The Reserve Bank adjusts interest rates to keep inflation under control. This does not work with perfect precision, but it works. There is one measure, one lever and a well-understood relationship between the two.
Not every policy goal is like that. Education Minister Erica Stanford took office promising to reverse a decades-long decline in New Zealand school education, especially in literacy and mathematics.
Stanford was faced with many potential levers, including curriculum, teacher training and school regulation. She decided to use as many of those levers as she could. She has reformed the curriculum, provided professional development for teachers, mandated an hour per day of reading, writing and mathematics for primary students and more.
Last week, the New Zealand Council for Educational Research reported on data from its Progressive Achievement Tests (PATs). PATs are widely used in New Zealand's primary schools to measure reading and mathematics learning.
The report includes data gathered over 15 years, from 2012 to 2026, from more than 1,300 schools and nearly 650,000 Years 4-8 students. Between 2012 and 2018 the mathematics data didn't change.
Scores slipped slightly in 2019 and 2020 and then dipped further during the pandemic. By 2023, when Stanford took office, they had recovered to pre-covid levels. In 2025 there was a lift, and a bigger one in 2026. Now, PAT mathematics attainment sits about a third of an average year's learning higher than in 2024.
Is the lift attributable to Stanford's reforms or to something else?
The compulsory hour per day was implemented for the 2024 school year. The new mathematics curriculum was published in late 2024 and mandated from Term 1, 2025. Throughout, primary teachers were given professional development in teaching maths, which a 2021 report from the Royal Society Te Apārangi had shown to be a weakness.
Other factors may be in play too. On the back of the Royal Society report, the Ministry of Education implemented a new strategy in 2022.
The mathematics PAT was refreshed in 2024, so the later results are not completely comparable with earlier ones. But the big gains in 2025 and 2026 are both on the new version.
The evidence in favour of Stanford's reforms is as good as it gets this soon after implementation. The timing fits, even if other potential causes can't be cleanly separated in the data.
Whoever is education minister after November's election should stay the course.
Dr Michael Johnston is a Senior Fellow at the New Zealand Initiative. This article was first published HERE
Last week, the New Zealand Council for Educational Research reported on data from its Progressive Achievement Tests (PATs). PATs are widely used in New Zealand's primary schools to measure reading and mathematics learning.
The report includes data gathered over 15 years, from 2012 to 2026, from more than 1,300 schools and nearly 650,000 Years 4-8 students. Between 2012 and 2018 the mathematics data didn't change.
Scores slipped slightly in 2019 and 2020 and then dipped further during the pandemic. By 2023, when Stanford took office, they had recovered to pre-covid levels. In 2025 there was a lift, and a bigger one in 2026. Now, PAT mathematics attainment sits about a third of an average year's learning higher than in 2024.
Is the lift attributable to Stanford's reforms or to something else?
The compulsory hour per day was implemented for the 2024 school year. The new mathematics curriculum was published in late 2024 and mandated from Term 1, 2025. Throughout, primary teachers were given professional development in teaching maths, which a 2021 report from the Royal Society Te Apārangi had shown to be a weakness.
Other factors may be in play too. On the back of the Royal Society report, the Ministry of Education implemented a new strategy in 2022.
The mathematics PAT was refreshed in 2024, so the later results are not completely comparable with earlier ones. But the big gains in 2025 and 2026 are both on the new version.
The evidence in favour of Stanford's reforms is as good as it gets this soon after implementation. The timing fits, even if other potential causes can't be cleanly separated in the data.
Whoever is education minister after November's election should stay the course.
Dr Michael Johnston is a Senior Fellow at the New Zealand Initiative. This article was first published HERE

1 comment:
Having been a reading and maths tutor for more than 40 years, I was in total despair with what was happening in the maths teaching in schools . I couldn't believe anyone could produce such madness.
The group discovery work was unbelievably bad
.Groups of students were given a word problem and the bully in the group asserted themselves , ridiculing all those who had different ideas from his /her.
For example the problem was about finding the area of a rectangle. The concluding group answer, that dominated in the group was the perimeter. Appallingly, this answer was not corrected by the teacher .
Doing no arithmetic at all would have been an improvement. But then doing no maths at all was something that happened in some classes , as well. The teacher ' didn't see the need for it". For two years, my student, in a composite class, reported she had no maths instruction at all .
Then there is the issue of whether the teacher actually knows the answer. On another occasion a child was told by a teacher that the answer to 15/2 was 7.1. Clearly, a complete ignorance of decimals .
Standford has a real battle. Not only has the syllabus been shocking but a proportion of teachers are lacking in basic knowledge .
Even in a high decile area , year 8 maths was, simply not done in ANY of the primary schools. The content was beyond most primary teachers.
Teachers have for decades , been told, they are professionals , who can decide what is best for their students. Being directed to follow certain guidelines seems insulting and dictatorial.
My answer is to have workbooks also available for parents. In the 1980s Addison Maths workbooks were cheap newsprint homework books , that were on the school book list to buy These books had answers as well.
Not every child has parents who can help them, but a proportion do and very well structured workbooks require little guidance. In Singapore parents are given truthful answers about their child's achievement and directed to buy structured remedial workbooks if their child is failing . There is a return to writing rather than screens which is why I mention workbooks instead of screens.
. Teachers need monitoring as well and parents should be able to this.
I am frustrated by the ministry's lack of available home materials. Their guidelines and information for parents are vague and pathetic in primary maths and reading .
For example phonic readers don't get sent home nor lists of phonic words to spell. This is a major error. Children need to read a book repeatedly and have drill of phonic concepts. There is still no direction to teach rote learning of number facts and times tables. Gaynor.
Post a Comment
Thank you for joining the discussion. Breaking Views welcomes respectful contributions that enrich the debate. Please ensure your comments are not defamatory, derogatory or disruptive. We appreciate your cooperation.