Pages

Wednesday, July 31, 2024

Tony Orman: How About an Outward Bound Based Youth Training Scheme?

Kids are in trouble. Just look at the news from commonplace ram raids and other crimes even at times involving youngsters in murders. It doesn’t end there. The jumbled minds of too many of todays kids sadly manifests itself in youngsters taking their own lives. In a word - suicide!

A UNICEF report found New Zealand's youth suicide rate - teenagers between 15 and 19 - to be the highest of a long list of countries. New Zealand’s adolescents are in deep trouble and at times of a tragic kind. 

            

For example New Zealand ranks poorly in terms of adolescent suicide and teenage pregnancies, according to authorities.

            

New Zealand has lost its way and particularly with its younger people. 

            

Because of a mixture of boredom, bewilderment and a feeling of helplessness, youngsters can lash out. Their confidence for the future is often uncertain and self-esteem frequently low.

            

Young people have energies to burn which if not channelled down the right path, have the potential to go awry. Outdoors pursuits like fishing and hunting are healthy outlets for that adolescent energy. Stalking and shooting a rabbit or catching a kahawai, snapper or trout is an achievement and those successes build confidence, self-belief and self esteem to make them better people and better future citizens. Society wins. 

            

Under good tuition, a youngster learns qualities like patience, observation and an appreciation in just being outdoors and a respect for the fish or game that is pursued. A youngster can be taught to fish or hunt wisely, never taking more than is needed and not killing wantonly. And can be taught a firearm is to be respected and handled safely.

            

New Zealand has urbanised rapidly. A youngster growing up in the city may never see the countryside, a trout stream, the mountains or even a farm. 

            

One of the conundrums of modern society is that our economic standard measured by Gross Domestic Product is based on material trends like television and washing machine sales. We are mostly better housed, better fed and better entertained, but given the social media, films and television, too often today “entertained” by poor values. Think in terms of ludicrous reality tv programmes (e.g. Married at First Sight”), violence (professional wrestling and others). The internet enables kids to clock into some sick, depraved stuff.

            

For youngsters when I was a teenager, there was no internet or television. It was  get outside play tennis, kick a rugby ball around or go fishing or hunting. The outdoors used to be a readily available indispensable class-room.  The sweet success of catching a trout or perhaps a kahawai, shooting a rabbit, climbing a mountain or canoeing a river were personal achievements which importantly built self-esteem in youngsters. 

            

Besides tramping, fishing and hunting encourage observation, analytical reasoning and a respect for Nature. And often a lesson such as to achieve in the outdoors and life, you have to sweat and persevere to reach a goal.

            

In New Zealand’s egalitarian society, anyone can fish or hunt. It was a legacy the first European settlers instilled into the new colony in order to escape the feudal system of Britain where for example, the best trout fishing, deerstalking or pheasant shooting is the preserve of the wealthy minority who can pay the exorbitant access fees. New Zealand’s European pioneers set in place laws that prohibit the charging of access fees to fish or hunt. It’s a reflection of the egalitarian principles the pioneers instilled. Equal opportunity for all regardless of wealth, “class” or ethnic origins.

            

In effect, in New Zealand the kid down the street may go trout fishing on equal terms and rights as the city’s top solicitor, doctor, baker and the candlestick maker or even the Governor General  or Prime Minister. A Horizon survey of sporting participation rates a few years back, showed fishing had more than five times more people participating than rugby. Twenty-six percent enjoyed fishing while just five percent played rugby.

            

When it came to “getting off the couch”, 25.5 percent of adult men and 18 percent of women fished while with youth, about 35 percent went fishing.

            

Yet government, society and media gave far more attention to rugby than outdoor recreation such as fishing and hunting. 

            

Again I am not alone in my concern. 

            

The recent reports that New Zealand adolescents ranked very high in OECD countries’ teenage suicide and pregnancies rates, prompted New Zealand’s Neuroscience educator Nathan Wallis to express deep concern.

           

"We've got this idea that New Zealand is this wonderful, clean, green, beautiful nation that is a wonderful place to raise children, so but statistics paint a different picture,” he said.

            

There was a very good model for youth education in Outward Bound in the Marlborough Sounds. Years ago there was compulsory military training (CMT) which worked wonders for 18 year old teenagers. 

            

I know I was a CMT entrant. 

            

But CMT was strangely abolished, inexplicably I understand by the 1970s Labour government led by the charismatic Norman Kirk. The strange aspect was heightened by Kirk’s love of the outdoors and going fishing or as a teenager, hunting.

             

The coalition government is endeavouring to put young offenders through a pilot training scheme. Unfortunately the spiteful mainstream media, smouldering over the loss of taxpayers’ money with the change of government, aim to denigrate and corrupt the concept by using the term “boot camps.”

            

It’s utterly irresponsible in the light of teenage crime and especially teenage suicide statistics, for the media to do so.

            

The government steers away from the term “boot camps”, but faces an uphill battle with the malicious media perverting the public image of the scheme.

            

Forget the military aspect but a Youth Training Programme for teenagers like CMT and focused on the outdoors and developing skills, would be a great investment for tomorrow’s society. Outward Bound should be the model.

 

Tony Orman has spent decades in the outdoors from as a youngster to today, mainly fishing and hunting. He is the author of several books on sport fishing and hunting.

13 comments:

Postman Pat said...

If DoC had any nous they should operate an "outward bound" scheme, but they couldn't manage their way out of a wet paper bag.

Anonymous said...

How many of us who spend our time following our outdoor pursuits take one of these problem kids with them on one of their fishing, hunting, tramping trips ect. Also would our declining rivers handle a few thousand more kids catching the few fish that are left.

Roger Dewhurst said...

Good commonsense. That is why the politicians cannot understand

Anonymous said...

I'm not a fan of teaching most of those youths how to shoot accurately.

Anonymous said...

Tony, that is a very good article. I totally agree with you on the maliciousness of some media. Bill Floyd.

Anonymous said...

Start educating the parents, then the kids might stand a chance.
Peter
Turangi

Robert Arthur said...

The demise of ethics much of the problem. The access limitations and gun laws and paucity of harvest have ruined hunting and fishing. There are too many trampers now. We do not want myriads of low life preying on trampers and their gear. Sport is no longer played for the game but with supremacy the goal. Manufactured goods are so cheap hobbies like building radios, fixing bikes are pointless. The more able can be captured but simpler souls see it all as pointless compared with the excitement available on line, on phone, and/or by anti social behaviour.

CXH said...

Sounds much like an angry old man shouting at the clouds. I missed CMT, fortunately, my older brother was in the raffle. Would it have been good for him, no way. Was it good for some, absolutely, but far from all.

To think that it can all be solved with a bit of outdoor hunting and fishing is shallow at best. The problem kids come from the problem parts of our society, until we try and fix this we are just pretending.

Anonymous said...

Great Idea this is , help fund it with a special LOTTO Draw ? Put a decent Bounty on STOATS ! & Teach our Youth how to Trap them properly , plus how to survive in the N.Z. Bush. Regards from Graham Elwell , Kaituna , Marlborough .

Casey Cravens said...

Thanks, Tony, for such a thoughtful and articulate discussion of how outdoor life offers so much today's generation needs. When I was a kid we spent most of our time outdoors playing sports, riding bikes, tramping, swimming, fishing or floating rivers. If you had pressures from home or school the outdoors is a good place to lose yourself from them. Too many Gen Zers look at small screens more than the wider world. Our youth suicide rate is the highest of the top 41 OECD and EU countries, according to Unicef: 15.6 suicides per 100,000. New Zealand's rate is twice as high as the US rate and almost five times that of Britain. The government might think of more enlightened policy encouraging the outdoor lifestyle and environment as a way to lower physical and mental healthcare costs, as well as long-term social costs.

Chaz Forsyth said...

Paraphrasing John Masters, 'No bad kids, just bad parents', and Tony's suggestion has the ring of truth about it, reflecting his life experiences.

Robert Arthur said...

in view of the reponses above perhaps maori and the Auckland Council (same thing) will unlock the vast public owned Waitakere Regional Park and allow again the grand outdoor activities indulged in by scouts and other youth over decades.

Gaynor said...

As i repeat ad nauseam on blogs statistics show two thirds of those students who do not reach proficiency in reading will end up in jail or welfare.They also have a much higher rate of psychological disorders according to DR Kerry Hempenstall of RMIT.

Don't get me wrong all children should be exposed to out door activities rather than glued for hours to screens. However first and foremost from my perspective the most vulnerable need to be achieving in the basics of the three Rs. NZ last century used to excel at doing this well but now by international standards we are rock bottom, having the longest tail of underachievement in the developed world . Those in the tail have little hope for a bright future. Sitting in class day in day out, year in year out feeling stupid and useless because they are failing to learn the basics is their lot.This is wholesale child abuse in our schools.

There needs to be an educational revolution that cancels the iniquitous methods and ideologies dominant in schools and replace them with what we had traditionally. Science supports old school methods that work.