An Epsom National supporter asked whether he should vote for Paul Goldsmith.
Why would he?
National’s problem is not winning too few electorates. It is that it will win too many.
Under MMP, electing another National electorate MP does not increase National’s representation. It means one fewer National list MP.
Epsom has a distinguished parliamentary history of electing independently minded MPs.
Sir Ronald Algie, Auckland University’s first professor of law, represented the electorate, then called Remuera, for 23 years.
Before entering Parliament, he resigned his professorship to lead the Freedom Association, which opposed increasing state control.
He became one of New Zealand’s finest parliamentarians.
What would Sir Ronald make of Paul Goldsmith’s police state proposal to remove the right to silence in certain criminal cases, with up to ten years’ imprisonment for refusing to provide information to police?
National’s willingness to compromise fundamental principles is why James Christmas is standing for ACT in Tāmaki.
Like Sir Ronald Algie, Christmas is distinguished in public law. He advised both John Key and Bill English.
He was once regarded as National’s future Attorney-General.
National has instead selected as its candidate a former “Head of People Operations”.
What Parliament needs is a first-class constitutional lawyer.
The answer to that Epsom voter’s question is that he should vote for David Seymour.
In Tāmaki, the issue is protecting the rights that make us New Zealanders by electing James Christmas.
It is not always the smartest political party that wins elections.
Often, it’s the smartest voters.
The Honourable Richard Prebble CBE is a former member of the New Zealand Parliament. Initially a member of the Labour Party, he joined the newly formed ACT New Zealand party under Roger Douglas in 1996, becoming its leader from 1996 to 2004. This article was sourced HERE
Epsom has a distinguished parliamentary history of electing independently minded MPs.
Sir Ronald Algie, Auckland University’s first professor of law, represented the electorate, then called Remuera, for 23 years.
Before entering Parliament, he resigned his professorship to lead the Freedom Association, which opposed increasing state control.
He became one of New Zealand’s finest parliamentarians.
What would Sir Ronald make of Paul Goldsmith’s police state proposal to remove the right to silence in certain criminal cases, with up to ten years’ imprisonment for refusing to provide information to police?
National’s willingness to compromise fundamental principles is why James Christmas is standing for ACT in Tāmaki.
Like Sir Ronald Algie, Christmas is distinguished in public law. He advised both John Key and Bill English.
He was once regarded as National’s future Attorney-General.
National has instead selected as its candidate a former “Head of People Operations”.
What Parliament needs is a first-class constitutional lawyer.
The answer to that Epsom voter’s question is that he should vote for David Seymour.
In Tāmaki, the issue is protecting the rights that make us New Zealanders by electing James Christmas.
It is not always the smartest political party that wins elections.
Often, it’s the smartest voters.
The Honourable Richard Prebble CBE is a former member of the New Zealand Parliament. Initially a member of the Labour Party, he joined the newly formed ACT New Zealand party under Roger Douglas in 1996, becoming its leader from 1996 to 2004. This article was sourced HERE

5 comments:
I think voting "party vote" ACT a better option.
James Christmas co-authored He Kupu Taurangi: Treaty Settlements and the future of Aotearoa New Zealand with Chris Finlayson.
He also seems to believe inanimate objects are people.
Maybe Davina Smolders would have been a more popular choice for the seat? Why is she so far down the ACT list?
If Tamaki goes to National as opposed to ACT, that means one more seat to the right coalition, and ACT still has the same number of MPs. I fail to see why Richard Prebble cannot understand this.
Prebble is factually wrong. This is not true = "Under MMP, electing another National electorate MP does not increase National’s representation. It means one fewer National list MP". Given National's low party vote support meaning a large overhang, Goldsmith winning Epsom will add another seat to the right block = Seymour would come back also under ACTs party vote regardless of winning Epsom. I was told today Don Brash did a dirty and unreported and probably breaking electoral rules backroom deal with ACT yesterday with a public ad telling people to party vote ACT = but ACT only agreed to the ad on condition Brash also publicly supported Seymour for the electorate vote. I call on Seymour and Brash to come clean on this misleading voter manipulation in public ads with no declaration of the dirty deal. Now Prebble tells porkers as well. What a pigs breakfast.
Gosh, I thought Richard was smarter than this, or is he just fudging the issue to support ACT? He must be aware of the overhang? Electing a National MP in the Epsom and Tamaki electorates WILL increase the number of MPs for the right bloc. Electing ACT MPs does not. Richard, you can do a lot better than this.
By the way, ACT broke electoral law since it dictated Brash's NZ Herald ad brought out in his name = ACT told Brash they would only allow the advert advising people to party vote ACT provided the ad also advised people to electorate vote ACT in Epsom and Orakei. So ACT jointly wrote the ad with Brash = but the law says Electorate candidates cannot spend mote than $36,000 on such ads. ACT put out an ad in another person's name and funding which ACT wrote but did not disclose. Thats not legal.
Post a Comment
Thank you for joining the discussion. Breaking Views welcomes respectful contributions that enrich the debate. Please ensure your comments are not defamatory, derogatory or disruptive. We appreciate your cooperation.