Pages

Friday, October 30, 2026

Colinxy: A Rabbit, Four Police Officers, and the Future Labour Wants for New Zealand


When mockery becomes policing, and speech becomes a matter for the State.

Recently in the United Kingdom, a 15‑year‑old boy found himself at the receiving end of four police officers after making fun of a local councillor on social media. His crimes allegedly included criticising the councillor’s clothing, comparing his appearance to a “rent boy”, and posting an edited image giving the politician rabbit ears. The teenager was arrested, fingerprinted, photographed, had DNA taken, and had electronic devices seized. Reports indicate police considered offences including harassment, malicious communications, and a possible hate crime[i].

The councillor involved was not physically threatened. No violence occurred. No property was damaged.

A teenager mocked a politician. And the police showed up.

The Logic of Non‑Crime Policing

According to reports, West Midlands Police stated they investigate reports in line with College of Policing guidance[ii].

This is where Britain has been heading for years.

The UK increasingly operates under the principle that speech need not be criminal to warrant police attention. The category of the “non‑crime hate incident” has slowly normalised the idea that law enforcement should concern itself not merely with criminal acts, but with offensive expression, perceived hostility, and subjective harm.

This is yet another example of anarcho‑tyranny.

The theory is simple:
  • Violent criminals increasingly avoid meaningful consequences.
  • Disorder becomes normal.
  • Yet ordinary citizens face growing scrutiny for speech, jokes, online comments, and political opinions.
Law becomes simultaneously weak and oppressive. Weak where it should be strong. Strong where it should be weak. The teenager’s case is merely the latest example of this inversion.

A Rabbit Today, What Tomorrow?

The important issue isn’t whether the teenager was rude. He was.

The important issue is whether mockery of elected officials should trigger police intervention.

In a functioning liberal society, politicians are expected to tolerate criticism, ridicule, satire, caricature, and even nastiness. That comes with the job.

If politicians can mobilise the machinery of the State against citizens who embarrass them, the relationship between ruler and ruled begins to reverse.

The citizen starts fearing the politician instead of the politician fearing the voter. That is unhealthy in any democracy.

New Zealand Should Pay Attention

It would be comforting to dismiss this as a uniquely British pathology.

Unfortunately, New Zealand has already begun travelling down similar roads.

As I noted in my earlier article on UK‑style non‑crime hate policing, many of the same concepts have quietly entered New Zealand’s political conversation. Ideas that would have been considered authoritarian a decade ago are now discussed as common‑sense regulatory measures.

The Ardern‑Hipkins Government attempted to introduce hate‑speech laws. It failed.

The desire, however, never disappeared. It merely changed form.

Labour’s Digital Duty of Care

The Labour Party has recently proposed a Digital Duty of Care regime, promising action within its first 100 days should it return to office.

At face value, this sounds harmless. Who could oppose “safety” online? Who could oppose “responsibility”? Who could oppose a “duty of care”?

That is precisely how speech regulation is marketed. The concern is not the slogan. The concern is the mechanism.

Labour proposes a system involving a regulator or commissioner tasked with determining what online content is appropriate, what platforms should permit, and what risks require intervention. Public reporting indicates the policy would create significant new powers over online content moderation and platform obligations.

The obvious question follows: Who decides what constitutes harm?

And once that question is asked, another inevitably follows: What cannot eventually be classified as harm?

The Pattern Never Changes

Every speech‑control proposal follows the same trajectory.

First, it targets:
  • abuse,
  • extremism,
  • threats,
  • criminal behaviour.
Most people support that.

Then the definitions expand. “Harm” broadens. “Safety” broadens. “Hate” broadens. “Suspected misinformation” broadens.

Soon enough, the problem is no longer criminal conduct.

The problem is disapproved opinion.

Britain provides a useful preview of where this process leads. Not necessarily because New Zealand will become identical. But because institutional incentives remain remarkably similar.

The Bureaucratic Temptation

The real danger is not malicious intent. The danger is bureaucracy.

Once a speech regulator exists, it must justify its existence.

Its budget must grow. Its remit must expand. Its staff must find work to do.

A commissioner charged with policing online harm will inevitably discover more and more harm. Because if there is no harm, there is no reason for the commissioner’s office to exist.

This is how bureaucracies behave. It is what bureaucracies do.

Freedom Means Tolerating Mockery

Liberal societies are built upon a simple but uncomfortable principle:

People have the right to say things we dislike.

That includes:
  • bad jokes,
  • insults,
  • mockery,
  • rude comments,
  • offensive opinions,
  • political satire.
The moment police become involved merely because speech is unpleasant, the principle has already been lost.

The teenager in Britain may have been obnoxious. Teenagers often are. That is not the point.

The point is that mockery of a politician should not involve police cars, DNA collection, and device seizures.

Conclusion: The Warning From Britain

The arrest of a teenager over a mocked‑up rabbit photo would have sounded absurd twenty years ago. Today it is reality.

Britain is showing us where the logic of non‑crime speech policing eventually ends:
  • the citizen becomes suspect,
  • politicians become protected classes,
  • speech becomes regulated,
  • and police become arbiters of acceptable expression.
New Zealand should pay attention. Because every restriction on speech begins with the assurance that it will only ever be used against the worst people.

It never stays there. And the people writing the rules are always convinced they are the good guys.


Colinxy regularly blogs at No Minister, This article was sourced HERE

5 comments:

Anonymous said...

If the 1970s and 1980s comedy programs were made today, all those involved would be arrested. "A Week Of It" made fun of NZ politicians. In UK, I can't think of a comedy program that would be tolerated today. Even Faulty Towers would lead to arrests for making fun of Spaniards, Americans and health inspectors.

Barrie Davis said...

I don't quite agree with you. Depending on circumstances, it may have been useful if a single cop had turned up, interviewed the boy and mentioned that it was helpful to be polite and not hurt people's feelings unnecessarily. No need for the arrest and all the rest of it, but a simple chat could have turned the lad around and also possibly some rapport building with the cops.
Also, you did not mention the race of the councillor which may have been relevant.

Anonymous said...

Wit and humour no longer exist. Quite a boring world now..... just overtaken by violence of every kind.

Anonymous said...

When adding "rabbit ears" to an "image" of a politician and innocuous mocking and satire results in a "minor / youth" being arrested?!
The state and the law have become more than a complete ass.
It has become totalitarian.
Based on what we know that boy deserves all the support a true democratic society can provide.
And rather than being fingerprinted, the police and politician deserve a big fat "middle finger" for bullying a kid.

Don said...

Where has our sense of humour Gone? Everything is taken so seriously now. Once we could laugh off all sorts of things - Wotthehell
- which gave us a sense of the relative importance of satire, utterances and so on. Now an off the cuff remark on the spur of the moment can be given the sanctity of a policy statement and analysed to the nth degree when all it was, was a human response to a moment of confusion or even the remark engendered by someone who was thinking of something else and responded automatically in ignorance. Human failing gets
no toleration in these cut-throat and competitive times.

Post a Comment

Thank you for joining the discussion. Breaking Views welcomes respectful contributions that enrich the debate. Please ensure your comments are not defamatory, derogatory or disruptive. We appreciate your cooperation.