Pages

Showing posts with label Real NZ history. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Real NZ history. Show all posts

Sunday, January 12, 2025

Elizabeth Rata: Ngai Tahu Ambitions for the South Island

History and the Treaty

The discussion surrounding the Treaty Principles Bill reveals two very different ways of understanding history.

An ahistorical understanding gives a sacred quality to human events, imbuing them with a spirit of timeless authority beyond human intervention. The 1840 Treaty of Waitangi and the post-1986 partnership principle are given this spiritual authority. It's seen in such phrases as the Treaty speaks to us today and in the fruitless search for a definitive Treaty meaning.

Saturday, September 2, 2023

Bruce Moon: Prepare For A Dirty War


“The goal of modern propaganda is no longer to transform opinion but to arouse an active and mythical belief.”
- 
Jacques Ellul

The observation by French philosopher Jacques Ellul which we quote above could hardly be more accurate than as a description of the relentless fabrication about the Treaty of Waitangi and New Zealand’s history by many a part-Maori commentator so freely featuring in the news media today.  Such a one is “treaty educator” Te Huia Bill Hamilton with a long article in E-Tangata for 27 August 2023.  In it he starts by claiming that “Opposition to co-governance is fuelled by racism, ignorance and fear. And it continues the colonising which asserts European superiority over Indigenous peoples.”

Friday, August 11, 2023

John Robinson: A message to demonstrators

For many years a proposal to divide New Zealand into two people, in direct opposition to the early call that “Now we are one people”, has been built up.  Supporters of racial division have threatened those who stand up for equality, becoming ever more active with many efforts to prevent or close down any debate of the current government policy of co-governance, in a series of determined attacks on free speech.[1] 

There has been no willingness to listen to any alternative point of view by this Government and its supporters, and thus no dialogue.  Many of the public remain unaware of what the policy means and how it is being put into action.

Once again, we challenge these zealots to explain their ideas and meet with other New Zealanders in an open forum.

Sunday, August 6, 2023

Roger Childs: The Impact of the Treaty of Waitangi and Colonisation


…. The two decades following the Treaty of Waitangi were characterized nationally more by co-operation between Maori and Pakeha than by conflict. ~ Historian Michael King

Salvation for Maori

In 1837 Chief Wiremu Hau wrote to the English King asking: Sir …. Will you give us law? Three years later the Treaty of Waitangi brought in the rule of law for all the people of New Zealand. It mean that there was freedom for slaves – mainly women – and the end of cannibalism, inter-tribal war, female infanticide, trading in smoked heads and the killing of prisoners. Disputes between tribes would now have to be settled in the courts and all New Zealanders would be subject to British laws.

The end of the Inter-Tribal Wars saved the Maori people from possible extinction. Over 40,000 men, women and children had been killed in more than 500 battles between 1800 and 1840, and the loss of so many women and girls meant that there were not enough potential mothers for the Maori population to recover quickly.

Saturday, January 7, 2023

Bruce Moon: Ngapuhi Gave Up Their “Sovereignty”- It Is False To Deny It!

Traditional Maori structure was tribal and hierarchical. Intertribal warfare was the norm. Violence was endemic.  Think of the enthusiasm with which muskets were adopted and tens of thousands of Maoris killed in the tribal Musket Wars. Think of the slaughter by Ngapuhi at Mauinaina, Te Totara and Matakitaki!  Chiefs and leaders held power as long as they were unbeaten by rivals. Those that lost, and those under their protection, suffered brutally with loss of autonomy, destruction of their lifestyle, loss of what they possessed: taonga, (goods) and other possessions, but duly guaranteed to them[i] and all New Zealanders in the Treaty. The winners of warfare on the other hand took control, enforced amongst other things by ritual executions, cannibalism, slavery, prostitution and headhunting.

To put it simply – in warfare, winner took all.

Saturday, December 31, 2022

Bruce Moon: Research in New Zealand Universities – a case study

It is a rather curious feature of New Zealand universities today that they swarm with quite a lot of part-Maoris who share a set of common practices somewhat at variance with the free and open exchange of accurately established knowledge.  Whatever the reason, many of these practitioners are women.

 “If I lose mine honour, I lose myself:” Shakespeare, “Antony and Cleopatra": Act 3 Scene 4

So consider the words being spouted by those in New Zealand who should, as a matter of academic integrity, know better.

1.  Curiously they describe our country by the fake name of “Aotearoa”:  We note:

a.    It is essentially a confection of two colonials of English descent. (WP Reeves and SP Smith)

b.   It does not appear anywhere in the Treaty of Waitangi – where the Williams would certainly have used it in their translation had it been Maori usage but simply, it was not!  “Few Maori opted for Aotearoa”[i]

c.    It is a mark of disrespect to the Maori chiefs and representatives who signed the Treaty of Waitangi wherein the country was called Niu Tirani. 

Saturday, December 24, 2022

John Robinson: Escape the guilt trap - who really broke the Treaty?

Three Waters and separate government: the elephant in the room

Many councils have spoken out against the Three Waters proposal, with most focussing on the high cost and the taking of ownership and control by a new national organisation. The public organisation Democracy Action has spoken against the proposal, “since the undemocratic co-governance provisions will bring more complexity, more bureaucracy, more costs – and a whole lot less democratic accountability”. The Taxpayers’ Union has pointed to “the lies about ‘ownership’, the unsuccessful buy off of the local government sector, and the parliamentary skullduggery”.

There was considerable publicity when a group of law academics (professors and PhDs), publicised their opinion that the development of Three Waters raised constitutional concerns, because an entrenched privatisation provision (which was dropped following widespread condemnation) “creates a dangerous precedent”. That provision was a last-minute amendment that the Green Party had insisted on, in order to block possible future privatisation.

The claim that the Greens are opposed to privatisation is smoke and mirrors, a diversion and a con designed to misdirect public attention, away from what is going on. The Three Waters legislation takes all those resources out of public control and gives effective control, that key feature of ownership, to an undefined Maori organisation. That is privatisation in all but name.

Tuesday, December 6, 2022

John Robinson: Are we two peoples - are ‘indigenous’ Maori a race apart?


The current (2022) government policy of co-governance calls for the racial separation of New Zealanders in an apartheid state with separate, race-based parliaments – when we will all come under Maori tribal rule.  Equality and democracy will be gone.  This must not be allowed; this is our country, it is our future to decide – see HERE.

However, there are plans for separate parliaments and a constitution enshrining apartheid under the control of ‘indigenous’ Maori – see HERE. 

This must be stopped - and reversed.

Here, in the third of a series of articles, I ask why Maori should be considered a people apart, and given such power.

Bruce Moon: Yet Another Of The Ilk


Dear, Oh Dear!  Here is yet another one from a University which cannot – or wilfully will not – even get the name of our country right.[i]

Do I have to tell them yet again that “Aotearoa”, which they will never find in that text, near-sacred to some, the Treaty of Waitangi, is a fake name for our country, “certainly not known to Maori as Aotearoa in pre-European times.”[ii]  One might have thought that a Senior Lecturer in Maori history could at least have got that one right, even if his University cannot!

So here is Dr Peter Meihana, doing the usual thing of listing his ancestral Maori tribes – four of them – but with not a word of his apparent European ancestry.  If an academic, or anybody, cannot, or will not, give an accurate summary of such significant details, how much reliance can we put in anything else he says?  We’ll take a look.

Saturday, July 30, 2022

Bruce Moon: The truth or not the truth - that is the question


“A state is either completely democratic, or not at all”  - Robin Lane Fox, ‘The Classical World’, Penguin, 2006, p.182

A bold headlined in “Te Ao Maori News” for 26th July 2022,  proclaims: “New Zealand Wars massacre  was real – Nanaia Mahuta.”

We have Mahuta’s reported claim in this article: “What we need to do is to be revising the historical injustices and hurt and harm in a way that builds our nation, not distract us and perpetuate further division.”

For this of course, we need the truth. We need to know the facts of our own history. This enables us to separate reality from mythology. It also forces us to acknowledge that reality, rather than creating a story by revising the facts to fulfil and perpetuate the social and political ideologies of those who promulgate them.

Sunday, June 26, 2022

Roger Childs: Dispelling appalling lies

Setting the Record Straight on Rangiaowhia 1864

On 21 February 1864, 1000 British troops marched into the tiny, defenceless village of Rangiaowhia and wantonly slaughtered a hundred women and children. Or did they?
- Piers Seed

There is no way that General Cameron, the chivalrous Commander of the Colonial troops in the Waikato War, would contemplate the killing of women and children. He had criticized Kingite general, Wiremu Tamihana, for having women in the front lines at the earlier Battle of Rangariri.

Cameron did want to occupy Rangiaowhia, because it was the major source of food for the Kingite forces, notably at the powerful set of forts at Paterangi. To get to the village he had cleverly by-passed these fortifications in the dead of night to avoid casualties.

Wednesday, June 8, 2022

Bruce Moon: Changing our Country’s Name by Stealth


To anybody who is reasonably observant, the rapid increase in appearance of the word “Aotearoa” in print and the spoken word will appear very striking, even sinister.  Thus, the former Race Relations Commissioner, Dame Susan Devoy, has used it; it has appeared on postage stamps in larger print than our country’s real name and more recently Prime Minister Arden has stated her opinion[1] that “Using 'Aotearoa' and 'New Zealand' together is ‘as it should be’”.

What is going on?  Is our country’s name being changed by stealth?  We are New Zealanders – surely we are proud of that!  By what right can anybody alter it?

As always, we can get some perspective by looking at our history which tells us that “Aotearoa” is a quite recent upstart with scant justification, if any at all, to be used as our country’s name.

Wednesday, May 18, 2022

Roger Childs: The Impact of the Treaty of Waitangi and Colonisation

…. The two decades following the Treaty of Waitangi were characterized nationally more by co-operation between Maori and Pakeha than by conflict. Historian Michael King

Salvation for Maori

In 1837 Chief Wiremu Hau wrote to the English King asking: Sir …. Will you give us law? Three years later the Treaty of Waitangi brought in the rule of law for all the people of New Zealand. It mean that there was freedom for slaves – mainly women – and the end of cannibalism, inter-tribal war, female infanticide, trading in smoked heads and the killing of prisoners. Disputes between tribes would now have to be settled in the courts and all New Zealanders would be subject to British laws.

The end of the Inter-Tribal Wars saved the Maori people from possible extinction. Over 40,000 men, women and children had been killed in more than 500 battles between 1800 and 1840, and the loss of so many women and girls meant that there were not enough potential mothers for the Maori population to recover quickly.

Thursday, February 25, 2021

Peter Bacos: Marion Dufresne at the Bay of Islands 25 March – 12 June 1772


Marc-Joseph Marion Dufresne was baptised at St Malo, Brittany, 24 May 1724. He belonged to the upper bourgeoisie, and although he did not belong to the nobility by birth, by being appointed a Chevalier of the Order of St Louis later in life he acceded to it by military title. He added a territorial designation to his name, from the village in Brittany where his ancestors came from, Le Fresne, but this is not his surname which is Marion, and we will refer to him as such throughout this essay. 

He joined the merchant navy and went to see in 1741. In effect he was a corsair during the War of the Austrian Succession which put France at loggerheads with England. Ships lay in wait around the coast of Brittany and especially the narrow inlets of the Channel Islands to pounce on British ships returning from the West Indies or West Africa laden with precious metals, white wine, oranges, lemons, corn, and rye. Many of these hauls supplied all of France in foodstuffs and were lucrative for the mariners involved.

Monday, December 28, 2020

Peter Bacos: James Cook and the Discovery of New Zealand



In the 250th anniversary celebrations of Cook’s landing in New Zealand last year the government tried to bracket this with the Maori arrival nearly 800 years before. This is typical of the way the European discovery of NZ is downgraded now by the state and put on a par with the Maori discovery centuries before; it is all part of a state orchestrated campaign to vilify and disparage European culture in this country. 

 There is no comparison between the two, the sophistication of the latter being far greater than the former. The doctoring of history continues by the Maori activists and their Pakeha partisans and the dispute last year about replacing the statue of James Cook on Mt Titirangi at Gisborne was another example of it. Barney Tupara, a representative of Ngati Oenone says that the first meeting between Maori and Pakeha was violent and 9 Maoris were killed. This is another example of the rewriting of history that Maoris are engaged in where their own role is sanitised and that of the European is vilified. 

Saturday, November 28, 2020

Bruce Moon: Rotorua Boys’ High School in the news


In recent days, for three reasons, Rotorua Boys’ High School has been in the news.

1.  It has been awarded “Apple Distinguished School” status.

2.  In a “first” it has appointed a woman of Maori descent as Deputy Principal.

3.  It has disposed of the portraits of four distinguished Englishmen because, as research by the boys is said to have found out, they had links with slavery.

Let us take these events one-by-one.

Saturday, October 24, 2020

Bruce Moon: The Tall Tales of Ngatiapa


And now we have Ngatiapa, a Nelson area tribe which, according to its cultural advisor, Kiely Nepia,[i] was "almost wiped off the face of the earth", “marginalised to a degree, ... largely without language, ... landless” and “had suffered from colonisation”.

Well now that certainly seems a sad state to be in but if indeed it “had suffered from colonisation”, why is it that, judging from the white faces of many of its members, it is largely a product of that colonization?  And with a fat “Treaty Settlement” for its 846 members in 2014 of $28.374 million from its own white relatives and others, together with a substantial amount of “cultural redress”,[ii]  it would appear to have done rather well at the expense of the New Zealand taxpayer.

Tuesday, October 1, 2019

Bruce Moon: Death Ship Comment and Response


Stuff article: Waikato academic calls Endeavour a “death ship”

A Waikato University academic has labelled Captain James Cook's HMB Endeavour a "death ship".

Dr Arama Rata, a senior research fellow, said the arrival of the replica Endeavour represents a re-enactment of the invasion of Māori land.