Friday, April 15, 2022

Richard Prebble: We need to restore low inflation as the Reserve Bank’s sole remit

The Reserve Bank’s .5% increase in interest rates will have little impact on inflation. Inflation is over 7%. The real interest rate gap between the OCR and inflation is possibly 6%. A half a per cent rise is not going to reduce baked in inflationary expectations.

The half a per cent rise is an attempt to restore the Bank’s shattered reputation. The Bank’s wildly optimistic forecasts and its compromised independence have fatally damaged the Bank’s credibility.

Prior to the last election the bank sought and received an independence compromising taxpayer guarantee from the Finance Minister. Grant Robertson agreed to cover any losses from the bank continuing to print a billion dollars a week.

The economy had bounced back from lockdown. There was no economic justification for the pre-election credit boom. This columnist said so at the time and predicted it would be inflationary.

If printing money was so risky the bank required a taxpayer guarantee then it was too risky for the country.

The printed money is near zero interest debt. The loss in the value of the bonds that the taxpayer has guaranteed to date is over $7b and increasing fast.

Grant Robertson’s taxpayer’s guarantee is the most expensive ever given by a finance minister. Already the cost of the guarantee is a third of the annual spend on Education.

The Governor and Board cannot re-gain credibility. Having missed their inflation target by over two hundred percent they should all be dismissed. They won’t be. Low inflation has never been a target of this Labour government.

Ministers who were at kindergarten when inflation ravaged New Zealand have no conception of inflation’s damage. Inflation destroys the living standards of the very people Labour claims to represent.

Inflation once it is established is extremely difficult to tame. We need to recall how New Zealand did finally tame inflation.

On 6 February this year the architect of the policy died. His policy gave us 30 years of low inflation. Most have never heard of him, Peter Neilson.

The Hon Peter Neilson was the Labour MP for Miramar. Peter was a qualified economist. Today’s Labour party would never select him.

Roger Douglas made Peter his Associate Minister of Finance. Roger believed the answer to combating inflation was to give the Reserve Bank a greater role. Peter was given the task of developing the policy.

The civil service hates associate ministers. The departments cannot bury associate ministers in paper work. Associate ministers have time to think. The fourth Labour government had a number of very capable associate ministers who not only had time to think but also the capacity to think.

I was greatly assisted by Bill Jeffries on port reform. Mike Moore’s associate was Fran Wilde. The late Trevor de Cleene steered the tax reforms through parliament. David Butcher, another economist, helped wean agriculture off subsidies addressing dozens of farmer meetings. These Associate Ministers had short parliamentary careers only because they represented marginal seats.

Peter Neilson’s work was perhaps the most important. Shortly before he died Peter sent me drafts of his memoirs. I hope someone will one day edit and publish his papers.

Peter writes when he received his commission from Roger he requested every paper the Treasury and Reserve Bank had written on inflation. He read them all. He developed his policy idea to give the Reserve Bank independence and a single remit, maintaining low inflation.

Peter then visited the world’s central Banks, the Bank of England, the Federal Reserve and the Bank of Canada and held meetings with some of the world’s leading economists.

He writes the Central Banks and economists said he was on the right track. Their only question was how a small county like New Zealand could be the policy leader on Central Bank reform?

The credit for taming inflation is rightly attributed to Sir Roger Douglas, Ruth Richardson and Dr. Don Brash. We should also give credit to Peter Neilson’s policy work.

Peter writes:

“Operating independence could be granted by law but would only be maintained if the regime delivered sustained lower inflation

Credibility with delivering lower inflation could not just be claimed it had to delivered over years if not decades

Credibility required a Governor that was prepared to resign if his or her delivery was being undermined by the politicians and

The Governor needed to be actively building a community consensus for sustainable lower inflation”.

Peter realized that sustained low inflation required bi-partisan support. After interviewing Dr. Don Brash he recommended the former National Party candidate be appointed Governor.

It is disturbing to reflect how far New Zealand has drifted from Peter Neilson’s policy.

We have the highest inflation in 30 years. Credibility is zero. The Governor himself compromised the Bank’s independence. This Governor gives speeches on every subject except the importance of low inflation.

Appointing a new governor and board will not be enough to restore sustained low inflation.

Today’s inflation is also a legacy of Winston Peters’ insistence that the Reserve Bank’s remit be changed to include “sustained employment”. Having a dual remit means the Reserve Bank has an excuse for failing to tame inflation.

Last election not one party campaigned to restore low inflation as the Reserve Bank’s sole remit. It is vital both National and ACT make it an election pledge.

At least 20 countries have copied New Zealand’s Central Bank reform. We have abandoned it.

We are about to discover the truth of Ludwig Von Mises prediction: “There is no means of avoiding the final collapse of a boom brought about by credit expansion.”

Richard Prebble CBE is a former member of the New Zealand Parliament. Initially a member of the Labour Party, he joined the newly formed ACT New Zealand party under Roger Douglas in 1996, becoming its leader from 1996 to 2004. This article was first published HERE.


Charles said...

This lamentable pack of incompetents would be quite incapable of understanding any of this. I doubt that they have any ability in finance. My expenses as a retiree will increase over a thousand dollars this year, power, 'phone and petrol just being the start. Rates have increased and food now requires a bank overdraft to purchase. I am now planning on using my silly covid mask to rob the bank. Unfortunately it is seldom open so even this creates problems!

Dave said...

Prebble hits the nail on the head. Shame so few people understand him.

His Labour Govt rescued 4 million Kiwis from the brink of economic collapse, caused by a disastrous Muldoon Govt.

Ironically, it is going to take a National Government to clean up the absolute shambles left by the current Labour Govt.

Incompetence is not partisian.

Shane C said...

As usual, Mr Prebble is on the money - unlike anyone serving us currently. Not only do they not have the intellectual horsepower to understand what's said, they've totally forgotten what they're supposed to be doing, i.e. serve the people of NZ first and foremost.
That doesn't mean constantly announcing announcements that amount to nothing, nor does it mean consistently lying to the people about things that matter most. While the PM may want this to become a police / communist island, she was voted in to uphold democratic principles!!