'Culture eats strategy for breakfast,' so the saying goes. In our new report, No Minister, we map the culture of New Zealand's public service – the shared beliefs and norms of officials.
We surveyed 718 public servants through Curia Market Research. We sorted surveyed officials by how they viewed ministers and democracy.
Under the 'Westminster bargain', officials keep their jobs when the government changes. In return, they wholeheartedly and enthusiastically support successive governments, whatever their political persuasion.
Eighty-three percent of surveyed officials who trusted ministers' judgement agreed that officials should put in their best effort to implement a lawful policy they think is misguided. Of those who distrusted ministers but still accepted that they have a democratic mandate to make decisions, 53 percent agreed.
Among those who distrusted ministers' judgement and rejected ministers' democratic mandate, only 25 percent agreed to put in effort. These results call into question whether the public service is politically neutral.
We asked what officials should do when they are convinced a minister is wrong. Majorities backed both open and covert interventions, including sackable offences such as leaking to the media to sabotage a minister's policy.
It is a truism that leaders model culture. So, what are public service leaders modelling?
First, the willingness of surveyed managers and leaders to put effort into a policy with which they disagree is associated with how they vote. Eighty-four percent of right-voting leaders agreed they should put in effort, even if they disagree, against just 58 percent of their left-voting colleagues. However, this result could reverse under a centre-left government.
Second, a larger share of surveyed managers and leaders than advisers believed that sticking to procedures is more important than delivering results in a timely manner. Finally, 63 percent of managers and leaders endorsed leaking to the media, against 36 percent of advisers.
So again, what is the public service leadership modelling for its employees? Effort should depend on political alignment with the government of the day. Loyalty to the department should trump the spirit of service. Feel free to do the bare minimum, or even work against ministers, when you disagree. And if all else fails, leak to the media.
If we accept that culture plays a role in performance, then the incoming government should begin with a careful look at managers and the public service leadership.
Eighty-three percent of surveyed officials who trusted ministers' judgement agreed that officials should put in their best effort to implement a lawful policy they think is misguided. Of those who distrusted ministers but still accepted that they have a democratic mandate to make decisions, 53 percent agreed.
Among those who distrusted ministers' judgement and rejected ministers' democratic mandate, only 25 percent agreed to put in effort. These results call into question whether the public service is politically neutral.
We asked what officials should do when they are convinced a minister is wrong. Majorities backed both open and covert interventions, including sackable offences such as leaking to the media to sabotage a minister's policy.
It is a truism that leaders model culture. So, what are public service leaders modelling?
First, the willingness of surveyed managers and leaders to put effort into a policy with which they disagree is associated with how they vote. Eighty-four percent of right-voting leaders agreed they should put in effort, even if they disagree, against just 58 percent of their left-voting colleagues. However, this result could reverse under a centre-left government.
Second, a larger share of surveyed managers and leaders than advisers believed that sticking to procedures is more important than delivering results in a timely manner. Finally, 63 percent of managers and leaders endorsed leaking to the media, against 36 percent of advisers.
So again, what is the public service leadership modelling for its employees? Effort should depend on political alignment with the government of the day. Loyalty to the department should trump the spirit of service. Feel free to do the bare minimum, or even work against ministers, when you disagree. And if all else fails, leak to the media.
If we accept that culture plays a role in performance, then the incoming government should begin with a careful look at managers and the public service leadership.
To learn more about 'No Minister', read the full research report and our latest NZ Herald column, watch the webinar and our explainer video or listen to our podcast.
Benno is a Research Fellow at The New Zealand Initiative with a wide range of policy interests. This article was first published HERE

No comments:
Post a Comment
Thank you for joining the discussion. Breaking Views welcomes respectful contributions that enrich the debate. Please ensure your comments are not defamatory, derogatory or disruptive. We appreciate your cooperation.