administrative and other procedures, though I feel that we must consider the role of media and ensure the political neutrality of our public service. In any case, I do hope that some readers will find this book of interest.
Dr David Lillis trained in physics and mathematics at Victoria University and Curtin University in Perth, working as a teacher, researcher, statistician and lecturer for most of his career. He has published many articles and scientific papers, as well as a book on graphing and statistics.
5 comments:
Elections are the problem David, not the solution. Even the most honest elections can still produce leaders like Ardern, Luxon, Starmer, Albanese Hipkins, etc. If some of that academic brainpower could be dedicated to figuring out how to get our best into office their names would liveth for evermore.
The voting public make their choices for their own reasons but, irrespective of who gets voted into power, all voting, counting and reporting processes must be robust and open to objective scrutiny, and legal remedies available, if needed.
Gross violations of process do occur in other countries. In addition, in some jurisdictions the media is manipulated in order to demonise the opposition and paint the current government as the only realistic choice. In addition, in some countries immense pressure is placed on the public service.
I will not comment here on New Zealand's mainstream media, nor on our public service.
Readers can judge for themselves the ideological positions that have been adopted by our public-funded media, much of social media, and our taxpayer-funded public service.
Anon above seems to be asking for a governmental appointment system based on meritocracy - I agree wholeheartedly. A wide variety of countries do this by running public service exams including France, Singapore, India, Malaysia and (gasp) Communist China. But it would take a major attitudinal/cultural shift in favour of making hopefuls sit such exams here to qualify for public service.
Unknown - critical comments must address the substance of the article, not the writer.
In reponse to various enquiries, I confirm that Professor Kovačić’s book is accessible at no cost. Therefore, neither I nor anyone else makes profit from its dissemination. It is made available purely as a public good.
Post a Comment
Thank you for joining the discussion. Breaking Views welcomes respectful contributions that enrich the debate. Please ensure your comments are not defamatory, derogatory or disruptive. We appreciate your cooperation.