Pages

Wednesday, March 8, 2023

Heather du Plessis-Allan: The Nats are onto something by targeting the Government’s consultancy spending

I think the Nats are onto something by targeting the Government’s consultancy spend over the last year.

It is huge, $1.2 billion dollars on record. The year before, it was closer to $900m, so it went up by a third in one year. 

That should've set off alarm bells for anyone in The Beehive, but they just pushed on with it. Such is their attitude, I suspect, to using money.

A lot of this is just a complete waste on projects that have gone absolutely nowhere.

Like the RNZ/TVNZ merger- up to $16m on consultants. The bike bridge to Birkenhead- $51m on consultants. Light Rail- $53m on consultants.

So you and I have paid the mortgage of these consultants, but we have literally nothing to show for it.  No bridge. No merger. No light rail yet.  Just wasted money. 

It’s got so out of hand in Wellington that there are jokes about the fact that there are three branches of Government: the legislature, the judiciary, and Martin Jenkins.

Martin Jenkins isn't even one of the big ones. The big ones raking in consultancy fees are Deloitte, KPMG, Ernst and Young and PwC.

There are a couple of obvious reasons why this spend has got so out of hand under this Government. 

The first is Labour approached Government like a drunk trying to prepare a dinner party. No clear plan, no idea where to start, just trying to do everything at once and then botch it because you can’t handle it all.

So it ended up with consultants chasing every hare brained idea every junior minister had.

The second is the obsession with spinning the story. Rob Campbell reckons there are over 200 communications people in Health NZ and even then they have to call in PR consultancy firms to sell you the story even better. 

None of us are going to shed a tear if these consultancy firms lose contracts.

Because we cancel stupid ideas that should never be explored and because we cut back on the PR double speak.

It puts Labour in a difficult position. Either fall into line and promise to cut the spending too, or defend wasting taxpayer money.

Heather du Plessis-Allan is a journalist and commentator who hosts Newstalk ZB's Drive show.

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

We have been policy governed not by our elected officials but by consultants and public servants that have both a reason to make it continue and an agenda to drive.

The elected government had no policy on the day they were annointed power and have basically abdicated governance to working groups since then.

Anonymous said...

Yes, it is truly outrageous. One of the biggest costs would surely have been Three Waters. The complexities and spin attempting to put that rort for a small cohort of Maori together would have been massive. The shear audacity to press on with it, when there was no public mandate or justification (for the asset grab and governance structure) and huge public opposition to it, just proves how corrupt Labour are. They should feel more than uncomfortable - for there is no excuse and, for that, they should be gone.
.

Terry Morrissey said...

The reason for employing consultants is that is impossible to get anything from a vacuum. That is what this governing cult is, both labour and greens.