The Parliamentary Commissioner for the Environment’s advice on the repeal of the RMA and its replacement legislation has been largely ignored by the select committee hearing submissions. And rightly so.
As the incoming National Minister for the Environment in 1990, Simon Upton inherited the foundational Resource Management Bill left behind by Geoffrey Palmer’s outgoing Labour government. Upton took charge of steering the legislation through Parliament. Upton had the opportunity to kill it then. He embraced it instead. While one can assume Upton had the best of intentions, his naivety seeded the legislation’s inherent flaw that inevitably led to its demise. Quite simply, the “enabling” legislation gave radical vested-interest groups a liberty that enabled them to seize control of the process to the detriment of the community as a whole.














