It will outrage supporters of Te Pāti Māori and New Zealand First, but their parties are remarkably similar.
Both are grievance parties.
Both are led by politicians who specialise in outrage.
Both need someone to blame. New Zealand First targets migrants, particularly Indians. Te Pāti Māori blames non-Māori.
Both make extravagant promises.
New Zealand First promises to buy back the BNZ, establish a $100 billion infrastructure fund, increase defense spending to 3% of GDP and give every newborn citizen $1,000 in KiwiSaver.
Te Pāti Māori promises a $3.1 billion food programme, a billion-dollar energy fund, $100 million to establish Māori-owned supermarkets, 2,000 houses on Māori land and half of all new social housing for Māori.
Neither has presented a fiscal plan to show how its policies are even remotely possible.
Both specialise in attacking the establishment while seeking the power to become part of it.
New Zealand First’s reversals are spectacular.
Peters made Jacinda Ardern Prime Minister. He served in the government that introduced compulsory vaccination and now courts the anti-vaccine vote. He supported the ban on new offshore oil and gas exploration and now champions exploration. I
While today attacking Labour, Te Pāti Māori co-leader Rawiri Waititi was in 2014 Labour’s candidate for Waiariki.
What attracts their supporters is not a coherent programme of government but the politics of grievance: the conviction that someone else is responsible for their misfortunes.
But the most remarkable similarity is that both parties are doing more electoral damage to their coalition partners than to themselves.
Winston Peters’ racist attack on a Chinese-born MP appears to have cost him little support. But it damaged Christopher Luxon.
Te Pāti Māori’s courting the gangs may not have cost the party votes. It may have cost Chris Hipkins any chance of becoming Prime Minister.
The Honourable Richard Prebble CBE is a former member of the New Zealand Parliament. Initially a member of the Labour Party, he joined the newly formed ACT New Zealand party under Roger Douglas in 1996, becoming its leader from 1996 to 2004. This article was sourced HERE
Both make extravagant promises.
New Zealand First promises to buy back the BNZ, establish a $100 billion infrastructure fund, increase defense spending to 3% of GDP and give every newborn citizen $1,000 in KiwiSaver.
Te Pāti Māori promises a $3.1 billion food programme, a billion-dollar energy fund, $100 million to establish Māori-owned supermarkets, 2,000 houses on Māori land and half of all new social housing for Māori.
Neither has presented a fiscal plan to show how its policies are even remotely possible.
Both specialise in attacking the establishment while seeking the power to become part of it.
New Zealand First’s reversals are spectacular.
Peters made Jacinda Ardern Prime Minister. He served in the government that introduced compulsory vaccination and now courts the anti-vaccine vote. He supported the ban on new offshore oil and gas exploration and now champions exploration. I
While today attacking Labour, Te Pāti Māori co-leader Rawiri Waititi was in 2014 Labour’s candidate for Waiariki.
What attracts their supporters is not a coherent programme of government but the politics of grievance: the conviction that someone else is responsible for their misfortunes.
But the most remarkable similarity is that both parties are doing more electoral damage to their coalition partners than to themselves.
Winston Peters’ racist attack on a Chinese-born MP appears to have cost him little support. But it damaged Christopher Luxon.
Te Pāti Māori’s courting the gangs may not have cost the party votes. It may have cost Chris Hipkins any chance of becoming Prime Minister.
The Honourable Richard Prebble CBE is a former member of the New Zealand Parliament. Initially a member of the Labour Party, he joined the newly formed ACT New Zealand party under Roger Douglas in 1996, becoming its leader from 1996 to 2004. This article was sourced HERE

3 comments:
Mr Prebble , there is no argument about your historical perspective , however your contribution errs in current relevance .
NZ must place economy and debt control among the first and most important Governmental virtues .
Public spending and its accomplice, public debt are the greatest of the dangers to be feared.
NZ voters must split their vote and only tick ACT or NZF to accompany Electorate Vote Blue .
“Both need someone to blame. New Zealand First targets migrants, particularly Indians.”
I’m in IT and found it increasingly difficult to obtain roles because the market was flooded by… Indians. That’s despite upping my skills over the years. Am I not entitled to feel aggrieved that my livelihood and home are at risk because of unfettered immigration?
“He served in the government that introduced compulsory vaccination and now courts the anti-vaccine vote.”
How thoroughly dishonest. NZF were out of government between 2020 and 2023. You hold NZF responsible for the stupidity of countless voters who were spellbound by Ardern in 2020? Wow.
Nor does he “court the anti-vaccine vote.” Everyone I know who votes NZF does so because our outlooks align with NZF’s direction of travel. I thought that was how things worked in the world of politics? Maybe I’ve been doing voting wrong and should vote Green because I like women with moustaches? Who knew.
“Winston Peters’ racist attack on a Chinese-born MP appears to have cost him little support.”
Exactly what was racist about it? Winston would have made the same comment to Genter or any other ungrateful immigrant attempting to white-ant New Zealand. Crying racist doesn’t work any more - get used to it.
You’ve written a piece befitting the likes of Stuff. Congratulations.
It is telling that you have left out the most obvious similarity: Both are led by Maoris.
Similarly, NZF had a full front-page ad in The Post yesterday which included around half dozen election issues, none of which were go-governance.
Today The Post had a piece on election issues which did not mention Maoris or co-governance.
It seems there are just words we do not now use.
Post a Comment
Thank you for joining the discussion. Breaking Views welcomes respectful contributions that enrich the debate. Please ensure your comments are not defamatory, derogatory or disruptive. We appreciate your cooperation.