Pages

Tuesday, October 27, 2026

Damien Grant: I’d rather doom-scroll the Paris riots than spend an evening listening to a Luxon speech. But...


“From the very beginning, from the first moment, I may almost say, of my acquaintance with you, your manners, impressing me with the fullest belief of your arrogance, your conceit, and your selfish disdain of the feelings of others.”

Thus said Elizabeth Bennet to William Darcy, as she rejected his proposal. For younger readers, imagine Bridget Jones delivering a similar line to Colin Firth.

Decisions are hard, and New Zealand faces a choice as compelling and consequential for our nation as that which confronted Bridget Jones as she weighed the merits and limitations of her two suitors.

I get it. The lack of enthusiasm for the coalition. Christopher Luxon appears inauthentic. At times befuddled by the responsibility of his office and uninterested in the lives of his subjects. And for the critical question: are you better off today than you were three years ago?

Christopher Luxon leads the coalition Government into the election with 13 days remaining in the campaign. Photo: Hannah Warbuton/Stuff

On a per-capita basis, no. You are not. Many of us have slipped backwards and every time we visit the petrol station is a cause for anxiety, and our frustration at the price of groceries makes taking a mallet to the duopoly appealing.

But, if I may, let’s consider the merits of our Mr Darcy before we decide to jump back into bed with our past paramour.

Yes. The Prime Minister can be grating. I’d rather doom-scroll the Paris riots than spend an evening listening to a Luxon speech. But, New Zealand, we are not electing a drinking buddy. We are electing, or re-electing, a Prime Minister.

Let’s compare and contrast.

Under the last government the prison roll fell to under eight thousand. Law and order was, in some polls, the second most important issue facing the electorate. Today, no one cares. And no one cares because Mark Mitchell has done his job. The prison muster is over eleven thousand and rising. The bad guys are locked up and crime is down.

The columnist argues voters should judge Luxon’s Government on competence and outcomes rather than personality. Photo: Hannah Warbuton/Stuff

In health, Simeon Brown has not wasted his ministerial talents and, although the sector remains troubled, Brown has been effective. He has instructed the ministry to put ideological reservations aside and pay the private sector to sharpen their scalpels to cut into the waiting lists.

The problem is a single-payer model where there is no cost to the end user is flawed and will always suffer from excess demand and insufficient funding. The failure to confront this structural reality is frustrating, but New Zealanders are not ready to accept any alternative.

Erica Stanford claims credit for the successful implementation of structural literacy, although it is important to remember that it was under Hipkins’ tenure as education minister that trials for this approach were commenced, and he has committed to maintaining it.

However, Stanford implemented this change, along with a requirement for three hours a day of core learning on reading, writing and mathematics, a development the opposition leader will leave to individual schools rather than a mandate from the centre.

Education is improving under this government because, if you can forgive some subjectivity from this columnist, the minister is prioritising teaching students over pandering to the education unions.

Inflation, especially in domestically traded goods and services, is back under control as the finance minister has narrowed the Reserve Bank’s mandate. The ruinous multi-billion cost of the pending pay-equity claims was avoided thanks to the work of Minister Brooke van Velden, something the opposition has promised to reinstate.

The heroic efforts of Messrs Bishop and Court have resulted in a reworked land management framework that has the potential to unlock enormous wealth as construction projects are liberated from the molasses of the certification and objection regime.

And let us not forget the now overlooked but economically significant Indian trade deal.

This government is tackling serious issues. They have yet to address the fiscal deficit and the rising pension costs, but they acknowledge this is a problem. National will be trapped into a coalition with David Seymour, certainly with a larger caucus, who will want to make deficit reduction a priority and who has a policy to raise the pension age.

The alternative ensemble to the dour Mr Darcy is full of charming, funny, and considerably more photogenic individuals than the phalanx of grey men representing the status quo. We can understand why Bridget Jones fell, briefly, into the welcoming embrace of the winsome Hugh Grant, if you allow me to continue the analogy.

But this is not a movie. We should remember the past performance of a Labour-led government: rising inflation, increased concerns about crime, falling education attendance and economic malaise.

I prefer the Bridget Jones version of Pride and Prejudice to Elizabeth Bennet’s. The chaotic, shambolic and awkward stumbling towards the obvious choice represents how most of us live and decide, rather than the cool objectivity that only exists in high English literature.

In a matter as serious as government, we should assess performance, not personality. Competence, not charisma. Outcomes, not intentions. Luxon leads an effective government that warrants a second term.....The full article is published HERE

Damien Grant is an Auckland business owner, a member of the Taxpayers’ Union and a regular opinion contributor for Stuff, writing from a libertarian perspective

7 comments:

Anonymous said...

80% of the funding increase for healthcare has gone direct to private providers. This is privatisation by stealth and the voting public can see that if we leave things as they are, we’ll end up like America with the highest cost and least efficient healthcare of any first-world nation.

Isn’t National supposed to be the clever financial management team? What on earth is happening to this country??

Anonymous said...

More nurses per head than the UK or the EU. More doctors per head than the USA!
That’s what’s happening to this country now.

Barend Vlaardingerbroek said...

Q: Which country has the highest per capita number of medical doctors?
A: Cuba.
However, NZ does better on nurses.
Be very, very careful about jumping to any conclusions when comparing countries on simple statistical data.

Barrie Davis said...

Damien, even you ignore the c-word; that is equivalent to Elizabeth Bennet omitting to mention whether Mr. Darcy is good in the sack.
Yes, the economy is important, but so is co-governance and many of us are primarily concerned as to why Christopher Luxon never mentions it. And worse still, neither do his coalition partners.
When we look to the Mother Country, we see something similar happening there. The leaders in both countries are just watching the country of which they are the Prime Minister being taken off them.
Can someone please tell us: What the hell is going on?

Vic Alborn said...

To quote Barrie Davis @ 11:54: "... And worse still, neither do his coalition partners. ...". Clearly you do not spend much time reviewing either NZ First nor ACT policies and record. What an ignorant statement.

Ellen said...

Important point Barrie, but Seymour is very clear that NZ will not have two races in co-governance.

Barrie Davis said...

Yes, I am aware that both ACT and NZ First want the Waitangi Tribunal abolished and a referendum held on the Maori seats. But neither are vocal about it; even David Seymour has gone quite.
Nevertheless, David Seymour, I believe. But what about the other fellow?
For example, will he leave it until just before the next election and then say if we want it we will have to vote him in again?
I want to see a commitment from all three that they will have the necessary referendum and pass the necessary legislation in the first year of the term and have it implemented well prior to the next election to ensure that the Maori Party are gone.
I want a permanent solution to the present problem so that we are not faced with it again, ever. That is asking no more than the possibility we are now facing with the Left writing an entrenched Constitution.
And I would appreciate it if you did not call my statement ignorant.

Post a Comment

Thank you for joining the discussion. Breaking Views welcomes respectful contributions that enrich the debate. Please ensure your comments are not defamatory, derogatory or disruptive. We appreciate your cooperation.