The following column appeared in the NATIONAL BUSINESS REVIEW October 27th 2017. With the support of Winston Peters, Jacinda Ardern had just been installed as Prime Minister.
The Limits of Cleverness versus Capitalism
I have concluded our new prime minister Jacinda Ardern is clever stupid.
She's quick, has good analytical skills and communicates well. There's no doubt she's clever.
But she's stupid on how the world works and lacks thought-through principles and values. She bobs along on feelings and sounding good and thereby perfectly in tune with a media that emotes rather than reports and analyses.
By her own account she grew up Mormon but jumped to socialism, becoming president of the International Union of Socialist Youth. She substituted one whacky religion for another. Her work experience is university and Parliament, first as a Labour Party staffer, then as an MP.
She's driven by belief, not understanding. She can't argue ideas and must dismiss her opponents as uncaring or not yet enlightened. The shortcoming in opposing ideas is not the ideas themselves but the moral deficiency of those expressing them.
When asked if capitalism had failed low-income New Zealanders, the prime minister-designate said: "If you have hundreds of thousands of children living in homes without enough to survive, that's a blatant failure. What else could could you describe it as?"
"Hundreds of thousands of children living in homes without enough to survive." That means "hundreds of thousands of children" dying because of material want. It's nonsense. There would be UN relief missions and international popstars having concerts to aid New Zealand were her claim true.
It isn't.
It's part of the media-manufactured Jacindamania that such rubbish claims are passed over. She cares, that's enough. It's as if her nonsensical hyperbole underscores the extent of her caring. "Yes, she might have been out by a few hundred children, and yes, they're not exactly not surviving, but her heart is in the right place."
The problem of poor and neglected children is not the fault of capitalism but of welfarism. Generations of handouts have robbed too many of any sense of personal responsibility even for the care and upbringing of their own children.
It's perfectly respectable now not to provide for yourself, nor house your family, nor commit in any way to your partner in child-making and to have children without the ability to provide or care or them.
It's not your fault. You're a victim. Capitalism has failed.
Ms Ardern's blinkered, if not blind, view of the world sees her advocating more of the policies causing the very problems concerning her rather than treating the cause.
No facts, no analysis, no experience would shift her view. Her socialism is her religion.
I'm a white, privileged male. I would say all of the above, wouldn't I ? I'm threatened by a female in charge and fear that my greedy exploitation of the poor is at an end. There, I dismissed my argument myself to save her supporters the effort.
Additional remarks by Lindsay Mitchell:
On the eve of the 2026 general election Ardern is no longer a factor.
But Carmel Sepuloni is.
As Minister for Social Development Sepuloni was responsible for scrapping the requirement for sole parent beneficiaries to name fathers; legislating for child support to be paid directly to sole parents as opposed to being kept to offset their benefit; numerous increases to family tax credits and benefit payment rates; reduction in sanctions for not meeting work obligations and introduction of the Best Start payment (now $77 weekly for newborns to age two).
Here's what happened - the population of under 18 year-olds grew by 4.6 percent while the number dependent on welfare grew by 25.7 percent. The increase for sole parent children was even higher at 30.5 percent:

Click to view
If Labour and Sepuloni are returned to government, this time with the influence of the Greens and Te Pati Maori, how much worse will these numbers get?
I have concluded our new prime minister Jacinda Ardern is clever stupid.
She's quick, has good analytical skills and communicates well. There's no doubt she's clever.
But she's stupid on how the world works and lacks thought-through principles and values. She bobs along on feelings and sounding good and thereby perfectly in tune with a media that emotes rather than reports and analyses.
By her own account she grew up Mormon but jumped to socialism, becoming president of the International Union of Socialist Youth. She substituted one whacky religion for another. Her work experience is university and Parliament, first as a Labour Party staffer, then as an MP.
She's driven by belief, not understanding. She can't argue ideas and must dismiss her opponents as uncaring or not yet enlightened. The shortcoming in opposing ideas is not the ideas themselves but the moral deficiency of those expressing them.
When asked if capitalism had failed low-income New Zealanders, the prime minister-designate said: "If you have hundreds of thousands of children living in homes without enough to survive, that's a blatant failure. What else could could you describe it as?"
"Hundreds of thousands of children living in homes without enough to survive." That means "hundreds of thousands of children" dying because of material want. It's nonsense. There would be UN relief missions and international popstars having concerts to aid New Zealand were her claim true.
It isn't.
It's part of the media-manufactured Jacindamania that such rubbish claims are passed over. She cares, that's enough. It's as if her nonsensical hyperbole underscores the extent of her caring. "Yes, she might have been out by a few hundred children, and yes, they're not exactly not surviving, but her heart is in the right place."
The problem of poor and neglected children is not the fault of capitalism but of welfarism. Generations of handouts have robbed too many of any sense of personal responsibility even for the care and upbringing of their own children.
It's perfectly respectable now not to provide for yourself, nor house your family, nor commit in any way to your partner in child-making and to have children without the ability to provide or care or them.
It's not your fault. You're a victim. Capitalism has failed.
Ms Ardern's blinkered, if not blind, view of the world sees her advocating more of the policies causing the very problems concerning her rather than treating the cause.
No facts, no analysis, no experience would shift her view. Her socialism is her religion.
I'm a white, privileged male. I would say all of the above, wouldn't I ? I'm threatened by a female in charge and fear that my greedy exploitation of the poor is at an end. There, I dismissed my argument myself to save her supporters the effort.
Additional remarks by Lindsay Mitchell:
On the eve of the 2026 general election Ardern is no longer a factor.
But Carmel Sepuloni is.
As Minister for Social Development Sepuloni was responsible for scrapping the requirement for sole parent beneficiaries to name fathers; legislating for child support to be paid directly to sole parents as opposed to being kept to offset their benefit; numerous increases to family tax credits and benefit payment rates; reduction in sanctions for not meeting work obligations and introduction of the Best Start payment (now $77 weekly for newborns to age two).
Here's what happened - the population of under 18 year-olds grew by 4.6 percent while the number dependent on welfare grew by 25.7 percent. The increase for sole parent children was even higher at 30.5 percent:

Click to view
If Labour and Sepuloni are returned to government, this time with the influence of the Greens and Te Pati Maori, how much worse will these numbers get?
Rodney Hide is former ACT Party leader, and Minister in the National-ACT Government from 2008 to 2011. This article was first published HERE

7 comments:
What a great analysis Rodney. I presume it was you who wrote the 2027 article?
What is socialist countries' attitude towards solo motherhood (meaning here never-married mothers)?
There is no single, simple answer to this. Traditionally, the socialist State has been disapproving of solo motherhood; the North Korean state continues to severely penalise unwed mothers and their progeny. Communist China did so for a long time but now extends full recognition and associated rights to illegitimate children. The State regards itself as the 'absent parent' and ensures that the mother 'educates' her child(ren) properly about social and political matters.
Cuba has a system that is very close to NZ's - solo motherhood is fine, the State is very supportive, and there is no pressure brought to bear on fathers.
I would find it difficult to present a case of, "This is how socialism deals with unwed women having children" because there does not appear to be "a socialist way" of doing so.
There doesn’t need to be a socialist way of doing this, just a NZ socialist way, that’s enough.
The nub of this NBR (Rodney Hide?) article is the proposition that "the problem of poor and neglected children is not the fault of capitalism but welfarism." At least this identifies the central question, but it gives a totally wrong answer.
Hide's argument is like saying that a patient died of cancer, but the cause of death was not the disease but the chemotherapy used to treat it. Poverty came first, "welfarism" was a response to it. It is true that the attempted solution can, like chemotherapy, can have debilitating side effects. A life of chronic dependency on welfare benefits is no life at all, but it is a consequence, not a root cause of the problem. The cause is ultimately unemployment.
Society can only condemn welfare beneficiaries only if it offers them meaningful and decently-paid employment and they turn it down. Is that the case in New Zealand today? Ask the people of Raetihi, Murupara, Kawerau or Tokoroa who had jobs they loved, but saw them disappear and their communities devastated when the mills closed. Or the one thousand people in West Auckland last week who applied for one meat packers job advertised by a butcher.
I'm aware of a female relative of friends, who raised her children (different fathers) on welfare, and apparently owns her home. She could have worked, but chose not to. Her children are now following in her footsteps. There are jobs, if you look hard enough, but often the pay is comparable to staying on the benefit.
Charity workers in slums in Brazil focus on educating young women, so becoming solo mothers is less likely. By education , I mean courses that lead to employment .We have had in NZ a rotten education system that selectively discriminated against the most vulnerable .
Looking after your cute baby instead of a job may be seductive but caring for that same 'baby' as a stroppy teenager without a father is not .
Being dependent on the state for welfare should be seen as a highly undesirable option . It is parasitic and selfish and not being responsible for your own fate unless you are genuinely handicapped.
The welfare system is dependent on a strong workforce, but with our schools, entrenched in an ideology not promoting a work ethic, we can't expect students to develop this.
In the 1950s being on welfare was a disgrace , almost like being a criminal. That is now not so. Rather it is seen as an entitlement . .
Cultural Christianity has strong words about those who will not work. Back to the puritan work ethic needed ?And Guilt ? O dear , so very un - modern .
A life of chronic welfare dependancy is not only unemployment, but serious, and rampant mishandling and abuse of contraception.
Post a Comment
Thank you for joining the discussion. Breaking Views welcomes respectful contributions that enrich the debate. Please ensure your comments are not defamatory, derogatory or disruptive. We appreciate your cooperation.