Pages

Wednesday, October 28, 2026

Bob Edlin: Maori trust’s beach barrier was blessed with a karakia....


......but it didn’t have the blessing of the local council – or the law

Uh, oh. Tensions between beach-going motorists and beach-protecting vigilantes were reflected in a report headed Kāwhia landowners face threats to burn down marae over beach closure.

The report explained that significant numbers of landowners supported the blocking of vehicle access to the Kāwhia Hot Water Beach beach to protect Te Arai ō Wiwini, a breeding ground and nursery for pātiki and other fish.

Because the report was intended for a Te Au Maori audience, the reporter apparently felt no need to explain that pātiki are flounders and flatfish.

Nor – more pertinently – did the reporter delve into the legality of the Onepū Charitable Trust’s intention to install a wooden pole barrier on Saturday as visitors arrived in Kāwhia for Labour Weekend.

It was illegal – but popular among the locals.

Daisy Horahaere Scott, of Ngāti Hikairo and Ngāti Mahuta, says more than 600 landowners support the closure.

But this looked likely to rankle at least some of those who would be barred from driving on to the beach and invite the prospect of retaliation.

Sure enough:

She says those backing it have faced threats, most recently a threat to burn down Maketū Marae.

“To threaten the destruction of our marae is very concerning,” Scott says.

“We had a hui with the landowners and those concerned or connected with the blockage. Everyone was adamant that we will continue and not take these threats.”


The concerns of the locals are understandable.

Scott says vehicles have driven over pipi beds, become stuck in the sand, and been caught by the incoming tide. Some – she says – have been left in the water for two or three days.

“Our pipi beds have been destroyed, the pātiki have decreased in number. It’s just been treated with disrespect,” she says.

She adds that regular vehicle use is disturbing kaimoana and damaging the dunes that protect the harbour. However, the beach will remain open to walkers and horse riders.


And:

“We’re wanting to save our land and also Te Arai ō Wiwini,” she says. “It’s the few that are doing this damage, but we’ve got to make a stand.”

Exacerbating the trust’s frustrations, it has established the block after years of petitioning the Ōtorohanga District Council and forestry operators to provide an alternative access point that won’t have the same destructive effects.

The blockade does not block foot traffic. The beach remains accessible to pedestrians and non-motorised wheeled devices.

But to what extent (the PoO team wonders) does the damaging and depletion of fish stocks – which rile Maori around the country – result from official disinclination to crack down on breaches of fishing regulations.

That question is raised by a OneNews report, headed Man allegedly found with nearly 15 times daily legal limit of pāua

OneNews reported that a man is facing prosecution after being caught nearly 15 times the daily legal limit of pāua in South Taranaki earlier this month.

During a fisheries inspection, the man was allegedly found with 73 pāua – 20 of which were undersized.

The daily limit in the area is five pāua per person and they must be at least 85mm.

The matter was referred to the Ministry for Primary Industries’ Fisheries Compliance team, who were looking at prosecution.


“Looking at prosecution” suggests the ministry is thinking about it.

Maybe the offender will get away with a warning.

OneNews went on to say:

Fifteen people were caught last weekend flouting recreational fishing rules in Auckland – more than half of them for undersized snapper.

North Harbour Fishery officers and Auckland Police Maritime officers carried out 514 inspections across the city’s east and west coasts.

Nine fishers were found with undersized snapper in the East Coast area. On the West Coast, one fisher had too many oysters and three others were in possession of undersized scallops.

Fisheries NZ was considering prosecution after two illegal set nets were found joined together at Mill Bay in West Auckland.

Infringement notices were issued to two people who took undersized snapper, while the remaining fishers received formal warning notices.


An infringement notice means an offender is fined, akin to a speeding or parking ticket.

The offender gets no criminal record but will pay a fine a set infringement fee—typically ranging from $200 to $500 for recreational breaches, or up to higher amounts for commercial or specific regulatory infractions.

Any illegal fish or equipment used in the breach (such as diving gear or nets) can still be seized.

The OneNews report said a warning was issued to a fisher whose unmarked set net was found at Titirangi.

No matter the rigour of the enforcement, the ministry’s Fisheries Compliance team does have legal authority to penalise offenders.

The Onepū Charitable Trust has no formal local government or statutory legal authority to close public vehicle access to the beach, thereby creating a legal conflict with the local council as well as with beach-goers who bridle at the barrier erected to block them.

Moreover, it seems the Ōtorohanga District Council has explicitly stated that placing physical barriers below the high-tide line constitutes a breach of its Traffic Management Bylaw.

But the trust no doubt put money on the council being a bit like the fisheries officers: it might receive no more than a warning.

Sure enough, the council authorities did not stop the trust from closing vehicular access to the beach.

It warned that the physical barriers breach its Traffic Management Bylaw – and that’s it.

The closure went ahead as planned following a traditional karakia – you can’t do much these days without one of them – and kept Kāwhia Hot Water Beach open only for pedestrians.

Bob Edlin is a veteran journalist and editor for the Point of Order blog HERE.

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

Meh, I’m no greenie Bob, and I’m continually outraged by bloody karakia being thrown around like we’ve all got a new national religion- as well as being rammed down our kids throats in schools every damn day, but in this situation the onepu trust have a pretty good point.

Vehicles on beaches in large numbers erode the beach, and destroy breeding grounds for all the animals that the locals and visitors might wish to eat. While their actions might be unlawful- as long as the barriers are temporary (which it sounds like they are), and they’re not actually stopping folks from accessing the beach, then it’s back to council and forestry whom they’ve petitioned for an alternative access. Or visit in the off peak season with your car. If it was my local beach I reckon I’d be all for their actions too. Fines or not. (But yes one law for me and another for thee!)
Plus we all know - don’t believe anything you see on comrade one.
They will only be telling us a small heavily biased part of what goes on - on a slow news day.

Anonymous said...

I go to Kāwhia beach several times each year and you may see the odd quad bike or 4X4. Why don’t the locals put up a polite sign about where people can drive /park to protect the “fish” breeding grounds. And where are the fisheries officers doing their job fining/ prosecuting the people who break the law?

Post a Comment

Thank you for joining the discussion. Breaking Views welcomes respectful contributions that enrich the debate. Please ensure your comments are not defamatory, derogatory or disruptive. We appreciate your cooperation.