Pages

Monday, November 23, 2026

Net Zero Samizdat: Grid operator needs £1bn Treasury lifeline as wind costs soar



Britain's grid operator has secured an extra £1bn in Treasury borrowing as the cost of balancing electricity supplies soars. Meanwhile, Labour is divided over Rosebank, North Sea investment is heading overseas and motorists face higher EV charging costs. How much more will Britain's pursuit of Net Zero cost?

Treasury steps in as electricity balancing costs hit £2bn

Britain's electricity grid operator has secured an additional £1bn in Treasury borrowing to meet rapidly rising costs of balancing electricity supply and demand.

According to The Telegraph, balancing costs have already reached £2bn this year, compared with £1.5bn in 2025, with £740m incurred in October alone. Wind farms are being paid to switch off when the network cannot carry their electricity, while gas-fired power stations elsewhere are paid to increase generation.

The National Energy System Operator's borrowing facility has consequently risen from £700m to £1.7bn.

Why it matters: John Constable of the Renewable Energy Foundation argues that successive governments have connected wind farms faster than the grid can accommodate them. With balancing costs rising faster than they can be recovered through electricity bills, the Treasury is now providing additional financial support. The episode raises questions about the full cost of Britain's transition to renewable electricity. Read more

UK

Energy Secretary accused of encouraging Labour's Rosebank rebels

Energy Secretary Miatta Fahnbulleh has been accused of encouraging Labour MPs campaigning against approval of the Rosebank oil field. Around 75 Labour MPs have urged Prime Minister Andy Burnham to block the development, which could account for 10 per cent of Britain's oil production. Fahnbulleh, who will ultimately decide whether to approve the project, is reported to have supported the rebels. The dispute highlights continuing divisions within Labour over North Sea production and the future of Britain's domestic oil industry. Read more

EnQuest turns to Asia as SSE warns of gas storage closure

Two British energy companies have signalled plans to withdraw investment from major domestic fossil fuel operations. EnQuest is shifting its focus from the North Sea towards Asia, citing the UK's uncertain investment environment and better prospective returns overseas. Meanwhile, SSE has warned that it could close one of Britain's largest gas storage facilities in Yorkshire unless ministers intervene to support its operation. The developments raise further questions about investment conditions and the resilience of Britain's domestic energy infrastructure. Read more

Public EV charging costs could surge next year

Electric vehicle owners face potentially sharp increases in public charging costs as operators contend with rising electricity network standing charges. A major UK charging provider has warned that the additional costs of connecting charging infrastructure to the grid could be passed on to motorists. Experts estimate that drivers using public rapid chargers for some popular electric vehicles could end up paying around a third more per mile than drivers of equivalent petrol cars. The warnings raise questions about the affordability of electric motoring for households without home charging. Read more

International

Britain's Net Zero transition increasingly dependent on China

A new Policy Exchange report warns that Britain's energy transition is creating significant dependencies on Chinese technology and supply chains. According to the think tank, China accounts for 91 per cent of UK solar imports and 94 per cent of permanent magnets used in wind power, while producing around 70 per cent of the world's electric vehicle batteries. The report argues that reliance on a strategic competitor for essential energy technologies presents risks to Britain's economic and national security. Read more

Lomborg: Ghana's Net Zero target could cost £1.36 trillion

Economist Bjorn Lomborg argues that Ghana's pursuit of Net Zero by 2050 would impose enormous economic costs for minimal climate benefit. Writing for Graphic Online, he estimates cumulative costs of £1.36 trillion by 2100, against global climate benefits worth approximately £60bn and a projected temperature reduction of just 0.00554°C. Lomborg contends that developing countries would achieve greater benefits by prioritising economic growth, poverty reduction and practical adaptation to extreme weather. Read more

Tuscany rebels against giant wind turbines

Plans for ten wind turbines, each approximately 650 feet tall, in Tuscany's celebrated Crete Senesi region have provoked opposition from farmers, environmental campaigners and local politicians. Asciano's mayor, Fabrizio Nucci, warns that the development could permanently damage a landscape largely unchanged for centuries and questions whether local wind conditions justify the scheme. Opponents also fear consequences for agriculture, tourism and the rural economy. The dispute illustrates growing tensions between renewable energy development and landscape protection. Read more

Opinion and Analysis - Four arguments to read alongside this week’s news.

Kristian Niemietz: Net Zero will not make us richer

Writing in The Critic, Kristian Niemietz challenges claims that the transition to Net Zero will deliver greater prosperity. If renewable energy is so cheap, he asks, why has it required decades of government subsidies, and why have consumers not seen the benefits in their electricity bills? Niemietz argues that subsidised green industries do not create wealth automatically: resources directed towards them must first be taken from elsewhere in the economy. He warns against confusing government-supported activity with genuine economic growth. Read more

David Turver: Green taxes are driving up Britain's energy bills

A new Prosperity Institute report, Not Zero, argues that Britain's carbon pricing policies are increasing energy costs and damaging industrial competitiveness. Author David Turver estimates that carbon pricing has frequently added £20–£40/MWh to wholesale electricity prices. The report also highlights the disproportionate burden of energy taxes on transport and agriculture, alongside a near-halving of British industrial energy consumption since 2005. Turver warns that closer alignment with EU carbon pricing could impose further costs on British manufacturing. Read more

Ross Clark: Miliband promised £300 savings — bills have risen £600

Writing in the Daily Mail, Ross Clark challenges the Government's claims about the affordability of Net Zero. He contrasts Ed Miliband's promise that clean energy would reduce household bills by £300 a year with figures suggesting that bills have instead risen by £600. Clark argues that Britain's legally binding 2050 target was adopted without a clear understanding of its ultimate economic cost. He questions whether ministers can continue to promise cheaper energy while pursuing policies that, he argues, are contributing to higher bills. Read more

Tilak Doshi: Burnham cannot electrify everything and cut bills

Writing in The Daily Sceptic, energy economist Tilak Doshi highlights the tension between Andy Burnham's international climate commitments and Labour's promises to reduce household energy bills. Britain's electricity system operator forecasts wind constraint costs of £3.2bn in the year to July 2027, while government estimates suggest they could reach £10bn by 2030. With ministers reportedly considering a pause in future renewable energy auctions, Doshi argues that transferring Net Zero costs from electricity bills to general taxation does nothing to eliminate them. Read more

The London-based Net Zero Watch is a campaign group set up to highlight and discuss the serious implications of expensive and poorly considered climate change policies. The Net Zero Samizdat is a newsletter summarising the latest issues - for more information, please visit the website at www.netzerowatch.com.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Thank you for joining the discussion. Breaking Views welcomes respectful contributions that enrich the debate. Please ensure your comments are not defamatory, derogatory or disruptive. We appreciate your cooperation.